Roth Conversions in Volatile Markets: Timing the Tax Break

The stock market’s recent turbulence has investors scrambling to protect their portfolios—and Roth conversions have emerged as a strategic tool for those looking to lock in lower tax rates while capitalizing on dips. But is a Roth conversion right for you? Let’s break down the opportunities, risks, and how to make the call.

Ask Aime: Is a Roth conversion right for me?

The Tax Rate Opportunity: Why 2025 Could Be a Golden Year

Roth conversions are about paying taxes now on pre-tax retirement assets (like traditional IRAs or 401(k)s) to enjoy tax-free growth and withdrawals later. A key incentive in 2025 is the impending expiration of the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA), which lowered tax rates. After 2025, rates could revert to pre-2017 levels, potentially increasing by up to 7.6% at the top bracket (e.g., from 37% to 39.6%).

For example:
- Converting $100,000 in 2025 at a 22% tax rate costs $22,000.
- If rates jump to 28% post-2025, that same conversion would cost $28,000—a $6,000 difference.

Market Dips: Your Friend in a Roth Conversion

When the market dips, the value of your traditional IRA or 401(k) drops, meaning you’ll pay taxes on a smaller amount. If your portfolio rebounds later, the gains grow tax-free in your Roth.

Ask Aime: "Should I convert my IRA to a Roth IRA in 2025?"

Consider a 2022–2023 example:
- January 2022: Your IRA holds $200,000 in stocks.
- June 2022 (after a dip): The value drops to $150,000.
- Converting $150,000 at a 22% tax rate costs $33,000.
- By 2025, if the market recovers to $220,000, your Roth holds $220,000—tax-free.

This strategy works best if you can fund the tax bill from non-retirement accounts, avoiding a reduction in your converted balance.

The 10-Year Rule: Protecting Heirs from Future Taxes

The SECURE 2.0 Act’s 10-year distribution rule for inherited IRAs (effective 2020, penalties enforced 2025) adds urgency. Most beneficiaries must drain inherited traditional IRAs within 10 years, paying income tax on withdrawals. A Roth conversion sidesteps this:
- Roth IRAs have no required minimum distributions (RMDs) during the original owner’s lifetime.
- Heirs inherit tax-free withdrawals over the 10-year period, avoiding income taxes on growth.

Risks and Considerations: Don’t Get Burned

1. The Five-Year Rule: Converted funds must stay in the Roth IRA for five years to avoid a 10% early withdrawal penalty (if taken before age 59½). Each conversion starts a new clock.
2. High-Income Surcharge: Taxpayers with AGI over $400,000 (single) or $450,000 (married) face a 10% surcharge on Roth conversions exceeding $5 million in 2025.
3. Medicare Penalties: Higher AGI from conversions could boost Medicare premiums (IRMAA), especially for those in higher-income brackets.

How to Decide: Your Checklist

• Tax Bracket Comparison: Are your current rates lower than what you expect in retirement?
• Market Timing: Is your portfolio undervalued? Use dips to minimize taxable conversions.
• Estate Goals: Do you want to shield heirs from taxes and RMDs?
• Penalty Risks: Can you wait five years (or until 59½) to withdraw?

The Bottom Line: Data-Driven Decisions

In 2025, Roth conversions offer a rare trifecta:
1. Lower Tax Rates: Before TCJA’s expiration.
2. Market Volatility: Opportunities to convert at depressed values.
3. Inheritance Benefits: Tax-free withdrawals for heirs.

But success hinges on context. For instance:
- A 55-year-old in the 22% bracket converting $100,000 during a 20% market dip could save $5,000 in taxes if rates rise to 28%.
- A high-income earner near the $5 million conversion threshold must calculate the 10% surcharge.

While dips make conversions tempting, they’re not a one-size-fits-all move. Use tax software to model scenarios, and consult a CPA or tax advisor to avoid penalties. In a volatile market, timing is everything—but so is the math.

Final Stat: Over 60% of financial advisors recommend Roth conversions during market downturns, per a 2023 Fidelity survey. If the numbers align with your goals, now could be the time to roar ahead—tax-free.