Tesla's Rally: Is Cramer's Bullish Call Finally Paying Off?

The markets have long oscillated between skepticism and adoration for
, Inc. (TSLA), but Jim Cramer's repeated bullish calls in 2025 have reignited debates about whether the stock's fundamentals can sustain its valuation. As of May 2025, the question demands scrutiny: Is Cramer's optimism justified, or is Tesla's rally a fleeting illusion? Let's dissect the data.
Valuation Sustainability: A Delicate Balance
Tesla's market cap of $797.9 billion as of early 2025 hinges on its dual identity as an automotive and AI powerhouse. While automotive revenue dipped 8% in Q4 2024, its energy division surged 113%—a critical shift toward diversified profitability. Cramer has framed Tesla as an “AI ETF,” betting that its advancements in autonomous driving and robotics will justify its premium valuation.
But the skeptics argue: Can Tesla's price-to-sales ratio (2.1x) and price-to-earnings (45x) sustain when competitors like Ford and GM are trading at 0.5x and 5x, respectively?
Competitive Advantages: Beyond the Road
Tesla's moats extend beyond its vehicles. Its energy storage business, now a $6 billion division, is a cash engine in a carbon-conscious world. Meanwhile, its Dojo supercomputers and FSD (Full Self-Driving) software are being leveraged as tools for monetization. Cramer highlights these strengths: “Tesla isn't just a car company—it's a tech disruptor with wheels.”
The Cybertruck, set for mass production in 2025, embodies this duality. Its rugged design and AI-enabled features have created a cult following, with pre-orders exceeding 2 million. Yet, production delays and Musk's political distractions (e.g., his role in the Department of Government Efficiency) have clouded execution.
Technical and Analyst Backing: A Rally in the Making?
Cramer's recent alignment with chartist Larry Williams adds a tactical layer to his bullish thesis. Williams' valuation model, which deemed Tesla undervalued in late April / early May, aligns with seasonal patterns showing an 80% historical rally rate post-earnings. Tesla's 7.6% rebound on April 22—its worst day since 2020—was interpreted by Cramer as a “bottoming” signal.
Analysts are cautiously optimistic. While Goldman Sachs and Truist downgraded to “Hold” due to valuation risks, Piper Sandler and Wedbush maintained “Buy” ratings with lowered targets, citing energy division growth. Crucially, Wedbush's Dan Ives upgraded Tesla to $500 in May, citing its AI leadership and Cybercab potential. Even bears like Ronald Jewsikow (who rated it “Sell”) admit Tesla's stock could rebound if Musk refocuses—a sign that the narrative remains fluid.
The Cramer Call: Bulls vs. Reality
Cramer's February 2025 recommendation to “start your electric engines” was prescient in hindsight. Since then, Tesla's stock has oscillated between $220 and $250, but key catalysts loom:
1. June Buying Window: Williams' “mid-June pullback” could offer an entry point, with Cramer emphasizing historical buying patterns.
2. 2026 Cybercab Launch: A successful rollout would solidify Tesla's lead in autonomous vehicles, a $1.5 trillion market by 2030.
3. Musk's Focus: If Musk's political ventures (like the Department of Government Efficiency) don't distract from operations, execution risks diminish.
The May Monthly Meeting saw Cramer reiterate Tesla's place in his “Investing Club” portfolio, calling it a “decade-defining play.” For investors, the question is: Can Tesla's fundamentals outrun its valuation skeptics?
Final Verdict: A Buy With Eyes Open
As of May 2025, Cramer's bullish stance holds water—but with caveats. Tesla's valuation is precarious without execution on Cybercab and FSD, yet its energy division and AI bets provide a safety net. Technical indicators suggest a rally is possible, but investors must monitor Musk's focus and delivery metrics closely.
Investors: Tesla's future is a blend of risk and reward. The stock's valuation may wobble, but its innovations and Cramer's technical insights suggest this is no ordinary EV play. Act swiftly—markets rarely wait for the hesitant.
Comments
No comments yet