Navigating Tariff Uncertainty: Strategic Plays in a Slowing Consumer Spending Environment

Cyrus ColeFriday, May 30, 2025 10:57 am ET
51min read

The global economy is at an inflection point. Trade tensions, inflation asymmetries, and sectoral divergence have created a high-stakes landscape for investors. As tariffs oscillate between temporary relief and renewed escalation, and inflation's grip shifts from goods to services and back, the playbook for wealth preservation has fundamentally changed. This is not the time to cling to outdated strategies—it's time to exploit the fault lines.

The Tariff Chessboard: Winners and Losers in Real Time

The May 2025 U.S.-China tariff truce—lowering rates to 10% but excluding critical sectors—has bought markets a brief reprieve. Yet the 16.4% average U.S. tariff rate (the highest since 1937) ensures no return to pre-trade-war normalcy. Meanwhile, the U.S.-U.K. trade deal, while favorable for auto imports, remains a niche win. The auto industry's rebate program (slashing tariffs to 3.75% in 2026) offers a lifeline, but it's a temporary salve for an industry still reeling from $2,300/household long-term price hikes.

TSLA Closing Price

Tesla's volatility since 2023—plunging during tariff spikes and rebounding on trade deals—epitomizes the auto sector's fragility. Investors should avoid such exposures until policy clarity emerges.

Inflation's Split Personality: Services Deflate, Goods Ignite

The core services inflation rate in G5 economies has plunged to 3.5%, its lowest since early 2022. This is a gift for sectors like healthcare, education, and hospitality, which rely on stable labor costs. Conversely, core goods inflation has surged to 0.6%, the highest in a year, as tariffs and inventory squeezes bite.

The divergence is stark:
- Resilient Sectors: Healthcare (aging populations + rising demand for chronic care), domestic IT services (unexposed to trade wars), and utilities (stable demand, inflation-hedged contracts).
- Overexposed Sectors: Retail (squeezed margins from higher import costs), autos (tariff-induced price hikes dampening demand), and consumer discretionary (debt-sensitive households cutting back).


Healthcare's growth trajectory is clear. Companies like UnitedHealth (UNH) and telemedicine leaders are positioned to capitalize on a services sector unburdened by tariff volatility.

The Employment and GDP Tax: Why Caution is Required

The tariff regime has already cost 456,000 U.S. jobs and shaved 0.4% off GDP by late 2025. Construction and mining sectors—already struggling with higher input costs—are bleeding value. Meanwhile, manufacturing's 1.5% output gain comes at the expense of these laggards, creating a zero-sum game.

Investors must ask: Is this a sustainable rotation, or a race to the bottom? The answer lies in the Fed's hesitant stance. Delayed rate cuts until September 2025 suggest policymakers are wary of stoking inflation, even as recession risks loom.

Your Playbook for This New Era

  1. Double Down on Services: Healthcare, IT, and financial services firms with domestic revenue streams (e.g., Cerner (CERN), Fidelity National Information Services (FIS)) offer insulation from trade wars.
  2. Embrace Inflation Hedges: Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities (TIPS) and real estate investment trusts (REITs) tied to essential services (e.g., hospitals, data centers) shield against goods-driven inflation.
  3. Avoid Tariff-Exposed Names: Auto manufacturers, retailers reliant on Chinese imports (e.g., Walmart (WMT)), and commodity firms face relentless margin pressure.
  4. Stay Nimble on Equities: Use sector ETFs like XLV (Health Care) and XLY (Consumer Discretionary) to tactically rotate—buy dips in defensive sectors, sell rallies in vulnerable ones.

Final Warning: The Tariff Sword Can Cut Both Ways

The $2.7 trillion in tariff revenue over the next decade may seem like a windfall, but it's a tax on consumers and businesses alike. A sudden escalation—say, a collapse of U.S.-China talks—could reignite 2025's $4,800/household income shock. Stay prepared for volatility by keeping 20% of portfolios in cash or short-term bonds.

The path forward is clear: diversify by sector, hedge by inflation, and avoid the tariff battlefield. This is not a time for passive investing—it's a time to act decisively before the next storm.

SPY Trend
Network error, please try to refresh

TIPS' outperformance during 2024's inflation spikes underscores their role as a critical defensive tool.

The next 12 months will separate the resilient from the reckless. Choose wisely.