Michael Saylor’s Strategy and the Road to S&P 500 Inclusion: Risks and Opportunities for Investors

The inclusion of a crypto-adjacent stock in the S&P 500 is no longer a fringe possibility—it’s a seismic event reshaping the financial landscape. For Michael Saylor’s Strategy (formerly MicroStrategy, MSTR), the road to S&P 500 inclusion has reached a critical inflection point. With a market capitalization exceeding $90 billion and a Bitcoin treasury valued at $65–$69 billion, Strategy has met the index’s eligibility criteria, including profitability, liquidity, and U.S. listing requirements. The S&P 500 committee is set to announce its decision on September 5, 2025, with changes effective September 19 [1]. If approved, Strategy would become the first Bitcoin-treasury company to join the index, signaling a watershed moment for digital assets in traditional finance.

The Opportunity: Liquidity, Valuation, and Institutional Inflows

Historical precedent suggests that S&P 500 inclusion can catalyze explosive price action. When Coinbase Global (COIN) joined the index in May 2025, its stock surged 24% in a single day due to mandatory purchases by index-tracking funds [2]. For Strategy, analysts estimate that inclusion could trigger up to $16 billion in institutional buying from passive funds, given its market cap and the index’s rules [3]. This influx would not only boost liquidity but also validate the company’s Bitcoin-centric business model, potentially attracting a broader base of institutional investors.

Strategy’s financials further amplify the opportunity. The company reported $14 billion in operating income and $10 billion in net income for Q2 2025, driven by new fair-value accounting standards that recognize unrealized gains on its Bitcoin holdings [4]. This accounting shift has transformed Strategy from a software company into a hybrid entity blending traditional enterprise software with crypto treasury management—a unique value proposition in the S&P 500.

The Risks: Volatility, Regulatory Scrutiny, and Systemic Exposure

Yet, the risks are equally profound. Strategy’s stock has exhibited extreme volatility, with 30-day price swings exceeding 96%—a red flag for the S&P committee, which prioritizes stability [5]. While the company has met profitability thresholds, its reliance on Bitcoin’s price action for valuation introduces a layer of unpredictability. A sharp decline in Bitcoin’s price could trigger forced liquidations, compounding market instability [6].

Regulatory headwinds add another layer of complexity. Nasdaq’s recent requirement for shareholder approval of crypto-related deals has already caused declines in crypto-adjacent stocks like Strategy and MARA Holdings [7]. This tightening of oversight reflects a broader skepticism toward speculative crypto plays, which could dampen investor enthusiasm even if Strategy is included in the S&P 500.

Moreover, the growing correlation between the S&P 500 and crypto markets—now at a 40-day coefficient of 0.67—highlights systemic risks [8]. While this alignment may benefit Strategy during bull markets, it also means that downturns could see synchronized declines in both stocks and Bitcoin. For example, during the Trump tariff announcements in April 2025, the correlation between the two markets spiked to nearly 90%, amplifying losses [9].

A Dual-Edged Sword: Market Dynamics and Investor Sentiment

The inclusion of Strategy in the S&P 500 would force millions of index-tracking investors—ranging from ETFs to retirement portfolios—to indirectly engage with Bitcoin. This could further entrench the link between crypto and traditional markets, creating a feedback loop where Bitcoin’s performance directly impacts stock valuations [10]. However, this interdependence also raises questions about market resilience. If Bitcoin’s volatility spills into the S&P 500, it could destabilize the index’s reputation as a bellwether for stable, blue-chip equities.

For investors, the key question is whether the potential rewards outweigh the risks. On one hand, Strategy’s inclusion could unlock unprecedented liquidity and institutional credibility. On the other, its exposure to Bitcoin’s volatility and regulatory uncertainty makes it a high-risk bet. The company’s success hinges on Bitcoin’s ability to maintain its value proposition amid macroeconomic headwinds, such as inflationary pressures or a Fed pivot.

Conclusion: A Pivotal Moment for Crypto-Adjacent Investing

Strategy’s potential inclusion in the S&P 500 is more than a corporate milestone—it’s a litmus test for the broader acceptance of crypto in traditional finance. For investors, the decision offers a rare opportunity to capitalize on a paradigm shift, but it also demands a nuanced understanding of the risks. As the September 5 announcement looms, the market will be watching closely: Will the S&P 500 embrace Bitcoin’s future, or will it reinforce the boundaries between crypto and conventional equities?

Source:
[1] MSTR Qualifies for S&P 500, Inclusion Decision Awaits ..., [https://www.coindesk.com/markets/2025/09/01/strategy-qualifies-for-s-and-p-500-inclusion-decision-could-come-on-friday]
[2] Coinbase Soars 24% on S&P 500 Inclusion, [https://www.nasdaq.com/articles/coinbase-soars-24-sp-500-inclusion-what-lies-ahead-etfs]
[3] S&P 500 Potential: Strategy Could See $16 Billion Inflows, [https://www.mitrade.com/insights/news/live-news/article-3-1098666-20250905]
[4] Strategy Qualifies for S&P 500, Inclusion Decision Could ..., [https://ca.finance.yahoo.com/news/strategy-qualifies-p-500-inclusion-093743829.html]
[5] S&P 500 Potential: Strategy Could See $16 Billion Inflows ..., [https://www.mitrade.com/insights/news/live-news/article-3-1098666-20250905]
[6] Why the S&P 500 committee could deny MSTR inclusion ..., [https://protos.com/why-the-sp-500-committee-could-deny-mstr-inclusion-on-friday/]
[7] Strategy shares decline as Nasdaq tightens crypto scrutiny, [https://www.investing.com/news/stock-market-news/strategy-shares-decline-as-nasdaq-tightens-crypto-scrutiny-4224874]
[8] Crypto and stocks share strongest positive correlation in ..., [https://www.theblock.co/post/317662/crypto-stocks-correlation-fed-rate-cut]
[9] The S&P 500 Just Embraced Crypto: Here's How It Affects ..., [https://www.investopedia.com/sp500-crypto-coinbase-11742673]
[10] Coinbase's S&P 500 Debut and Bitcoin's Bright Future, [https://www.gate.com/tr/crypto-wiki/article/coinbase-s-s-p-500-debut-and-bitcoin-s-bright-future]