Peloton vs Planet Fitness: Which Fitness Stock Offers Stronger Upside?

Peloton and Planet Fitness represent different approaches to the modern fitness market. Peloton's improving profitability and strong product innovation position it beyond connected biking and into a broader wellness ecosystem. However, it faces top-line pressure, subscription declines, and a product recall. Planet Fitness benefits from strong demand trends and an expanding member base, with 6.9% system-wide same-club sales growth and 13% year-over-year revenue growth. Its value proposition resonates with younger consumers, with a 30% surge in participation in its High School Summer Pass program.