Royalties Inc.'s Legal and Royalty Recovery Story: A High-Conviction Play for 2025-2026

In the volatile world of resource and intellectual property (IP) investments, few stories blend legal rigor, asset recovery, and recurring income potential as compellingly as Royalties Inc. (RI). As of September 2025, the company stands at a pivotal juncture, with two cornerstone initiatives—its court-backed claim on the Portree properties in Mexico and its dividend-generating stake in Music Royalties Inc. (MRI)—positioning it as a high-conviction play for investors seeking undervalued assets and long-term yield.

Legal Victory in Mexico: A Path to $25M+ in Recovered Royalties

Royalties Inc.'s subsidiary, Minera Portree de Zacatecas (MPZ), achieved a landmark legal win in June 2025 when the Third Commercial Court of Zacatecas ruled in its favor, invalidating Capstone Copper Corp.'s 2019 unauthorized assignment of a 2% net smelter royalty (NSR) on the Cozamin MineRoyalties Inc. Reports Q2 Results For June 30, 2025 and Update on Capstone Lawsuit [https://www.miningstockeducation.com/2025/08/royalties-inc-reports-q2-results-for-june-30-2025-and-update-on-capstone-lawsuit/]^[1]. The court affirmed that the 2002 contract establishing the NSR could not be transferred without MPZ's consentRoyalties Inc. Responds to Capstone's Appeal in Ongoing Cozamin Mine Royalty Dispute [https://www.newsfilecorp.com/release/260919/Royalties-Inc.-Responds-to-Capstones-Appeal-in-Ongoing-Cozamin-Mine-Royalty-Dispute]^[2]. This ruling not only validates MPZ's ownership but also opens the door to retroactive payments for production since 2019, estimated at $9 million, with annual cash flow potential of $2.5 millionRoyalties Inc. Responds to Capstone's Appeal in Ongoing Cozamin Mine Royalty Dispute [https://www.newsfilecorp.com/release/260919/Royalties-Inc.-Responds-to-Capstones-Appeal-in-Ongoing-Cozamin-Mine-Royalty-Dispute]^[2].

However, Capstone has appealed the decision to the Supreme Court of Zacatecas, arguing procedural flaws in the trial court's failure to quantify liquid damagesRoyalties Inc. Responds to Capstone's Appeal in Ongoing Cozamin Mine Royalty Dispute [https://www.newsfilecorp.com/release/260919/Royalties-Inc.-Responds-to-Capstones-Appeal-in-Ongoing-Cozamin-Mine-Royalty-Dispute]^[2]. While this delays resolution, MPZ has countered that Capstone's mining activity since 2019 provides unambiguous evidence of the NSR's valueRoyalties Inc. Responds to Capstone's Appeal in Ongoing Cozamin Mine Royalty Dispute [https://www.newsfilecorp.com/release/260919/Royalties-Inc.-Responds-to-Capstones-Appeal-in-Ongoing-Cozamin-Mine-Royalty-Dispute]^[2]. A geological expert has independently valued the 2% NSR at $25 million, underscoring the high stakesRoyalties Inc. Reports Q2 Results For June 30, 2025 and Update on Capstone Lawsuit [https://www.miningstockeducation.com/2025/08/royalties-inc-reports-q2-results-for-june-30-2025-and-update-on-capstone-lawsuit/]^[1].

This legal battle is emblematic of RI's broader strategy: leveraging court systems to recover undervalued or misappropriated assets. With global copper and silver demand surging due to AI and green energy infrastructureRoyalties Inc. Responds to Capstone's Appeal in Ongoing Cozamin Mine Royalty Dispute [https://www.newsfilecorp.com/release/260919/Royalties-Inc.-Responds-to-Capstones-Appeal-in-Ongoing-Cozamin-Mine-Royalty-Dispute]^[2], the Cozamin Mine's strategic importance is only growing.

