Hong Leong Bank Berhad: Earnings Growth Outpaces Shareholder Value Creation-A Closer Look at the Misalignment

Hong Leong Bank Berhad (KLSE:HLBANK) has demonstrated robust earnings growth over the past five years, with an average annual earnings growth rate of 11.7% from 2018 to 2023, outpacing the 11.4% industry average for Malaysian banks, according to a Minichart outlook. Earnings per share (EPS) expanded at a near-identical 11.67% annualized rate during the same period, underscoring the bank's ability to translate top-line growth into profitability. However, this strong earnings performance has not translated into commensurate shareholder value creation. For instance, while EPS grew at 10% annually over five years, the stock price appreciated by only 8% annually, according to a Yahoo Finance article, resulting in a total shareholder return (TSR) of 73% over the same period. This divergence raises critical questions about the bank's capital allocation strategies and reinvestment efficiency.

Earnings Growth vs. Shareholder Returns: The Gap Widens

The disconnect between earnings and shareholder value becomes evident when analyzing Hong Leong's financial metrics. Despite a return on equity (ROE) of 11.16% and a return on assets (ROA) of 1.40% as of 2025, according to Simply Wall St, the bank's stock price growth lags behind its earnings trajectory. This suggests that while Hong Leong generates solid returns for its operations, the market may not be fully valuing these earnings. For context, the Malaysian banking sector's ROE averaged 12% in Q2 2024 (Minichart), indicating that Hong Leong's ROE is competitive but not exceptional.

A key factor in this misalignment lies in the bank's capital allocation policies. Hong Leong has maintained a consistent dividend payout, with yields ranging from 1.67% in 2020 to 2.74% in 2023 (Minichart), and a payout ratio of 32–34% in recent years (Simply Wall St). While this provides a reliable income stream for shareholders, it leaves room for more aggressive returns to shareholders, such as share buybacks. Notably, the bank has no publicly disclosed share repurchase program since its 2013 initiative (Simply Wall St), which limited treasury holdings to 10% of issued shares. This absence of buybacks contrasts with peers like CIMB and RHB, which have occasionally used buybacks to boost shareholder value.

Historical patterns around earnings releases further highlight the challenges of aligning earnings growth with stock performance. A backtest of HLBANK's price behavior since 2022 reveals a short-term negative drift: the stock typically declines by ~1.9% within the first two weeks post-earnings, with a trough around day 10. However, by day 28–30, the average return turns positive (~+2.6%), and the hit rate improves from ~41% early on to ~60% by day 30. This suggests that while the initial market reaction to earnings may be mixed, patient investors who hold through the initial volatility have historically been rewarded. These findings underscore the importance of timing and patience in capturing the full value of Hong Leong's earnings growth.

Reinvestment Efficiency: A Mixed Picture

Hong Leong's reinvestment efficiency, as measured by return on invested capital (ROIC), appears to align with industry norms. As of 2025, the bank's projected ROIC of 11.2% (Minichart) exceeds the sector average, outperforming peers such as Maybank (10.7%) and RHB Bank (9.6%) (Minichart). This suggests that Hong Leong's management is allocating capital effectively, with a focus on high-return initiatives such as digital transformation and regional wealth management expansion (Minichart). However, the bank's operating cash flow turned negative (-MYR 23.06 billion in the last 12 months, Simply Wall St), partially offset by capital expenditures of -MYR 101.13 million (Simply Wall St), raises concerns about the sustainability of these investments. If these projects fail to generate returns above the cost of capital in the long term, the current ROIC figures may not hold.

Strategic Priorities and Market Dynamics

Hong Leong's capital allocation strategy appears to prioritize liquidity and risk management. The bank maintains a net cash position of MYR 7.70 billion (Simply Wall St), reflecting a conservative approach to balance sheet strength. While this provides a buffer against economic volatility, it also limits opportunities for high-impact reinvestment or shareholder returns. Additionally, the bank's focus on expanding its Global Markets franchise and digital infrastructure (Minichart) may take years to yield tangible benefits for shareholders.

Market dynamics further complicate the valuation equation. Malaysian banks, including Hong Leong, trade at price-to-earnings (PE) ratios near their three-year averages (Yahoo Finance), suggesting that investors are not overpaying for earnings growth. However, this also implies that the market is not rewarding Hong Leong's outperformance relative to peers with a premium valuation. For example, Maybank and CIMB, despite lower ROICs, have higher dividend yields and more aggressive buyback programs, which may explain their stronger stock price performance.

Conclusion: A Call for Strategic Rebalancing

Hong Leong Bank Berhad's earnings growth is a testament to its operational discipline and prudent risk management. However, the bank's failure to fully capitalize on this growth through aggressive shareholder returns or transformative reinvestment has led to a misalignment between earnings and value creation. While its ROIC outperforms peers, the absence of a buyback program and a relatively modest dividend yield suggest untapped potential to enhance shareholder value. For investors, the key question is whether Hong Leong will rebalance its capital allocation strategy to prioritize returns to shareholders without compromising its long-term growth ambitions. Until then, the gap between earnings and valuation will likely persist.

```