Tesla's Stock Plunge Signals Deeper Vulnerabilities: Why the Musk-Trump Fallout Matters

Henry RiversThursday, Jun 5, 2025 9:31 pm ET
78min read

The bitter public feud between Elon Musk and Donald Trump in June 2025 triggered a historic 14% drop in Tesla's stock price, erasing $151 billion in market value—the largest single-day loss since March 2020. But this plunge is more than a temporary blip. It exposes deeper vulnerabilities in Tesla's valuation, including weak electric vehicle (EV) sales, regulatory headwinds, and Musk's increasingly risky political entanglements.

The Immediate Market Reaction: Options Markets Reflect Controlled Panic

Tesla's stock collapse on June 5 was exacerbated by real-time social media exchanges between Musk and Trump. Musk accused Trump's tax bill of being a “disgusting abomination,” while Trump retaliated, threatening to cancel federal contracts with Musk's companies. The stock's 14% drop was amplified by options market dynamics:

  • Put Options Surge: The Jun-06-25 315 and 330 put options saw combined trading of over 68,000 contracts, with retail investors dominating 77%-81% of volume.
  • Implied Volatility (IV) Trends: Despite the sharp decline, IV for these puts fell slightly (from 57.1% to 52.1% for the 315 strike) or remained subdued, suggesting traders viewed the drop as a manageable risk rather than a panic sell-off.

Underlying Issues: Erosion of Tesla's Growth Engine

The Musk-Trump clash is a symptom of a broader crisis for Tesla:

  1. Slumping EV Demand:
  2. Tesla's sales dropped 45% in the U.K. and 36% in Germany in early 2025, as competition from Chinese brands like BYD and domestic rivals like Ford's Mustang Mach-E intensified.
  3. U.S. sales are also weakening, with Tesla's Q1 2025 net income down 71% year-over-year.

  4. Regulatory and Policy Risks:

  5. The U.S. tax bill Musk criticized includes cuts to EV tax credits, which could reduce demand. Meanwhile, California's proposed “pollution fee” for older EVs could hit Tesla's used-car sales.
  6. Musk's alignment with Trump's administration has already strained relationships in Europe, where regulators are scrutinizing Tesla's Autopilot safety claims.

  7. Brand Decline:

  8. Tesla's once-legendary brand luster is fading. A 2025 J.D. Power survey ranked the Model S at the bottom of luxury EVs for owner satisfaction, citing software glitches and poor service.

Musk's Political Entanglements: A Threat to Subsidies and Contracts

Musk's feud with Trump is more than a personality clash—it jeopardizes Tesla's access to critical government support:

  • Federal Contracts: Trump threatened to cancel $22.5 billion in SpaceX and contracts, a move that could derail Tesla's Cybertruck production or SpaceX's Starlink expansion.
  • EV Subsidies: Musk's vocal opposition to Trump's bill risks alienating lawmakers who previously backed EV incentives. JPMorgan analysts estimate Tesla could lose $1.2 billion in annual profits if subsidies are cut.
  • Reputational Damage: Musk's combative social media tactics—such as accusing Trump of hiding Epstein-related files—undermine his credibility with policymakers and investors.

Technical Analysis: Overvalued, Oversold, or Both?

Tesla's valuation remains a puzzle. The stock trades at 140x projected 2025 earnings—a P/E ratio far above peers like Ford (8.3x) or BYD (43x). Analysts like Wedbush's Dan Ives have downgraded Tesla to “underperform,” citing “execution risks” and a “commodity price war” in EVs.

The Bottom Line: Avoid Tesla Until Risks Subside

Investors should steer clear of Tesla until three conditions are met:

  1. Policy Clarity: A resolution to the Musk-Trump feud and a clear path for EV subsidies.
  2. Sales Stabilization: Evidence of demand recovery in key markets, particularly in Europe and China.
  3. Valuation Alignment: A significant correction to Tesla's P/E ratio to reflect its risk profile and competitive landscape.

Until then, Tesla's stock remains a bet on Musk's ability to navigate political storms and revive flagging sales—a gamble with too little upside and too much downside.

Investment Recommendation: Avoid Tesla (TSLA) until regulatory risks ease and fundamentals stabilize. Consider shorting or selling puts if exposure is unavoidable.

In the words of one analyst: “This isn't a stock to hold through a knife fight.” The Musk-Trump clash is just the opening salvo.

Comments



Add a public comment...
No comments

No comments yet

Disclaimer: The news articles available on this platform are generated in whole or in part by artificial intelligence and may not have been reviewed or fact checked by human editors. While we make reasonable efforts to ensure the quality and accuracy of the content, we make no representations or warranties, express or implied, as to the truthfulness, reliability, completeness, or timeliness of any information provided. It is your sole responsibility to independently verify any facts, statements, or claims prior to acting upon them. Ainvest Fintech Inc expressly disclaims all liability for any loss, damage, or harm arising from the use of or reliance on AI-generated content, including but not limited to direct, indirect, incidental, or consequential damages.