Rising Medicare Costs Outpace Social Security's 2.8% COLA, Seniors Warn

The Social Security Administration (SSA) announced on October 24, 2025, that the 2026 cost-of-living adjustment (COLA) will be 2.8%, marking a modest increase for the program's 75 million beneficiaries. The adjustment, which translates to an average $56 monthly boost for retirees, brings the average benefit to $2,071 from $2,015 in 2025. While this is the fifth consecutive year of at least a 2.5% increase—a rarity since the early 1990s—the adjustment has drawn widespread criticism for failing to keep pace with inflation and rising healthcare costs .

The 2.8% COLA, calculated using the CPI-W, reflects a 2.9% year-over-year increase in prices through August 2025. However, experts argue that CPI-W does not accurately capture the expenses faced by seniors, particularly in healthcare and housing. The index weights costs like transportation and food more heavily, while underrepresenting the rising costs of medical care, which now consume a growing share of retirees' budgets .

For many seniors, the COLA's impact is further eroded by steep increases in Medicare premiums. The standard Medicare Part B premium is projected to rise by 11.6% in 2026, from $185 to $206.50 per month, according to the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. This increase could offset the entire COLA gain for some beneficiaries. "Rising Medicare premiums alone could fully consume the COLA for many seniors in 2026," said Mary Johnson, an independent Social Security and Medicare policy analyst .

Public sentiment reflects this disconnect. A recent AARP survey found that 77% of older Americans believe the 2.8% increase is insufficient to cover rising living costs. Three-quarters of respondents said they would need a 5% or higher adjustment to maintain their standard of living. Gina Seibert, CFO of PSECU, noted that even small shortfalls force retirees to cut back on essentials like groceries and housing or dip into savings prematurely .

The SSA's announcement also highlighted broader structural challenges for Social Security. The June 2025 trustees' report, which finances benefits, is projected to become insolvent by 2034, at which point it would only be able to pay 81% of scheduled benefits without congressional action. The report cited demographic shifts and declining birth rates as key factors in the looming shortfall. Meanwhile, the Trump administration's recent tax reforms, including the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, have raised concerns about accelerated insolvency due to reduced revenue from benefit taxation .

Advocates have long pushed for reforms to the COLA calculation, including adopting the Consumer Price Index for the Elderly (CPI-E), which better reflects seniors' spending patterns. The National Council on Aging (NCOA) emphasized that the current COLA "is woefully insufficient for older Americans who already have high healthcare costs and are facing even greater increases in their Medicare costs in 2026" .

The 2026 COLA announcement also came amid a federal government shutdown that delayed the release of critical data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics. While the SSA managed to publish the adjustment on schedule, the episode underscored vulnerabilities in the system. Commissioner Frank J. Bisignano stated the COLA "ensures benefits reflect today's economic realities," but critics argue that the program's long-term sustainability remains unaddressed .

As retirees brace for the January 2026 implementation of the COLA, many are left grappling with the reality that modest increases may not alleviate financial strain. With inflation persisting and healthcare costs climbing, the debate over how to better align Social Security adjustments with seniors' needs is likely to intensify.

---