Harvey Norman Holdings: Reconciling Price Momentum with Weak Earnings and ROE

The stock price of Harvey Norman Holdings (ASX:HVN) has surged in recent months, defying its mixed financial fundamentals. While the company's valuation metrics suggest it trades at a discount to peers, its earnings growth and return on equity (ROE) remain underwhelming. This article explores whether the stock is overvalued or if the market is forward-looking, leveraging Harvey Norman's strategic strengths and industry tailwinds to justify its momentum.

Valuation Metrics: A Discounted Retail Giant

Harvey Norman's trailing P/E ratio of 17.4x (as of August 2025) is significantly lower than the Australian retail sector average of 31.4x and the global multiline retail industry average of 21.0x. This 50% discount to peers suggests the market is undervaluing the company's profitability and cash flow generation. The Price-to-Book (P/B) ratio of 1.59 and Price-to-Sales (P/S) ratio of 2.67 further reinforce this narrative, as both metrics are in line with or below fair value estimates.

The company's valuation appears attractive when compared to its intrinsic value. A 2-stage Free Cash Flow to Equity model estimates a fair value of AU$5.92, while the current share price of AU$6.03 is near this level. Analysts' 12-month price target of AU$4.92 implies a potential downside, but this may reflect skepticism about earnings sustainability rather than intrinsic value.

Earnings and ROE: A Tale of Two Periods

Harvey Norman's ROE of 9.41% (TTM) is a 32.8% decline from its 10-year average of 14.01% and lags behind peers like JB Hi-Fi (28.98%) and Super Retail Group (16.91%). This underperformance reflects weaker profitability and asset efficiency. However, the company's recent earnings growth of 15.6% in the full year 2024 outperformed its 5-year average of -7.3% and the industry benchmark of 2.1%.

The disconnect between valuation and fundamentals can be explained by two factors:
1. Property Portfolio Resilience: Harvey Norman's $4.39 billion property portfolio, which accounts for 53.2% of total assets, generates stable rental income and capital appreciation. This asset base acts as a buffer during retail downturns and is not fully reflected in traditional valuation metrics.
2. Franchise Model Strength: Franchisee sales grew by 9.0% in November–December 2024 and 7.2% in early 2025, driven by a recovery in home renovation and AI PC demand. The franchise model's scalability and margin expansion (from 4.52% to 5.40% in 1H25) suggest earnings could stabilize or improve.

The recent 2.55% price increase following the 1H25 earnings report highlights investor optimism about the company's ability to navigate challenges. However, the 5-year earnings decline (-7.79%) and ROE contraction remain red flags.

Strategic Moves and Industry Tailwinds

The Australian retail sector is experiencing a recovery fueled by improving consumer sentiment and a stabilizing housing market. Harvey Norman's focus on discretionary categories like furniture and appliances positions it to benefit from this trend. Additionally, the AI PC product cycle is boosting electronics sales, a segment where the company has a strong presence.

The company's geographic diversification across eight countries and its integrated business model (retail, franchising, property) provide resilience against domestic retail cycles. While international markets like Ireland and New Zealand face challenges, the core Australian business is showing resilience. Gerry Harvey's recent investment in PNG cement also signals a strategic pivot toward infrastructure-related opportunities, diversifying revenue streams.

Analyst Sentiment and Market Dynamics

Analyst ratings are mixed, with six “Buy,” four “Hold,” and three “Sell” ratings as of August 2025. Jefferies upgraded the stock to “Buy,” citing improved demand in Australia, while UBS downgraded it to “Neutral,” reflecting caution about earnings sustainability. The stock's beta of 0.765 and low volatility suggest it is less sensitive to market swings, making it a defensive play in a volatile environment.

Investment Thesis: Undervalued or Overhyped?

Harvey Norman's valuation metrics suggest it is undervalued relative to peers and intrinsic value. The market appears to be discounting the company's property portfolio and franchise model strengths while underappreciating its ability to adapt to industry trends. However, the weak ROE and earnings history warrant caution.

Investment Advice:
- Bull Case: Investors who believe in the recovery of the Australian retail sector and the company's ability to leverage its property and franchise assets should consider a long position. The stock's current price near intrinsic value and low valuation multiples offer a margin of safety.
- Bear Case: Those concerned about earnings sustainability and ROE underperformance may prefer to wait for a pullback or clearer signs of operational improvement.

In conclusion, Harvey Norman Holdings is not overvalued but rather undervalued in the context of its strategic strengths and industry tailwinds. The key risk lies in its ability to sustain earnings growth and improve ROE. For patient investors, the stock offers an attractive risk-reward profile.
"""