Target's Circle 360: How Markup-Free Delivery Is Rewriting Retail Economics


In an era where
Prime and Walmart+ dominate the retail subscription landscape, Target is engineering a bold countermove. By dismantling the markup barriers that have long plagued third-party delivery, the retailer’s Circle 360 ecosystem has quietly become a high-margin, defensible moat—one that could redefine customer loyalty economics. For investors, this is a story of network effects, margin expansion, and underestimated scalability, positioning Target (TGT) as a buy at current levels. Let’s unpack why.The Markup-Free Revolution: A Disruptive Pricing Play
Target’s elimination of product markups on Shipt’s 100+ retailers—a move effective since May 2025—is not just a tactical adjustment. It’s a strategic masterstroke that undercuts competitors’ business models. Unlike Amazon, which charges delivery fees or premium prices for third-party items, or Walmart+, which limits free delivery to $35+ orders, Circle 360 members pay only the retailer’s listed price for same-day delivery. The savings are tangible: Target estimates members save $20+ per order on average, with alcohol and select items as minor exceptions.
While TGT’s stock lingers at $220—a 20% discount to its 2023 high—the market has yet to price in the full impact of this strategy. The Circle 360 ecosystem is a high-margin flywheel: no markup fees mean higher customer retention, which drives cross-retailer transactions, and the data from those transactions strengthens Target’s negotiating power with partners. This isn’t just a discount play—it’s a digital mall where Target becomes the gateway to local and national retail.
Network Effects: The "Digital Mall" Model Scales
Target’s ecosystem now spans over 100 retailers, including regional grocers like Hy-Vee and Lowe’s hardware stores, creating a geographically sticky network. Members aren’t just buying from Target—they’re consolidating their entire shopping errands into one app. The $49/year discount for Target Circle Card holders (cutting the annual fee to $49) and the $20 first-order credit further grease the skids for subscriptions.
Crucially, this isn’t a zero-sum game. Partner retailers gain access to Target’s 200M+ customer base, while Target captures transaction data to refine its inventory and loyalty programs. The result? A virtuous cycle: more retailers join the Shipt network, more customers subscribe to Circle 360, and more data fuels Target’s supply chain and pricing agility.
Already, Circle 360’s $99/year fee (or $10.99/month) is outpacing rival subscriptions. With 40% of U.S. households lacking a membership to Amazon, Walmart+, or Target, there’s ample room to grow. The student tier ($4.99/month) alone could lock in Gen Z for decades—a demographic rivals are struggling to retain.
Margin Expansion: The Hidden Profit Lever
Critics argue that eliminating markups erodes revenue, but they’re missing the bigger picture. The Circle 360 ecosystem reduces customer churn, increases order frequency, and boosts basket sizes—all at higher gross margins. For example, a member ordering groceries from Hy-Vee and dog food from PetSmart via Target’s app generates two transactions for Target (the order placement and Shipt delivery fee), not just one.
Moreover, the 5% discount for Target Circle Mastercard holders (excluding markups) adds a financial services layer to the model. As more customers link their cards to Circle 360 accounts, interchange fees and interest revenue flow into Target’s coffers. The synergies are compounding:
- 2024 pilot markets saw 30% higher order volumes and 15% larger baskets after markup elimination.
- Shipt’s personal shoppers—who handle 98% of deliveries—maintain a 99% customer satisfaction rate, ensuring retention.
Target’s gross margin has already expanded to 29% in 2025, outpacing Walmart’s 25% and Amazon’s 14%. With Circle 360’s scalability, this metric could climb further, unlocking a valuation rerating.
The Moat Widens: Why Amazon Can’t Compete
Amazon’s dominance in delivery logistics is legendary, but Target’s ecosystem plays a different game. By outsourcing delivery to Shipt’s personal shoppers (while retaining ownership of the customer relationship), Target avoids the costly fixed-cost trap of self-operated warehouses. Meanwhile, Walmart+’s reliance on in-store pickup and limited third-party access leaves it exposed to Circle 360’s convenience.
The "digital mall" model also shields Target from price wars. Members aren’t just paying for delivery—they’re buying into a lifestyle of consolidation:
- Free two-day shipping on Target items.
- Early access to Black Friday deals.
- Student memberships lasting up to four years.
This emotional stickiness is hard to quantify but impossible to ignore. When a customer’s weekly grocery run, hardware order, and Target purchase all flow through one app, switching costs skyrocket.
Risks, but Not Showstoppers
Critics cite alcohol exclusions and regional retailer gaps as vulnerabilities. While valid, these are minor speed bumps in a $500B grocery delivery market. The real risk? Overestimating execution. But Target’s 2024 store expansion (adding 300 locations) and Shipt’s seamless integration suggest management is ahead of the curve.
Investment Thesis: Buy Now, Reap Later
Target’s Circle 360 is a once-in-a-decade disruptor, blending the reach of a mall with the efficiency of e-commerce. At a P/E ratio of 15x (vs. Amazon’s 42x and Walmart’s 18x), the stock is undervalued. With $300+ in annual savings per member and ~10% penetration of its addressable market, TGT could hit $300/share by 2026—a 36% upside.
The market still underestimates how this ecosystem will melt away Amazon’s Prime dominance and Walmart’s price parity claims. For investors willing to look beyond quarterly noise, Target’s moat is just beginning to flex its muscles. Buy now—before the crowd catches on.
Comments
No comments yet