MRI: A Recurring Income Powerhouse

While the Mexico litigation unfolds, Royalties Inc. has quietly built a dividend-generating royalty portfolio through its stake in Music Royalties Inc. (MRI). As of June 2025, RI holds 5.05 million shares in MRI, valued at $2.525 million, generating $181,800 annually in dividendsRoyalties Inc. Reports Q2 Results For June 30, 2025 and Update on Capstone Lawsuit [https://www.miningstockeducation.com/2025/08/royalties-inc-reports-q2-results-for-june-30-2025-and-update-on-capstone-lawsuit/]^[1]. This represents a 7.2% yield, with MRI having distributed over $12 million in dividends since 2019 from 31 cash-flowing music catalogsRoyalties Inc. Reports Q2 Results For June 30, 2025 and Update on Capstone Lawsuit [https://www.miningstockeducation.com/2025/08/royalties-inc-reports-q2-results-for-june-30-2025-and-update-on-capstone-lawsuit/]^[1].

MRI's performance is a testament to the scalability of IP-based royalties. By acquiring 30+ cash-flowing catalogs, MRI has diversified its revenue streams across genres and geographies, insulating itself from market volatility. For Royalties Inc., this translates to predictable, inflation-resistant income that complements its mining royalty exposure.

Notably, RI's investment in MRI has grown steadily, from $1.5 million in 2024 to $2.525 million in 2025, reflecting confidence in the sector's growth. The music royalties market, valued at $2.4 billion in 2024, is projected to double to $4.8 billion by 2033, driven by digital consumption and AI-driven royalty management toolsMusic Royalties Management Solution Market 2025 [https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/music-royalties-management-solution-market-2025-leading-letzf]^[3].

Strategic Synergy: Capital Appreciation and Yield

The combination of legal asset recovery and recurring income creates a compelling dual-engine model for Royalties Inc. The Cozamin Mine dispute, if resolved in MPZ's favor, could unlock $25 million+ in value—a material boost for a company with a market cap below $6 billionRoyalties Inc. Responds to Capstone's Appeal in Ongoing Cozamin Mine Royalty Dispute [https://www.newsfilecorp.com/release/260919/Royalties-Inc.-Responds-to-Capstones-Appeal-in-Ongoing-Cozamin-Mine-Royalty-Dispute]^[2]. Meanwhile, MRI's dividends not only cover corporate overheadRoyalties Inc. Reports Q2 Results For June 30, 2025 and Update on Capstone Lawsuit [https://www.miningstockeducation.com/2025/08/royalties-inc-reports-q2-results-for-june-30-2025-and-update-on-capstone-lawsuit/]^[1] but also provide a steady cash flow to reinvest in higher-yielding assets or return to shareholders.

Critics may argue that Capstone's appeal and the inherent risks of legal battles introduce uncertainty. However, RI's CEO, Tim Gallagher, has emphasized that the Cozamin Mine's royalty payments to other holders in 2024—averaging $1.5 million annually—make the claim “immaterial” for a $6 billion companyRoyalties Inc. Responds to Capstone's Appeal in Ongoing Cozamin Mine Royalty Dispute [https://www.newsfilecorp.com/release/260919/Royalties-Inc.-Responds-to-Capstones-Appeal-in-Ongoing-Cozamin-Mine-Royalty-Dispute]^[2]. This suggests Capstone's resistance is more about precedent than financial survival, tilting the odds in RI's favor.

Conclusion: A High-Conviction Play for 2025–2026

Royalties Inc. embodies the intersection of legal acumen, strategic IP investment, and recurring income generation. Its Mexico litigation represents a high-impact, low-probability-of-loss scenario, while its MRI stake offers a 7.2% yield in a growing market. For investors with a 12–24 month horizon, RI's dual focus on asset recovery and yield makes it a rare combination of capital appreciation potential and income security.

As the Supreme Court of Zacatecas deliberates and the music royalties sector expands, Royalties Inc. is poised to deliver outsized returns to those who recognize its undervalued assets and disciplined strategy.