Old Mutual's Strategic Turnaround Under New CEO Jurie Strydom: A Compelling Case for Re-entry into African Insurance Markets

The African insurance market, though fragmented and underdeveloped, is poised for explosive growth. By 2033, the continent's insurance market is projected to reach USD 1.49 trillion, driven by rising economic activity, urbanization, and technological adoptionAfrica Insurance Market Size & Growth^[1]. For Old Mutual, a financial services giant with deep roots in Africa, this represents a golden opportunity to reassert its dominance under the leadership of CEO Jurie Strydom. Strydom's appointment in June 2025 marks a pivotal moment for the company, as it seeks to leverage operational reforms, strategic acquisitions, and digital innovation to reclaim market share in a sector defined by both risk and reward.

Operational Reforms: Streamlining for Efficiency and Resilience

Jurie Strydom's tenure has already signaled a shift toward operational discipline. Under his leadership, Old Mutual has restructured its Life & Savings segment, appointing Prabashini Moodley as CEO to focus on simplifying processes and enhancing customer deliveryOld Mutual Appoints Jurie Strydom as CEO^[2]. Strydom's emphasis on cost discipline and efficient capital deployment aligns with broader industry trends, where insurers are recalibrating business models to address rising claims costs and climate-related risks2025 Global Insurance Outlook^[3]. For instance, Old Mutual's rebranding of its multi-manager investment business as “Symmetry” reflects a strategic pivot toward full-service investment solutions, a move that could strengthen its appeal to both institutional and retail clientsOld Mutual Multi-Manager Business Rebrands as 'Symmetry'^[4].

The company's operational reforms also extend to its banking arm. By shifting oversight of Old Mutual Finance and Transaction Services to OM Bank CEO Clarence Nethengwe, Strydom is aligning the group's banking operations with its long-term vision of expanding relationships with existing and new customersOld Mutual Group Reports Strong Earnings^[5]. This restructuring underscores a commitment to leveraging Old Mutual's 346-branch network and R1.5 billion in deposits to deepen market penetrationOld Mutual Group Reports Strong Earnings^[5].

Market Expansion: Targeting Growth in East and West Africa

Old Mutual's expansion strategy under Strydom is anchored in strategic acquisitions and partnerships. In West Africa, the company aims to become one of the top five insurers in Nigeria and Ghana within five years by acquiring local firmsOld Mutual Plans Acquisitions in West Africa^[6]. This approach mirrors broader industry trends, where consolidation is seen as a key driver of scale in fragmented marketsCar Insurance Providers in South Africa^[7]. For example, in Kenya, Old Mutual's H1 2025 results highlighted initiatives like the Thrive wellness program and financial literacy training for 21,800 students, reinforcing its role as a holistic financial partnerResilience Redefined: Old Mutual Kenya’s H1 2025 Results^[8].

The company's focus on East Africa is equally noteworthy. By tailoring products for diaspora investors—such as extended mortgage horizons and climate-linked insurance solutions—Old Mutual is addressing the unique needs of a growing demographicOld Mutual Outlines Diversified Portfolios^[9]. These efforts align with the continent's projected economic growth, which is expected to rise from 3.3% in 2024 to 4.3% by 2026–27Africa Overview: World Bank^[10].

Navigating the Protection Gap and Climate Risks

A critical challenge for African insurers is the continent's staggering protection gap. In 2023, global economic losses from natural disasters reached $357 billion, with 65% of these losses uninsured—particularly pronounced in Africa2025 Global Insurance Outlook^[11]. Old Mutual's investment in advanced data analytics and AI-driven risk modeling positions it to address this gap. For instance, its African Frontiers Flexible Income Strategy emphasizes currency risk management and active market engagement, leveraging its pan-African presence to navigate frontier market complexitiesAfrican Frontiers Flexible Income Strategy^[12].

Moreover, Strydom's leadership has prioritized partnerships with local businesses and ecosystem players to develop innovative products. In Ethiopia and Uganda, for example, Old Mutual is collaborating on climate-linked agricultural insurance, a sector critical to economic resilienceMarketdataforecast.com on Africa Insurance^[13]. These initiatives not only mitigate risks but also align with global trends in prevention-focused financial servicesResilience Redefined: Old Mutual Kenya’s H1 2025 Results^[8].

Challenges and Criticisms: Transformation and Regulatory Hurdles

Despite its strategic momentum, Old Mutual faces headwinds. The Black Management Forum (BMF) has criticized Strydom's appointment as a setback for economic transformation in South Africa, where 81% of the population is Black but most live in povertyTransformation Fund and Empowerment Codes^[14]. This criticism highlights the need for Old Mutual to balance growth with inclusive leadership, a challenge that could impact its reputation and regulatory standing.

Additionally, the African insurance market remains hindered by low financial literacy, macroeconomic instability, and data scarcityDWIC 2025: Africa’s Insurance Leaders^[15]. Strydom's emphasis on digital innovation—such as mobile financial services and AI-driven platforms—could mitigate these barriers, but success will depend on sustained investment in infrastructure and talent.

Future Outlook: A Compelling Investment Case

Old Mutual's strategic initiatives under Strydom present a compelling case for re-entry into African insurance markets. With the continent's insurance sector growing at an 11.70% CAGR from 2025 to 2033Africa Insurance Market Size & Growth^[1], the company's focus on operational efficiency, digital innovation, and tailored products positions it to capture market share. Moreover, its ability to navigate regulatory complexities and address the protection gap could drive long-term profitability.

Conclusion

Jurie Strydom's leadership marks a turning point for Old Mutual. By combining operational rigor with strategic expansion, the company is well-positioned to capitalize on Africa's insurance growth while addressing systemic challenges. For investors, this represents a high-conviction opportunity in a sector where resilience and innovation are rewarded.