Miniso's TOP TOY Spin-off: A Play for the Future or a Risky Gamble?

The global toy market is undergoing a transformation, with Chinese brands like POP MART and TOP TOY (a subsidiary of MINISO) leading the charge in the "collectible craze." MINISO's decision to spin off TOP TOY and pursue a Hong Kong IPO—a move backed by JPMorgan and UBS—has sparked debate over whether this is a strategic bet on long-term growth or a premature play in an overvalued sector. Let's dissect the numbers, risks, and opportunities.

The Momentum Behind TOP TOY

TOP TOY's rapid rise is undeniable. Its revenue surged 58.9% year-over-year to $46.8 million in Q1 2025, while its store count expanded to 280 globally—a 120-store increase since 2024. The brand's focus on IP-driven products (e.g., blind boxes, plush toys, and licensed collaborations like its Stitch-themed Hong Kong flagship store) has resonated with "kidult" consumers.

.

The strategic rationale for the spin-off is clear: separate valuation. By isolating TOP TOY's high-margin (44.2% gross margin in Q1 2025) and fast-growing business, MINISO aims to unlock value akin to POP MART, which now commands a $33.6 billion valuation—far surpassing legacy players like Mattel ($5.1B) and Hasbro ($8.7B).

Valuation: Riding the Wave or Overvalued?

POP MART's success highlights the power of IP and collectibles. Its LABUBU and SKULLPANDA IPs generated explosive revenue growth (726.6% and 106.9% respectively in 2024), while overseas sales surged 375% in Q1 2025. If TOP TOY can replicate this, its IPO could be a hit. However, risks loom:

1. Market Saturation: The plush toy category alone accounts for 21.7% of TOP TOY's revenue, and while demand has been robust (POP MART's plush sales jumped 1,289% in 2024), there's no guarantee this trend will endure. Competitors like TOPTOY (also under MINISO) and 52Toys (which filed for an IPO but reported losses) are vying for the same market.
2. Fad Dependency: Blind boxes and trending IPs are cyclical. If consumer interest wanes, revenue could crater. POP MART's older IPs like Molly have seen declining sales, forcing reliance on newer franchises.
3. Geopolitical Risks: TOP TOY's expansion hinges on overseas markets, where supply chain disruptions (e.g., U.S. tariffs) and IP disputes could derail growth.

Spin-offs Post-Pandemic: Success or Cautionary Tale?

The post-pandemic era has seen mixed results for spin-offs. POP MART's 460% stock surge since 2020 is a gold standard, but 52Toys' recent IPO struggles (despite revenue growth) underscore the risks. Investors now demand sustainable IP pipelines and profitability beyond fads. TOP TOY's current 58.9% revenue growth is impressive, but its net margin (not disclosed) must keep pace with gross margin to avoid dilution.

Investment Implications: Timing and Risks

• Bull Case: If TOP TOY's IPO proceeds fund IP acquisitions, global store expansion, and supply chain resilience, it could become the next POP MART. MINISO's core business (discount retail) gains flexibility to focus on cost-cutting.
• Bear Case: Overvaluation in a saturated market, coupled with reliance on fickle trends, could lead to a "POP MART correction" (if its growth slows).

Actionable Insights:
1. Wait for Details: The IPO's timing and valuation multiples (e.g., EV/EBITDA vs. POP MART's 20x+) are critical.
2. Monitor IP Cycles: Track TOP TOY's new IP launches and retention rates for existing franchises.
3. Geographic Diversification: Assess whether overseas expansion (currently 38.9% of POP MART's revenue) is sustainable for TOP TOY.

Conclusion: A High-Reward, High-Risk Gamble

MINISO's TOP TOY spin-off is a bold move to capitalize on the collectibles boom. While the brand's growth and strategic partnerships (e.g., Disney's Stitch) are promising, investors must weigh the risks of market saturation and IP lifecycle management. For now, the best approach is to wait for IPO specifics and valuation metrics before committing. If TOP TOY can prove its global appeal and IP longevity, this could be a transformative play. Otherwise, it may become another cautionary tale of overhyped spin-offs.