The Risks and Opportunities in Neogen Corporation’s (NEOG) Ongoing Securities Class Action Litigation

The ongoing securities class action litigation against Neogen Corporation (NASDAQ: NEOG) offers a stark case study in the interplay between corporate governance failures and shareholder value erosion. Investors who purchased Neogen stock between January 5, 2023, and June 3, 2025, are alleging that the company and its executives misled them about the integration of the 3M Food Safety Division, concealing operational inefficiencies and financial missteps that culminated in a $461 million goodwill impairment charge and a 79% stock price plunge by June 2025 [1]. This litigation, coupled with Neogen’s governance shortcomings, underscores the long-term financial and reputational risks of poor corporate stewardship—and the opportunities for reform if leadership can rebuild trust.

Governance Failures and Shareholder Value Erosion

Neogen’s governance issues began with the 2022 acquisition of the 3M Food Safety Division, a move that initially seemed to expand its market reach but later exposed systemic integration challenges. The company’s leadership, including CEO John Adent, allegedly downplayed these issues in public disclosures, leading to a pattern of misleading statements that inflated the stock price [2]. When the truth emerged—via a $461 million impairment charge in January 2025 and a 3.4% revenue decline in April 2025—the stock plummeted, wiping out $4.9 billion in market capitalization [3].

Academic research corroborates the link between governance failures and shareholder value loss. A 2025 study found that companies with governance deficits underperformed their sectors by 35% in the year following a crisis, with an average $490 billion in lost shareholder value [4]. Neogen’s case aligns with these findings: its stock underperformed peers by over 70% in 2025, and its market cap loss exceeds the average cited in the study [5]. The company’s internal control weaknesses and leadership instability—exemplified by Adent’s resignation and the appointment of Mike Nassif—further eroded investor confidence [6].

Reputational Damage and Legal Risks

The reputational fallout from Neogen’s governance lapses is equally severe. The company’s “Pillars of Trust”—a governance framework emphasizing openness and credibility—now appear hollow, as investors question the alignment between public statements and operational realities [7]. This disconnect has fueled the class-action lawsuit, which accuses Neogen of securities fraud and seeks to hold executives accountable for misleading disclosures [8]. Legal risks remain high, with the lead plaintiff deadline set for September 16, 2025 [9].

Reputational damage compounds financial losses. A 2023 study on UK firms showed that governance reforms tailored to sector-specific challenges can improve financial performance, but Neogen’s reactive restructuring—such as board overhauls and internal control upgrades—has yet to prove effective [10]. The company’s recent restructuring of its Genomics business and emphasis on transparency may help, but these measures are untested against the scale of its current crisis [11].

Opportunities for Recovery

Despite these risks, Neogen’s situation also presents opportunities for investors who believe in the company’s long-term potential. The appointment of Mike Nassif, a Siemens Healthineers veteran, signals a strategic pivot toward operational discipline [12]. Additionally, governance reforms—such as the removal of anti-takeover provisions and enhanced board independence—could align with academic findings that such changes improve long-term performance [13].

However, recovery hinges on Neogen’s ability to demonstrate sustained transparency and accountability. A 2025 study emphasized that robust governance disclosures exceeding industry averages are critical for restoring investor trust [14]. Neogen must also address its material internal control weaknesses, which persist despite leadership changes [15].

Conclusion

Neogen’s securities class action litigation is a cautionary tale of governance failures and their cascading financial and reputational impacts. While the company faces significant hurdles—including a $4.9 billion market cap loss and ongoing legal battles—its recent leadership changes and governance reforms offer a path to recovery. Investors must weigh the risks of continued mismanagement against the potential for a turnaround if Neogen can credibly rebuild trust. As academic research shows, the road to recovery is long and uncertain, but companies that prioritize transparency and accountability often emerge stronger in the long term [16].

Source:
[1] Neogen Corporation Class Action Lawsuit - NEOG, [https://www.rgrdlaw.com/cases-neogen-corporation.html]
[2] Neogen Corporation (NEOG) Securities Class Action..., [https://zlk.com/learn?p=neogen-corporation-neog-securities-class-action-lawsuit-update]
[3] Neogen Corporation: Legal Storms and Governance Gaps ..., [https://www.ainvest.com/news/neogen-corporation-legal-storms-governance-gaps-threaten-shareholder-investors-2508/]
[4] The Effect of Corporate Governance on Shareholder Value, [https://www.nber.org/digest/may11/effect-corporate-governance-shareholder-value]
[5] Neogen Corporation (NEOG) Investors Who Lost Money Have Opportunity to Lead Securities Fraud Lawsuit, [https://www.morningstar.com/news/pr-newswire/20250828la61394/neogen-corporation-neog-investors-who-lost-money-have-opportunity-to-lead-securities-fraud-lawsuit]
[6] Neogen Corporation: A Case Study in Securities Litigation ..., [https://www.ainvest.com/news/neogen-corporation-case-study-securities-litigation-governance-failures-path-rebuilding-market-trust-2507/]
[7] Investor Relations | Governance, [https://www.neogen.com/en/investor-relations/governance/]
[8] Neogen Corp. Shareholder Files Securities Class Action Lawsuit, [https://www.ainvest.com/news/neogen-corp-shareholder-files-securities-class-action-lawsuit-2508/]
[9] Join Class Action to Recover Losses from Neogen Corporation (NEOG), [https://www.wric.com/business/press-releases/accesswire/1066529/join-class-action-to-recover-losses-from-neogen-corporation-neog-contact-levi-korsinsky-before-september-16-2025]
[10] The Impact of Corporate Governance on Financial, [https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10226873/]
[11] Neogen’s Integration Fiasco: A Cautionary Tale for Investors, [https://www.ainvest.com/news/neogen-integration-fiasco-cautionary-tale-investors-2507/]
[12] Neogen Corp (NEOG) Beats Expectations Amid Leadership Change and Restructuring Efforts, [https://finance.yahoo.com/news/neogen-corp-neog-beats-expectations-220657046.html]
[13] The Effect of Corporate Governance on Shareholder Value, [https://www.nber.org/digest/may11/effect-corporate-governance-shareholder-value]
[14] The Impact of Corporate Governance on Firm Value, [https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1059056025006355]
[15] Neogen Corporation: Legal Storms and Governance Gaps ..., [https://www.ainvest.com/news/neogen-corporation-legal-storms-governance-gaps-threaten-shareholder-investors-2508/]
[16] The Value of Corporate Governance in a More Sustainable World, [https://sponsored.bloomberg.com/article/axa/the-value-of-corporate-governance-in-a-more-sustainable-world]