Tompkins Financial: A Resilient Dividend Champion in a High-Rate World

In an era of persistent high interest rates, income investors face a daunting challenge: finding companies that can sustain dividend growth while navigating the financial pressures of a tightening monetary environment. Tompkins Financial Corporation (TMP) stands out as a compelling candidate. With a 10-year average dividend growth rate of 4.05% and a track record of adapting to shifting interest rate dynamics, the company has demonstrated resilience. But can this performance endure in 2025 and beyond?

Earnings Momentum: The Engine Behind Dividend Growth

Tompkins Financial's second-quarter 2025 earnings report underscores its ability to thrive in a high-rate environment. Diluted earnings per share (EPS) surged 36.4% year-over-year to $1.50, driven by a 35-basis-point expansion in net interest margin (NIM) to 3.08%. This improvement reflects strategic adjustments: average loan balances grew 7.8% compared to the prior year, while funding costs dropped 20 basis points. The company's net interest income climbed 18% year-over-year to $60.1 million, a testament to its disciplined balance sheet management.

The key to Tompkins' success lies in its ability to balance loan growth with cost control. Average loans increased by $410.8 million in 2024, with commercial real estate and industrial portfolios leading the charge. Meanwhile, the average cost of interest-bearing liabilities fell to 2.44%, a 20-basis-point decline from the same period in 2024. This dual strategy—boosting revenue while trimming costs—has created a buffer against rate volatility.

Interest Rate Risk Management: A Strategic Edge

High-rate environments test even the most seasoned banks. Tompkins, however, has mitigated risk through proactive hedging and a diversified funding structure. As of June 30, 2025, the company's interest rate spread widened to 2.34%, up from 1.91% in 2024, driven by higher asset yields and lower liability costs. Its funding mix includes $6.7 billion in deposits, with noninterest-bearing accounts accounting for 28% of total deposits, reducing reliance on costly time deposits.

The company's liquidity position further bolsters its resilience. With $1.5 billion in ready access to wholesale funding sources—including the Federal Reserve's Discount Window and the Federal Home Loan Bank—Tompkins can weather short-term liquidity shocks. Capital ratios remain robust, with Tier 1 capital at 9.36% of average assets, well above regulatory thresholds.

Dividend Sustainability: A Balancing Act

Tompkins' dividend growth has not been linear. After a 11.11% jump in 2021–2022, the company paused growth in 2022–2023 and 2023–2024. However, a modest 0.83% increase in 2024–2025 suggests a cautious but sustainable approach. The current dividend yield of 2.4% (as of July 19, 2025) is attractive, but investors must assess the payout ratio. With 2025 earnings projected to exceed $5.00 per share, the payout ratio remains below 50%, leaving ample room for future increases.

Historically, Tompkins has demonstrated strong post-ex-dividend performance. Over the past three years, the stock has shown a 71.43% win rate within three trading days of ex-dividend dates, with 64.29% of instances showing positive returns over 10 days and 57.14% over 30 days. These patterns suggest that the stock has historically rewarded investors with price appreciation following dividend distributions. The company's average dividend yield during this period has been 3.98%, underscoring its role as a reliable income source.

The company's recent stock repurchase program—authorizing $400,000 shares—also signals confidence in its capital structure. By returning capital to shareholders through both dividends and buybacks, Tompkins reinforces its commitment to long-term value creation.

Risks and Opportunities

While Tompkins has navigated high rates adeptly, challenges remain. Rising funding costs could pressure margins if the Federal Reserve tightens further. Additionally, nonperforming assets, though declining, still stand at 0.63% of total assets, requiring vigilance.

Yet the company's strengths outweigh these risks. Its net interest margin is primed to benefit from sticky loan rates and a gradual decline in deposit costs. With loan growth accelerating and fee-based services rising 4.5% year-over-year, Tompkins is well-positioned to sustain earnings growth.

Investment Thesis

For income-focused investors, Tompkins Financial offers a rare combination of defensive qualities and growth potential. Its disciplined approach to interest rate risk, robust capital ratios, and strategic loan growth provide a foundation for consistent dividend payments. While the payout has seen pauses, the underlying financials remain strong, and the 2025 dividend hike hints at a return to growth.

Recommendation: Investors seeking a high-quality income stock in a high-rate world should consider adding Tompkins to their portfolios. With a yield above 2%, a sustainable payout ratio, and a business model built for resilience, the company represents a compelling long-term hold. However, monitor interest rate trends and asset quality metrics to ensure continued stability.

In a market where many dividend stocks falter under rate stress, Tompkins Financial has proven its mettle. For those who prioritize durability and disciplined growth, the stock is a standout choice.
"""