Grocery Outlet: A Contrarian Gem in the Defensive Retail Play

Grocery Outlet Holding Corp (NASDAQ: GO) has just been added to the Russell 2000 Value-Defensive Index—a move that's no accident for this $1.1 billion discount retailer. This inclusion marks a strategic repositioning of GO as a defensive play in an era of economic uncertainty. But here's the twist: while the market frets over recession risks, GO's “treasure hunt” business model and margin resilience are creating a buying opportunity that's too big to ignore. Let's dig in.

The “Treasure Hunt” Model: Resilience in Disguise

Grocery Outlet's stores are designed to feel like a daily treasure hunt, with markdowns, bulk deals, and irregularly stocked shelves. This model isn't just gimmicky—it's a masterclass in price-sensitive consumer engagement. Shoppers love the thrill of finding steals (think $0.99 bananas or $5 cases of wine), while Grocery Outlet maintains astonishing margins. In Q1 2025, gross margins hit 30.4%, up 110 basis points year-over-year, proving that discount retail doesn't have to mean low profitability.

This model thrives when consumers are pinching pennies—a key defensive trait. Even as Walmart (WMT) and Target (TGT) struggle with inflation-driven sales pressures, GO's comparable store sales grew 0.3% in Q1. Sure, April's 2% dip in average basket sizes is a red flag, but this is a tactical issue, not a death knell. The real story is the operational discipline: restructuring charges ($33.9M) to close underperforming stores and focus on high-growth markets show management isn't afraid to cut losses and invest in winners.

The Defensive Case: Margins, Stores, and Institutional Inflows

The Russell 2000 Value-Defensive Index inclusion isn't just a label—it's a liquidity catalyst. Passive funds tracking the index will have no choice but to buy GO shares, driving volume and stabilizing the stock. This is especially true as the reconstitution takes effect on June 30, 2025, with $2 trillion in passive assets rebalancing.

But the real kicker is store expansion. GO plans to open 33–35 new stores annually, with 85% franchised—a scalable model that requires minimal upfront capital. With only 1% of U.S. grocery sales, there's massive untapped potential. Meanwhile, adjusted EBITDA surged 31.7% to $51.9M in Q1, fueled by better inventory management.

The Contrarian Play: Valuation Gap and Long-Term Catalysts

Here's where it gets juicy: valuation. GO trades at a 25.3x P/E, well below its 5-year average of 31x. GuruFocus sees a 174.5% upside to its $38.32 target, while the average analyst target is more conservative at $15.62. This gap is a contrarian's dream—a stock that's been punished for near-term noise (executive transitions, April sales slumps) but is fundamentally undervalued.

The risks? Absolutely. Inflation could squeeze margins, and competition from giants like Walmart is real. But here's why I'm betting on GO:
- Its independent operator model (85% franchised) scales without diluting control.
- Debt is manageable at 1.8x net leverage vs. EBITDA.
- Consumer staples dominance is a recession hedge—people buy groceries no matter what.

Time to Buy? Yes, But with a Plan

This isn't a “set it and forget it” play. The stock is volatile, and the next few quarters will test its ability to rebound sales. Investors should:
1. Average in: Start with a small position, adding on dips.
2. Watch margins: If gross margins dip below 29%, it's a red flag.
3. Track store openings: 35 new stores in 2025? That's growth.

The Russell inclusion alone could push GO past $15 by Q4—18% upside from current levels. But the real win comes if the “treasure hunt” model captures even 2% of U.S. grocery sales. That's a $8 billion revenue play, and GO isn't priced for that.

Final Take: A Defensive Gem with Growth Legs

Grocery Outlet isn't just a discount retailer—it's a recession-proof machine with a growth engine. The Russell inclusion is validation, not a gimmick. Yes, there are risks, but the valuation gap, store pipeline, and margin resilience make this a buy now, hold forever stock.

Action Alert: GO is a contrarian's goldmine. Buy the dip to $12.50, and hold for the next 12–18 months. The Russell inflows and store growth will do the rest.

—
Disclosure: The author does not hold a position in GO as of publication.