MSCI's China Stock Cull: A Blow to Market Confidence

Despite a recent market rebound, MSCI Inc. continues to remove Chinese stocks from its indexes, raising concerns about the outlook for the world's second-largest economy. The index provider announced it will remove 60 stocks from the MSCI China Index this month, following 56 deletions in May and 66 in February. This trend highlights the grim prospects for China's equity market and its potential impact on global investors.



The deletions may further increase the downside for China's already battered market, with index-tracking funds forced to sell these shares. The largest such fund, the US-listed iShares MSCI China ETF, is part of the at least $7.9 billion tracking the MSCI China Index. This selling pressure could exacerbate the existing market downturn, as investors grapple with the reality of China's economic slowdown and policy uncertainty.

The deletions help "even the playing field for EM investors," according to Marvin Chen, a strategist with Bloomberg Intelligence in Hong Kong. This means that the large weighting and impact of China earlier may be more evenly distributed to other markets such as India, Korea, and Taiwan. This shift in allocations could lead to increased investment in these markets, potentially benefiting their economies and financial markets.

In contrast to the deletions in China, MSCI has announced the addition of seven stocks to its India gauge, including Samsung Electronics Co.'s supplier Dixon Technologies India Ltd. This move could attract significant inflows to the Indian market, further shifting the balance of investment away from China. For instance, HDFC Bank is set to gain the most, with its increased weight likely to attract $1.8 billion of inflows in the near term and another $1.8 billion by November.



The deletions of Chinese stocks from MSCI's global benchmarks, totaling nearly 200 in 2024 alone, have significantly impacted the overall representation of Chinese equities in these indexes. As of the end of July 2024, China represented only 22.33% of the Emerging Markets gauge, down from its previous outsized presence. This reduction in representation is due to the removal of dozens of Chinese securities from MSCI's global benchmarks for the third consecutive quarter.

The potential consequences for China's financial market are twofold: increased downside risk for China's market and a shift in allocations towards other emerging markets. The deletions may further increase the downside for China's already battered market, as index-tracking funds are forced to sell these shares. This selling pressure could exacerbate the existing market downturn. Additionally, the shift in allocations towards other emerging markets could lead to increased investment in these markets, potentially benefiting their economies and financial markets.

In conclusion, MSCI's decision to remove more Chinese stocks from its indexes, despite the recent market rebound, underscores the grim prospects for the world's second-largest economy. The deletions may further increase the downside for China's already battered market and shift allocations towards other emerging markets, potentially benefiting their economies and financial markets. Investors should closely monitor the situation and consider adjusting their portfolios accordingly.