French Inflation Below ECB's 2% Target: A Persistent Divergence
Thursday, Oct 31, 2024 4:16 am ET
3min read French inflation has remained below the European Central Bank's (ECB) 2% target for the second consecutive month, with the Harmonised Index of Consumer Prices (HICP) rising by 3.4% in January 2024, after +4.1% in December. This persistent divergence between French inflation and the ECB's target raises questions about the factors contributing to this gap and the potential impact on French inflation expectations and market behavior.
The composition of the French consumer price index (CPI) basket differs from the ECB's HICP basket, with a higher weight assigned to services (48%) and lower weights to food (16%) and energy (9%). This composition affects inflation dynamics in France, with services inflation often being more persistent and less volatile than food and energy inflation. In January 2024, the French CPI rose by 3.1% year-on-year, with services inflation accelerating to 3.2% and energy inflation slowing to 1.8%. This compositional difference contributes to the divergence between French and euro area inflation rates, with the latter measured by the HICP.
Housing costs, currently excluded from the HICP, account for a significant portion of household expenditure in France (around 18% according to the French National Institute for Statistics and Economic Studies). As housing costs are expected to rise, their inclusion in the HICP could potentially push French inflation closer to the ECB's target. However, the persistent gap between French inflation and the ECB's target suggests that other factors, such as domestic economic conditions and fiscal policy, may also play a role in this divergence.
French labor market dynamics, such as wage rigidities and unemployment, influence the persistent divergence between French inflation and the ECB's 2% target. Despite robust economic growth, wage increases have been modest, with average annual wage growth of 1.6% in 2021. This sluggish wage growth, coupled with a relatively high unemployment rate of 7.4% in April 2024, has limited cost pressures and contributed to the subdued inflation rate. Additionally, the French labor market exhibits downward nominal wage rigidities, making it difficult for wages to adjust downwards during economic downturns. This further constrains wage growth and, consequently, inflation.
Geopolitical factors, notably the war in Ukraine and the global economic reopening, have significantly impacted French inflation. The war has driven up energy and food prices, while the reopening has led to supply bottlenecks, pushing up inflation. However, these factors have had a more pronounced effect on French inflation due to its heavy reliance on energy imports and the war's direct impact on French agriculture. Despite the ECB's symmetric 2% target, French inflation has remained below this threshold, reflecting the unique domestic pressures.
The ECB's new symmetric 2% inflation target, announced in July 2021, has helped anchor inflation expectations in France. Following the announcement, the ECB Survey of Monetary Analysts showed an increase in respondents expecting long-run inflation at 2%, with a decline in those expecting inflation below 2%. According to the latest survey round, the median respondent expects inflation to be exactly 2.0% as of the fourth quarter of 2024. This suggests that both medium-term and long-term inflation expectations are firmly anchored at the new target. However, French inflation has remained below the 2% target for the second consecutive month, indicating that other factors may be at play.
The ECB's flexible medium-term orientation allows for short-term deviations of inflation from target, enabling a lengthening of the horizon over which inflation is brought back to target. This avoids pronounced falls in economic activity and employment, which could jeopardise medium-term price stability. As long as inflation expectations remain well-anchored, the ECB can extend this horizon. However, if inflation expectations become unanchored, the ECB may need to tighten policy more aggressively.
The ECB's forward guidance and communication strategies play a crucial role in shaping inflation expectations and, consequently, French inflation dynamics. By providing clear and consistent communication, the ECB can help anchor long-term inflation expectations closer to its 2% target. This, in turn, can influence wage and price-setting behavior in France, ultimately affecting domestic inflation. However, the effectiveness of forward guidance depends on the credibility of the central bank and the alignment of market expectations with its policy intentions. The ECB's recent adoption of a symmetric 2% inflation target and its acknowledgment of the need for forceful monetary policy action when operating close to the lower bound on nominal interest rates are steps towards enhancing the credibility of its forward guidance. Nevertheless, the ECB must continue to refine its communication strategies to ensure that its forward guidance is well understood and effectively transmitted to French inflation dynamics.
In conclusion, the persistent divergence between French inflation and the ECB's 2% target highlights the importance of understanding the unique domestic pressures and geopolitical factors influencing French inflation dynamics. As the ECB refines its forward guidance and communication strategies, investors should monitor the evolution of French inflation expectations and market behavior to assess the potential impact on the French economy and the broader euro area.
