AI Avatar Rejected in Courtroom, Judges Cite Protocol Concerns

A man recently attempted to use an AI-generated avatar to present his argument in a courtroom, marking a notable instance of artificial intelligence being utilized in a legal setting. The incident occurred on March 26, 2025, during a live stream video hosted on the YouTube channel of the Appellate Division of the First Judicial Department of the Supreme Court. The avatar, appearing on a video screen set up in the courtroom, was used by the plaintiff who believed it would effectively deliver his legal arguments. However, the judges were not receptive to this innovative approach. The panel of judges rebuked the man for his unconventional method, highlighting the challenges and limitations of integrating AI technology into traditional judicial processes.

The use of an AI avatar in such a formal legal environment underscores the evolving role of technology in facilitating legal discourse and decision-making. While the integration of AI in judicial processes has the potential to transform traditional courtroom procedures, this incident serves as a reminder of the importance of adhering to established legal protocols. The judges' reaction indicates that while technology can enhance certain aspects of legal proceedings, it must be used judiciously and in accordance with the rules and expectations of the court.

The man, who did not have a lawyer representing him in the lawsuit, felt that the AI avatar would be able to deliver his arguments more effectively. However, the court made a special accommodation for the avatar but was not properly convinced by the presentation. This incident raises questions about the ethical and practical implications of using AI in legal settings. While AI has the potential to streamline processes and provide new tools for legal professionals, it also presents challenges related to authenticity, reliability, and the human element of legal proceedings.

The judges' scolding of the man highlights the need for a balanced approach to integrating AI into the judicial system. While technology can offer new possibilities for legal discourse, it must be used in a way that respects the traditions and principles of the legal system. The incident serves as a cautionary tale for those considering the use of AI in legal settings, emphasizing the importance of understanding the limitations and potential pitfalls of this technology. As AI continues to evolve, it will be crucial for legal professionals and judges to navigate these challenges and ensure that technology is used in a way that enhances, rather than hinders, the administration of justice.