Howmet Aerospace: A High-Flying Story of Growth and Margins Amid Valuation Headwinds

In the summer of 2025, Howmet Aerospace (NYSE:HWM) delivered a Q2 performance that defied even the most optimistic expectations. Revenue surged 9% year-over-year to $2.05 billion, with earnings per share (EPS) soaring to $1.00 from $0.65 in the same period last year. Adjusted EBITDA hit $589 million, and operating margins expanded by 420 basis points to 25.4%. These numbers are not just impressive—they are a testament to the company's ability to capitalize on the global aerospace renaissance while refining its operational efficiency. Yet, as investors cheer the record $344 million in free cash flow and raised full-year guidance, a critical question lingers: Is this stock still a buy, or has the market already priced in all the good news? Historically, HWM has shown strong performance following earnings releases, with a 78.57% win rate over 10 days and an average return of 2.17% over 30 days.

A Recipe for Margin Expansion

Howmet's margin compression in recent years has been a source of frustration for long-term investors. But Q2 2025 tells a different story. The company's Engine Products segment, which accounts for 54% of revenue, saw adjusted EBITDA margins jump to 33.0%, driven by strong demand for turbine blades in both commercial and defense aerospace. Meanwhile, the Fastening Systems division, a cash cow with 29.2% margins, outperformed expectations as global aircraft production cycles remain robust. Even in segments like Engineered Structures, where revenue grew 5% year-over-year, margins held steady at 21.4%, reflecting disciplined cost management.

The key to this margin expansion lies in Howmet's dual focus on pricing power and cost discipline. With aerospace OEMs (original equipment manufacturers) locked in multi-year supply agreements, Howmet has leveraged its technical expertise to secure favorable pricing terms. At the same time, its lean manufacturing initiatives and automation investments have reduced per-unit costs. The result? A company that is not only growing but doing so profitably.

Free Cash Flow and Shareholder Returns

Free cash flow of $344 million in Q2—nearly 10% of revenue—is a green light for capital allocation. Howmet has used this firepower to return value to shareholders through a 20% dividend hike and $175 million in buybacks. The company also reduced debt by $76 million, trimming its leverage ratio to a more comfortable 2.1x EBITDA. For investors, this signals a balance sheet that is both strong and flexible.

But the real intrigue lies in the full-year guidance. Howmet now expects revenue between $8.08 billion and $8.18 billion, up from a previous range of $7.95 billion to $8.10 billion. This revision, coupled with its trailing 12-month EBITDA of $2.01 billion, suggests the company is on track to exceed $2.1 billion in annual operating profit—a threshold that would cement its status as a high-margin aerospace leader.

Valuation: A Double-Edged Sword

The challenge, however, is the stock's lofty valuation. At a trailing P/E of 62.78 and a PEG ratio of 2.72, HWM trades at a premium to both its historical averages and industry peers like Raytheon (P/E: 34.1) and Triumph Group (P/E: 50.02). The EV/EBITDA ratio of 40.09 is equally eye-catching, implying that investors are paying over 40 times earnings to participate in Howmet's growth story.

These multiples are not without justification. Analysts project a five-year EPS growth rate of 24.64%, driven by the global aerospace recovery and Howmet's dominant position in high-margin segments. Yet, the market's willingness to pay such a premium raises questions. Is the stock trading on its fundamentals, or is it being propelled by a broader narrative of “aerospace as the new tech sector”?

Insider Activity: Caution or Compensation?

The other elephant in the room is insider selling. Over the past three months, corporate insiders have offloaded $130.9 million in shares, including a blockbuster indirect sale by CEO John Plant of 125.5 million shares in May 2025. CFO Ken Giacobbe and officer Neil Marchuk also sold millions of dollars' worth of stock, raising red flags for some investors.

While stock awards and grants (which are part of standard compensation packages) account for some of this activity, the magnitude of the direct sales cannot be ignored. Insiders are typically the best judges of their company's prospects, and heavy selling—especially by top executives—can signal overconfidence in their personal financial planning or a lack of conviction in the stock's future.

That said, it's worth noting that Howmet's institutional investors have been net buyers. PFG Advisors and GPS Wealth Strategies Group LLC increased their stakes by 37.9% and 114.6%, respectively, in Q1 2025. With 90.46% of shares held by institutions, the broader market appears to have more patience than the insiders.

The Long-Term Verdict

Howmet Aerospace's Q2 results are a masterclass in operational execution. Its margin expansion, free cash flow generation, and strategic positioning in the aerospace sector are undeniably compelling. Yet, the stock's valuation is a hurdle. At 62x earnings, HWM trades at a level that assumes perfect execution for years to come—a tall order in a cyclical industry.

For long-term investors, the key is to balance optimism with caution. If the company can maintain its margin momentum and deliver on its full-year guidance, the stock may justify its premium. But if execution falters or aerospace demand softens, the high valuation could become a drag.

Investment Takeaway:
Howmet Aerospace remains a high-conviction story for those comfortable with its valuation premium. Investors should monitor two metrics: 1) the pace of margin expansion, and 2) insider selling activity. A pullback in the stock price or a slowdown in margin growth could create a more attractive entry point. For now, a cautious “hold” is warranted, with a watchful eye on Q3 results and the broader aerospace cycle.

"""