Old National Bank (ONB) Earnings Report: A Buy Opportunity Amid Strong Earnings Momentum and Favorable Sector Trends?

The regional banking sector has long been a cornerstone of U.S. financial stability, offering a unique blend of local expertise and scalable infrastructure. As investors assess opportunities in this space, Old National Bancorp (ONB) emerges as a compelling case study. With its Q2 2025 earnings report due on July 22, the bank's recent performance, strategic initiatives, and sector dynamics warrant a closer look.

Earnings Expectations and Momentum

Analysts project Old National Bancorp to report Q2 2025 earnings per share (EPS) of $0.51, with revenue estimated at $622.83 million. These figures represent a 11.84% year-over-year revenue growth and align with the company's strong Q1 2025 performance, where EPS of $0.45 and revenue of $486.87 million exceeded expectations. The bank's ability to consistently outperform forecasts—by $0.03 in EPS and $8.5 million in revenue in Q1—underscores its operational discipline and resilience.

The consensus of 10 analysts, with EPS estimates ranging from $0.49 to $0.55, reflects confidence in ONB's momentum. This optimism is further reinforced by a "Moderate Buy" rating and an average price target of $26.30, with Truist and Barclays raising their targets to $27 and $28, respectively. The forward P/E ratio of 11.00 suggests the market is pricing in continued earnings growth, a critical metric for value-oriented investors.

Notably, historical backtesting of ONB's performance around earnings releases from 2022 to the present reveals a 64.29% win rate over three days post-announcement, with a 50% probability of positive returns over 10 days. The maximum return of 1.05% occurred 41 days after an earnings release, suggesting a favorable historical pattern for investors employing a buy-and-hold strategy.

Historical Performance and Strategic Growth

Old National's financial trajectory from 2020 to 2024 tells a story of disciplined expansion. Annual revenue grew from $903 million in 2020 to $2.956 billion in 2024, with the 2022–2024 period marked by a 117.38% and 37.01% surge, respectively. This growth has been driven by strategic acquisitions, including the $1.4 billion purchase of Bremer Financial Corporation in May 2025, which added 70 branches and $14 billion in assets. The integration of Bremer is expected to enhance ONB's presence in the Midwest and Southeast, regions where it already holds a strong deposit base of $41 billion and a loan portfolio of $36.5 billion.

The bank's efficiency ratio of 53.7% (adjusted 51.8%) further distinguishes it from peers. In a sector grappling with margin compression, ONB's ability to maintain low operating costs while expanding its asset base is a significant competitive advantage. Additionally, its 3.27% net interest margin (NIM) and strong capital position—evidenced by a Tier 1 common equity ratio of 11.62%—provide a buffer against economic headwinds.

Competitive Positioning and Sector Trends

ONB's competitive edge lies in its dual focus on community banking and technological innovation. Unlike larger national banks, it retains a human-centered approach, exemplified by its "Civic 50" recognition for community engagement. This reputation, combined with its recent acquisition of Bremer, positions it to capture market share in the Midwest, where it now ranks as the third-largest bank by deposits.

Sector-wide, regional banks are navigating a complex landscape. The Federal Reserve's rate-cutting cycle in 2025 has led to margin compression, but ONB's disciplined deposit management and diversified revenue streams mitigate this risk. For instance, noninterest income accounted for 42% of total revenue in Q1 2025, a trend mirrored by peers like U.S. Bancorp. However, ONB's efficiency ratio of 53.7% outperforms the industry average, highlighting its operational superiority.

Valuation and Investment Considerations

ONB's valuation metrics are equally compelling. Trading at a price-to-book (P/B) ratio of 1.0x—below the industry average of 1.3x—and a forward P/E of 11.00, the stock appears undervalued relative to its peers. Analysts project $2.60 EPS for FY2026, implying a 25% year-over-year increase. This growth potential, coupled with a ROE of 10.6% in Q1 2025, suggests the bank is well-positioned to deliver shareholder value.

However, investors must consider sector-wide risks, including regulatory pressures from the re-proposed Basel III Endgame rules. These could increase capital requirements for mid-sized banks like ONB. That said, the bank's robust capital ratios and strategic use of credit risk transfer (CRT) instruments provide a buffer.

Conclusion: A Buy Opportunity?

Old National Bancorp's combination of strong earnings momentum, strategic acquisitions, and favorable valuation metrics makes it a compelling investment ahead of its July 22 earnings release. While the broader regional banking sector faces headwinds from interest rate normalization and regulatory changes, ONB's disciplined execution and community-focused model position it to outperform.

Investors seeking exposure to a bank with a proven ability to balance growth with profitability should consider ONB. The upcoming earnings report will be a key inflection point, offering insights into whether the bank can maintain its Q1 momentum and deliver on Bremer integration synergies. For now, the data supports a "buy" case, particularly for those with a medium-term horizon and an appetite for value-driven growth in the regional banking sector.
"""