A Year of Gensler’s Crypto-Era Texts Wiped by Systemic IT Failures

A recent report from the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission’s Office of Inspector General (OIG) has revealed that “avoidable errors” within the SEC’s IT department led to the permanent loss of nearly a year’s worth of text messages from former Chair Gary Gensler’s government-issued mobile device. The messages, which disappeared between October 2022 and September 2023, coincided with a period of heightened regulatory activity in the cryptocurrency sector. The OIG attributed the loss to a poorly understood and automated IT policy that triggered an enterprise-wide wipe of Gensler’s device, compounding the issue with a lack of proper backups, ignored system alerts, and unaddressed vendor software flaws [1]. As a result, the SEC could not determine why Gensler’s device ceased to communicate with its mobile device management system [2].

The report highlighted that the lost messages included critical discussions related to the SEC’s enforcement actions against crypto companies and their founders. This data gap may obscure details about how and when the SEC pursued cases during a pivotal period in the crypto market. Investigators were able to recover approximately 1,500 messages from Gensler’s colleagues and other sources, finding that around 38% of the recovered texts were mission-related, involving senior staff in matters such as decisions on when to file enforcement actions against certain crypto platforms and their founders [3]. The loss of these messages has raised concerns about transparency and accountability in the agency’s decision-making processes, particularly as key details of regulatory strategies may now be inaccessible to courts, Congress, and the public.

In response to the findings, the SEC has taken several corrective measures, including disabling text messaging on most government-issued devices, notifying the National Archives and Records Administration of the lost records, and implementing new training protocols for senior officials on recordkeeping. Additionally, the agency has begun improving its backup practices for senior officials' devices [4]. The OIG also noted that the loss of these messages may impact the SEC’s ability to respond to certain Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) requests, underscoring the broader implications for public transparency. The SEC has previously emphasized the importance of recordkeeping, with Gensler himself warning financial institutions about the trust implications of failing to maintain proper records [5].

The timing of the lost messages—during a period marked by major developments in the crypto space—has added to the scrutiny. The period included the collapse of FTX, regulatory challenges around the Grayscale spot Bitcoin (BTC) ETF, and a surge in enforcement actions against crypto firms. Gensler’s tenure was also characterized by a regulatory strategy that critics have described as contradictory, particularly his “come in and get registered” stance, which led to a wave of enforcement actions against companies that attempted to comply with the SEC’s demands [6]. The OIG report does not indicate that any intentional misconduct occurred, but it does highlight systemic vulnerabilities in the SEC’s IT infrastructure and data management protocols.

Industry observers have expressed concern over the implications of the lost messages. Nate Geraci, president of NovaDius Wealth Management, noted that the period in question was one of intense regulatory and market activity, which raises questions about the transparency of the SEC’s decision-making process. Meanwhile, Custodia Bank founder Caitlin Long quipped that the situation resembles a “mysterious ‘boating accident’” for Gensler’s communications [7]. The loss of these records, while not directly linked to any specific enforcement action, may hinder future investigations or legal proceedings that rely on a complete record of internal communications. As the SEC moves forward with reforms, the incident serves as a case study in the importance of robust data governance and oversight in regulatory institutions.

Source:

[1] SEC Report Faults Errors For Loss Of Gensler's Texts (https://cointelegraph.com/news/avoidable-errors-led-to-the-loss-of-gary-gensler-text-messages-sec)