The composition of the French consumer price index (CPI) basket differs from the ECB's HICP basket, with a higher weight assigned to services (48%) and lower weights to food (16%) and energy (9%). This composition affects inflation dynamics in France, with services inflation often being more persistent and less volatile than food and energy inflation. In January 2024, the French CPI rose by 3.1% year-on-year, with services inflation accelerating to 3.2% and energy inflation slowing to 1.8%. This compositional difference contributes to the divergence between French and euro area inflation rates, with the latter measured by the HICP.
Housing costs, currently excluded from the HICP, account for a significant portion of household expenditure in France (around 18% according to the French National Institute for Statistics and Economic Studies). As housing costs are expected to rise, their inclusion in the HICP could potentially push French inflation closer to the ECB's target. However, the persistent gap between French inflation and the ECB's target suggests that other factors, such as domestic economic conditions and fiscal policy, may also play a role in this divergence.
French labor market dynamics, such as wage rigidities and unemployment, influence the persistent divergence between French inflation and the ECB's 2% target. Despite robust economic growth, wage increases have been modest, with average annual wage growth of 1.6% in 2021. This sluggish wage growth, coupled with a relatively high unemployment rate of 7.4% in April 2024, has limited cost pressures and contributed to the subdued inflation rate. Additionally, the French labor market exhibits downward nominal wage rigidities, making it difficult for wages to adjust downwards during economic downturns. This further constrains wage growth and, consequently, inflation.
Geopolitical factors, notably the war in Ukraine and the global economic reopening, have significantly impacted French inflation. The war has driven up energy and food prices, while the reopening has led to supply bottlenecks, pushing up inflation. However, these factors have had a more pronounced effect on French inflation due to its heavy reliance on energy imports and the war's direct impact on French agriculture. Despite the ECB's symmetric 2% target, French inflation has remained below this threshold, reflecting the unique domestic pressures.
The ECB's new symmetric 2% inflation target, announced in July 2021, has helped anchor inflation expectations in France. Following the announcement, the ECB Survey of Monetary Analysts showed an increase in respondents expecting long-run inflation at 2%, with a decline in those expecting inflation below 2%. According to the latest survey round, the median respondent expects inflation to be exactly 2.0% as of the fourth quarter of 2024. This suggests that both medium-term and long-term inflation expectations are firmly anchored at the new target. However, French inflation has remained below the 2% target for the second consecutive month, indicating that other factors may be at play.
The ECB's flexible medium-term orientation allows for short-term deviations of inflation from target, enabling a lengthening of the horizon over which inflation is brought back to target. This avoids pronounced falls in economic activity and employment, which could jeopardise medium-term price stability. As long as inflation expectations remain well-anchored, the ECB can extend this horizon. However, if inflation expectations become unanchored, the ECB may need to tighten policy more aggressively.
The ECB's forward guidance and communication strategies play a crucial role in shaping inflation expectations and, consequently, French inflation dynamics. By providing clear and consistent communication, the ECB can help anchor long-term inflation expectations closer to its 2% target. This, in turn, can influence wage and price-setting behavior in France, ultimately affecting domestic inflation. However, the effectiveness of forward guidance depends on the credibility of the central bank and the alignment of market expectations with its policy intentions. The ECB's recent adoption of a symmetric 2% inflation target and its acknowledgment of the need for forceful monetary policy action when operating close to the lower bound on nominal interest rates are steps towards enhancing the credibility of its forward guidance. Nevertheless, the ECB must continue to refine its communication strategies to ensure that its forward guidance is well understood and effectively transmitted to French inflation dynamics.
In conclusion, the persistent divergence between French inflation and the ECB's 2% target highlights the importance of understanding the unique domestic pressures and geopolitical factors influencing French inflation dynamics. As the ECB refines its forward guidance and communication strategies, investors should monitor the evolution of French inflation expectations and market behavior to assess the potential impact on the French economy and the broader euro area.
Disclaimer: the above is a summary showing certain market information. AInvest is not responsible for any data errors, omissions or other information that may be displayed incorrectly as the data is derived from a third party source. Communications displaying market prices, data and other information available in this post are meant for informational purposes only and are not intended as an offer or solicitation for the purchase or sale of any security. Please do your own research when investing. All investments involve risk and the past performance of a security, or financial product does not guarantee future results or returns. Keep in mind that while diversification may help spread risk, it does not assure a profit, or protect against loss in a down market.
_f1f065a11747915420440.jpeg)
