Repay Holdings: Is This Earnings Miss a Buying Opportunity Amid Strategic Momentum?

Repay Holdings (NASDAQ: RPAY) has faced a significant earnings miss in Q2 2025, with a reported EPS of -$1.15—far below the forecasted $0.20. While the short-term disappointment is undeniable, a closer look reveals a company with resilient cash flow, strategic momentum, and a compelling value proposition. For value investors, this dip may represent an opportunity to capitalize on a business poised for long-term growth in the digital payments sector. Historical context from past earnings misses further strengthens this case.

Financial Resilience Amid Short-Term Headwinds

Despite the EPS shortfall, RPAY's financials remain robust. The company generated $75.6 million in revenue, a 1% year-over-year increase, and reported adjusted EBITDA of $31.8 million with a 42% margin. Free cash flow for the quarter reached $22.6 million, with a 71% conversion rate—up from the prior quarter. This cash flow strength, coupled with $163 million in cash and $413 million in total liquidity, underscores a fortress balance sheet.

The earnings miss was largely driven by one-off factors: client losses in the Consumer Payments segment and the lapping of political media contributions. When normalized, gross profit growth would have shown single-digit improvement. Importantly, the Business Payments segment demonstrated 1% normalized growth, suggesting underlying demand for RPAY's services.

Strategic Momentum in Digital Payments

RPAY's long-term value lies in its strategic initiatives to expand its digital payment ecosystem. The company has added 286 integrated software partners, expanded its AP supplier network to 440,000 (a 47% YoY increase), and boosted instant funding volumes by 38%. These metrics highlight a growing network effect, which is critical in the payments industry.

Management's focus on operational excellence and capital allocation further strengthens the case for value investors. The company repurchased 4.8 million shares for $22.6 million in Q2 alone, signaling confidence in its intrinsic value. With a current share price of $5.06—well below its 52-week high of $9.75—RPAY trades at a discount to its fair value, according to InvestingPro analysis. Analysts remain bullish, with a target range of $4.50 to $12.00.

A Path to Recovery: Q4 Guidance and Growth Levers

RPAY's management has reiterated confidence in its 2025 outlook, projecting high-single-digit to low-double-digit normalized gross profit growth in Q4. This acceleration is expected as the company laps client losses and benefits from expanded partnerships. Free cash flow conversion is also projected to exceed 60% by year-end, a key metric for value investors prioritizing cash-generating businesses.

Strategic investments in enterprise sales, customer support, and digital payment technology position RPAY to capitalize on the broader shift toward real-time payments. The company's openness to tuck-in M&A in the consumer and business payments segments adds another layer of growth potential.

Risks and Considerations

The earnings miss highlights near-term volatility, particularly in the Consumer Payments segment. Political media contributions and client attrition due to market consolidation remain risks. However, these challenges appear to be transitory, with management emphasizing sequential improvement in operational execution.

For value investors, the key question is whether the current valuation reflects these risks or represents a mispricing. Given RPAY's strong liquidity, resilient cash flow, and strategic momentum, the latter seems more likely.

Investment Thesis

Repay Holdings' earnings miss is a short-term setback, not a long-term concern. The company's financial health, strategic initiatives, and discounted valuation create a compelling case for patient investors. With a focus on capital allocation, operational efficiency, and digital innovation, RPAY is well-positioned to deliver durable growth as it navigates near-term challenges.

For value investors, this dip offers a strategic entry point to a business with a strong balance sheet, expanding ecosystem, and a clear path to recovery. As the digital payments landscape evolves, RPAY's ability to adapt and scale could unlock significant upside—particularly for those willing to look beyond the quarterly noise.

"""