Northeastern Student Seeks Tuition Refund After Professor Uses AI for Lectures

Ella Stapleton, a senior at Northeastern University, discovered that her business professor, Rick Arrowood, had been using OpenAI’s ChatGPT to generate lecture notes. Stapleton noticed several indicators of AI use, including a ChatGPT search citation, misspellings, and images with extraneous limbs and digits. This
prompted her to question the integrity of her education and the value of her tuition fees.Stapleton brought her concerns to the university's administration, demanding a refund of her $8,000 tuition fees. After a series of meetings that continued until her graduation, the administration ultimately decided not to refund her tuition. The university's stance was that the use of AI tools by professors did not warrant a tuition refund, despite the student's valid concerns.
The incident sparked a broader discussion about the ethical use of AI in education. While some educators argue that there is no "one-size-fits-all" approach to using AI in the classroom, others view the use of AI at work as lazy and look down upon those who use it. A study found that people both anticipate and experience judgment from their colleagues for using AI at work, indicating a social evaluation penalty for its use.
Arrowood, who had used various AI tools including ChatGPT, the Perplexity AI search engine, and an AI presentation generator called Gamma, acknowledged that he should have reviewed the outputs more closely. He now advocates for greater transparency in the use of AI tools in education, suggesting that professors should disclose when and how AI is used in their teaching. This stance indicates that the incident served as a teachable moment for Arrowood, who now recognizes the importance of transparency and ethical considerations in the use of AI.
The incident at Northeastern University highlights the complexities and challenges of integrating AI into educational settings. While AI tools can enhance productivity and provide new perspectives, their use also raises questions about academic integrity, transparency, and the social evaluation of those who employ them. As AI continues to evolve, it is crucial for educational institutions to develop clear guidelines and policies to ensure that its use is ethical and beneficial for all stakeholders.

Comments
No comments yet