Spotify's Second-Quarter Loss and Market Rebound: Is This the Right Time to Buy?

Spotify's Q2 2025 earnings report sent shockwaves through the market. The company, which had been on a steady growth trajectory for years, posted a net loss of €86 million—a stark reversal from a net profit of €274 million in the same period in 2024. This unexpected turn triggered an 11.6% drop in its stock price, erasing $16.6 billion in market value. Yet, for value investors, this volatility may signal a critical inflection point. By dissecting Spotify's financials, Deutsche Bank's bullish stance, and the broader market sentiment, we can assess whether the selloff presents a compelling opportunity to buy.

The Anatomy of the Loss: A Temporary Setback or a Structural Issue?

Spotify's loss stemmed from three key factors:
1. Elevated Operating Expenses: Operating expenses surged by 8% year-over-year to €914 million, driven by increased personnel costs, marketing spend, and professional services.
2. Unpredictable Social Charges: Payroll taxes tied to stock-based compensation—€116 million in Q2—surpassed forecasts by €98 million. These charges, directly linked to Spotify's stock price, ballooned as the company's shares appreciated by over 100% in the 12 months prior.
3. Net Finance Costs: The company faced €358 million in finance costs, a dramatic shift from €4 million in finance income in Q2 2024.

However, these challenges were offset by robust operational performance. Spotify added 8 million premium subscribers (276 million total) and grew MAUs to 696 million, a 12% and 11% year-over-year increase, respectively. Revenue rose 10% to €4.19 billion, with premium revenue up 16% and a gross margin of 31.5%, surpassing guidance. Despite the loss, Spotify's free cash flow remained strong at €534 million, and it announced a $2 billion stock buyback plan—a clear signal of confidence in its long-term value.

Deutsche Bank's Bullish Case: A “Buy” Rating and Price Target of $775

Deutsche Bank raised its price target for Spotify from $700 to $775, maintaining a “Buy” rating. Analysts highlighted three pillars of optimism:
1. Subscriber and Revenue Resilience: Deutsche Bank praised Spotify's ability to grow its premium subscriber base in both developed and emerging markets, with 30% higher net additions in H1 2025 compared to H1 2024.
2. Margin Expansion: The company's gross margin of 31.6% in Q2 2025 marked a 400-basis-point improvement year-over-year, outpacing guidance and demonstrating pricing power.
3. Innovation and Diversification: Spotify's expansion into video podcasts (430,000 titles), audiobooks, and AI-driven personalization is creating new revenue streams. The Spotify Partner Program, which paid out $100 million to podcast creators in Q1 2025, underscores its commitment to content diversification.

The bank's analysis also acknowledged near-term headwinds, such as modest ad revenue growth and macroeconomic uncertainty, but argued that Spotify's structural advantages—its first-mover position in streaming, network effects, and brand loyalty—will drive long-term value creation.

Market Sentiment: A Selloff or a Buying Opportunity?

The 11.6% post-earnings drop in Spotify's stock price has sparked debate. Critics argue that the loss highlights the company's vulnerability to unpredictable costs and a saturated streaming market. However, value investors should consider the following:
- Undervaluation at a P/E of 95.1x: While Spotify's P/E ratio appears high, its revenue growth (10% YoY) and margin expansion justify a premium valuation. For context, Netflix trades at a P/E of 70.5x despite slower user growth.
- Catalysts for Recovery: The $2 billion buyback plan, combined with Spotify's focus on monetizing video podcasts (which show 50% higher engagement than audio-only content), could drive earnings growth in 2026.
- Margin of Safety: At $620.01 (post-earnings), Spotify trades at a 13% discount to Deutsche Bank's $775 price target. This discount reflects the market's short-term pessimism but ignores the company's long-term potential.

Historically, Spotify's earnings release dates have coincided with positive stock price movements. From 2022 to the present, the stock has averaged a 4.91% increase on earnings announcement days, reflecting investor confidence in the company's ability to deliver results that exceed expectations. This pattern suggests that while the recent selloff was sharp, it may represent an overreaction to short-term volatility rather than a fundamental shift in the company's trajectory.

Long-Term Prospects: Navigating Competition and Consumer Trends

Spotify faces stiff competition from Apple Music, Amazon Music, and emerging AI-driven platforms. However, its first-mover advantage, 700 million MAUs, and diversified content strategy (music, podcasts, audiobooks) provide a moat. The company's focus on video podcasts—a niche with $1.2 billion in ad revenue potential by 2027—could further differentiate it.

Moreover, Spotify's ability to adapt to consumer trends is a strength. The rollout of AI-powered features like “Daily Mix” and “Enhance” has boosted user engagement, while its freemium model ensures a steady flow of ad-supported users. Deutsche Bank estimates that Spotify's ad business could grow to €1 billion annually by 2027 if it accelerates programmatic ad adoption.

The Verdict: A Buy for the Patient Investor

While Spotify's Q2 loss was a shock, it is a temporary setback rather than a structural failure. The company's core metrics—subscriber growth, revenue expansion, and margin improvement—remain intact. Deutsche Bank's raised price target and $2 billion buyback plan signal confidence in its long-term trajectory.

For value investors, the selloff offers an opportunity to buy a high-quality growth stock at a discount. The key risks—volatile social charges and ad revenue underperformance—are manageable and do not outweigh the company's strengths. As Spotify executes on its innovation roadmap and refines its ad business, the stock is well-positioned for a rebound.

Investment Recommendation: Buy with a 12-month price target of $775. Investors should monitor the company's ability to control social charges and accelerate ad revenue growth while maintaining its focus on user acquisition and content diversification.

"""