Navigating Volatility: Insider-Backed Small Caps Poised to Outperform in a Tumultuous Market

Geopolitical tensions, rising interest rates, and sector-specific headwinds have created a fertile environment for contrarian investors. Amid this uncertainty, two small-cap stocks—Clarkson PLC (LSE:CKN) and VersaBank (TSX:VBNK)—stand out for their strategic insider buying activity, signaling confidence in their long-term prospects. These companies exemplify how insider purchases can act as a contrarian indicator, offering entry points into undervalued assets poised to rebound as macro risks subside.

---

### The Contrarian Play: Insider Activity as a Sentiment Gauge
In volatile markets, institutional investors often retreat, leaving small caps vulnerable to sentiment-driven sell-offs. Yet, insider buying—particularly by executives with significant personal capital at stake—can reveal a hidden narrative. When insiders purchase shares at depressed prices, it suggests they see value where the broader market does not. Both Clarkson and VersaBank have seen notable insider activity in recent months, despite sector-specific challenges.

---

### Clarkson PLC (LSE:CKN): Insider Buoyancy in a Volatile Shipping Sector

Clarkson, a leading global shipping services provider, has faced headwinds including a projected 2% annual decline in earnings over the next three years and reliance on external borrowing. Yet, key insiders have been aggressive buyers:
- Laurence David Hollingworth, a director, purchased 236,232 shares (a 67% stake increase) on May 1, 2025, investing £178,000.
- Constantin Cotzias added 86,774 shares in May, including a £1.7m purchase on May 20 at £47.53 per share.

These buys contrast with earlier April sales by other executives, highlighting a divergence in sentiment. While the stock trades at a PE ratio of 12.1x, below its five-year average, insiders' actions suggest they believe the company's strategic advantages—such as its dominant broking division and diversified services—will outlast cyclical pressures.



Why it's undervalued: The shipping sector's cyclical nature has depressed valuations, but Clarkson's $1.31bn market cap and 13.06% net income margin (2023) underscore operational strength. As geopolitical risks ease and demand for shipping rebounds, insiders' purchases could mark a bottom.

---

### VersaBank (TSX:VBNK): Insider Optimism Despite Earnings Misses

VersaBank, a Canadian digital bank, has seen its stock plummet 34.4% over three months amid an earnings miss (Q2 EPS of $0.18 vs. estimates of $0.21). Yet, insiders have been relentless buyers:
- Patrick George, a director, executed 123,828 shares in June at ~$10.50, following a $1.25m purchase in April.
- Richard H.L. Jankura (Director) and Francis J.C. Newbould (Director) added shares at prices reflecting double-digit discounts to recent highs.

The $503,600 in insider purchases over 90 days (vs. zero sales) contrast starkly with the stock's decline, suggesting executives see long-term value in its digital banking model and growth opportunities.



Why it's undervalued: VersaBank trades at a price-to-book ratio of 1.0x, below peers like Toronto-Dominion Bank (1.6x). Its $529m in revenue (broking division) and expansion into fintech solutions position it to capitalize on rising digital adoption. While near-term earnings volatility persists, insider confidence hints at a rebound as macro stability returns.

---

### The Contrarian Case: Why These Stocks Could Outperform
1. Undervalued Metrics: Both companies trade at discounts to historical averages, offering a margin of safety.
2. Sector-Specific Resilience:
- Clarkson benefits from long-term shipping demand tied to global trade.
- VersaBank's digital focus aligns with secular trends in banking innovation.
3. Insider Credibility: Executives with skin in the game reduce agency risk, signaling alignment between ownership and strategy.

---

### Investment Advice: A Contrarian's Checklist
- Entry Point: Wait for further dips or positive catalysts, such as Clarkson's Q3 earnings or VersaBank's upcoming earnings report (Jun 3, 2025).
- Risk Management: Allocate small positions, with stops below recent lows.
- Long-Term Horizon: These plays require patience; geopolitical risks could linger into 2026.



---

### Conclusion: Betting on Conviction
In an era of geopolitical flux and market skittishness, insider buying activity serves as a compass for contrarian investors. Companies like Clarkson and VersaBank—backed by executives willing to commit personal capital—offer asymmetric risk/reward opportunities. While risks remain, their fundamentals and insider confidence suggest they could emerge as winners when the fog of uncertainty lifts.

Invest with discipline, but bet on those who are already in the trenches.

---
Disclaimer: Past performance does not guarantee future results. Conduct thorough due diligence before making investment decisions.