Netflix Earnings Set to Drop the Mic: Can Record Margins and Ad Growth Silence the Skeptics?

Netflix (NFLX) is set to report second-quarter 2025 earnings Thursday after the close, and expectations are running high. Shares are up 45% year-to-date, and while bulls are optimistic, some on the Street are bracing for a potential "sell the news" moment given the massive run. At the heart of this earnings report is a narrative shift: Netflix is no longer just a subscriber growth story. It's now about advertising momentum, pricing power, operating leverage, and strategic content investments. With live events, a growing ad-supported tier, and blockbuster content like Squid Game 3, Netflix enters this quarter with elevated expectations—and a lot to prove.

Wall Street expects Q2 revenue of around $11.05 billion, up 15.6% year-over-year, with EPS forecast at $7.07. Operating margins are anticipated to hit 33.3%, continuing a streak of expansion from 27.2% a year ago and 31.7% last quarter. Free cash flow guidance stands firm at $8 billion for the full year, though bulls are hoping for a revision higher. Analysts from Wedbush, UBS, and BMO are calling for modest beats and upward revisions to full-year revenue and margin targets, while noting Netflix's growing monetization capacity through its ad-tier and international market expansion.

Q1 offered a strong foundation: EPS of $6.61 beat by nearly a dollar, and Netflix reiterated its full-year guidance. The company continues to benefit from strong pricing execution and a favorable shift toward content efficiency. Notably, Netflix stopped reporting net adds, pushing focus to ARPU and operating margin—a move that aligns with its transition to a value-per-user business model. With high U.S. and Canada penetration, future growth will lean heavily on Asia and Latin America, where household reach is still well below 30%.

Key items to watch include:

• U.S. and Canada sales growth, which should show mid-teens improvement due to price hikes and retention gains.
• Advertising revenue progress and commentary on scale, CPMs, and user engagement (now topping 94M monthly active users).
• International market performance, particularly how much growth is driven by underlying strength vs. FX tailwinds.
• Margin improvement and content spend efficiency.

AI and live content are also playing a larger role in Netflix’s story. Analysts point to hundreds of billions of user interactions that can be leveraged with generative AI to personalize engagement and streamline production. Content productivity and cost discipline remain core strengths—with $18 billion in content spending still producing robust free cash flow thanks to scale.

Bulls argue that Netflix's leadership in content, global reach, and growing ad platform offer a virtuous cycle of pricing power and profitability. Advertising-supported subscriptions open new revenue streams and lower price points, while international local-language content continues to gain traction. Needham notes Netflix’s revenue per employee surpasses even Apple and Google, underscoring productivity and execution.

Bears, however, flag valuation concerns. With the stock pricing in near-2030 operating targets, any hiccup could bring volatility. There are also geopolitical risks: tariffs on foreign-produced content (a possibility under the Trump Administration) could raise costs. And while content is king, it’s an arms race—competition remains fierce and content budgets continue to rise.

Still, consensus points to continued outperformance. With momentum in pricing, advertising, and margins, Netflix appears to be entering a new phase of maturity—one where it monetizes its platform at scale, even if subscriber growth slows. Thursday's results will test that thesis. If Netflix delivers a beat and raises guidance, bulls may have more runway. If not, the stock's impressive rally could stall—at least temporarily.

In short, the new Netflix story is about moving from volume to value, from subscriber counts to monetization metrics. And in this earnings season, that pivot will take center stage.

WATCH: “The worst thing you can do is keep doing what works.”