Shareholders Back Musk's $1 Trillion Stake, Igniting Governance vs. Innovation Debate

Tesla shareholders on Thursday approved a historic $1 trillion compensation package for CEO Elon Musk, cementing his role as the company's central figure while reigniting debates over executive pay and corporate governance, according to a CNBC report. The vote, backed by over 75% of investors, grants Musk a stake that could rise to 25% of Tesla if he meets ambitious performance targets tied to market capitalization, vehicle deliveries, and AI-driven innovations.

The pay plan, structured into 12 tranches, requires Tesla to achieve milestones such as reaching an $8.5 trillion market value—over five times its current $1.5 trillion valuation—and delivering 20 million vehicles annually, Livemint reported.

Musk, who already owns 13% of Tesla, would gain an additional 12% stake under the package, enhancing his voting power and control over strategic decisions, including Tesla's foray into robotics and artificial intelligence. The board argued the plan is critical to retaining Musk's leadership amid competition in emerging technologies, warning that his departure could destabilize the company.

Despite strong retail investor support, the proposal faced opposition from major institutional investors, including Norway's $2 trillion sovereign wealth fund and California's CalPERS pension fund, TimesNow reported. Critics highlighted concerns over excessive dilution, lack of performance safeguards, and Musk's growing political and business ventures. Norges Bank Investment Management, Tesla's sixth-largest institutional shareholder, called the package "unreasonable" and emphasized the need for mitigating "key person risk". Proxy advisors Glass Lewis and Institutional Shareholder Services also recommended rejecting the plan.

Musk's influence extends beyond Tesla, with the billionaire leading SpaceX, xAI, and Neuralink while actively engaging in U.S. politics. His supporters, including Tesla Board Chair Robyn Denholm, argue his multifaceted roles are essential to Tesla's innovation. "Elon is the ultimate 'key man' of key man risk," said Ron Baron, a prominent Tesla backer. However, governance experts like Nell Minow criticized the arrangement, noting Musk's "part-time CEO" status given his external commitments.

The approval comes as Tesla navigates a volatile market. The company's stock has surged 14% this year, aided by Musk's $1 billion stock purchase and optimism over AI-driven growth, a Blockonomi analysis noted. Analysts like Wedbush's Dan Ives hailed the vote as a "new chapter" for Tesla, citing its physical AI edge in autonomous vehicles and robotaxis. Yet, challenges persist, including declining auto sales in recent quarters and regulatory scrutiny over safety risks.

The pay package also includes provisions for "covered events," such as pandemics or regulatory shifts, which could allow Musk to earn shares without hitting operational targets. This flexibility has drawn criticism, with opponents arguing it undermines accountability. Meanwhile, Tesla's board faces ongoing legal battles over its 2018 pay plan, which a Delaware court ruled was improperly approved.

As Tesla moves forward, the outcome underscores the tension between visionary leadership and corporate governance norms. With Musk's stake now poised to grow significantly, the company's ability to balance innovation with investor expectations will remain a focal point in the years ahead.

---