FirstGroup plc (LON:FGP): A Tale of Intrinsic Value Mispricing and Market Over-Optimism

---

The valuation of FirstGroup plc (LON:FGP) presents a compelling case study in the tension between intrinsic value and market sentiment. While the company's FY 2025 results underscored resilience and strategic progress in decarbonization, the stock's current price appears to diverge significantly from fundamental metrics. This analysis explores the mispricing of FirstGroup's intrinsic value and the over-optimism driving its market valuation, drawing on recent financial disclosures and analyst forecasts.

Intrinsic Value: A Conservative Estimate

Using a 2 Stage Free Cash Flow to Equity (FCFE) model, FirstGroup's intrinsic value has been calculated at UK£1.57 per share, with a sensitivity range of £1.53–£1.71, according to a fair value analysis. This estimate assumes a 12% cost of equity and a terminal growth rate of 1.8%, aligned with the UK's 10-year government bond yield. The model projects a total equity value of £962 million, derived from the present value of 10-year free cash flows (£589 million) and a terminal value (£374 million). Crucially, this valuation hinges on conservative assumptions about electrification costs and revenue growth, given the company's £150 million FY 2026 capital expenditure plan, as outlined in FirstGroup's annual report.

However, FirstGroup's current stock price of 216.40 GBP (as of October 2025) implies a 23% overvaluation relative to that fair value estimate. Even the higher end of the FCFE range (£1.71) suggests a 26% premium. This discrepancy raises questions about whether the market is overestimating the company's ability to monetize its electrification investments or underestimating the risks of rising debt (adjusted net debt to Rail EBITDA of <2.0x), as noted in the annual report.

Market Over-Optimism: Analysts vs. Fundamentals

Despite the intrinsic value gap, analysts remain bullish. Four analysts have set a median 12-month price target of GBX 242.50, representing a 15.37% upside from the current price of GBX 210.20, according to the MarketBeat forecast. That MarketBeat data shows a consensus "Buy" rating, which contrasts sharply with earnings and revenue forecasts that predict a 27.8% annual revenue decline and a 2.3% earnings contraction, as reported in the annual report. These projections highlight a disconnect between short-term optimism and long-term fundamentals.

The over-optimism may stem from FirstGroup's recent shareholder returns. The company increased dividends from 3.8p in FY 2023 to 6.5p in FY 2025 and executed a £92 million buyback program, per the annual report. While these actions signal confidence, they may also be inflating short-term expectations. Additionally, the focus on electrification-supported by £22 million in government co-funding-has likely attracted ESG investors, further decoupling the stock from traditional valuation metrics, as discussed in the annual report.

Valuation Metrics: A Mixed Picture

FirstGroup's P/E ratio of 10.57 and EV/EBITDA of 2.77 suggest a moderate valuation relative to peers, per Investing.com. However, these metrics mask structural risks. The company's P/B ratio of 1.69 implies a premium over book value, which could be justified if electrification investments yield long-term returns. Yet, with adjusted net debt to Rail EBITDA at <2.0x, leverage remains a concern, particularly if interest rates rise or electrification costs exceed projections.

Conclusion: A Cautionary Outlook

FirstGroup's valuation discrepancy reflects a classic case of market over-optimism. While the company's strategic focus on decarbonization and shareholder returns is commendable, the current stock price appears to embed unrealistic growth assumptions. Investors should weigh the intrinsic value estimates against the risks of declining revenue and rising debt. Analysts' price targets, though optimistic, may not account for the volatility of government funding or the capital intensity of electrification. For now, FirstGroup remains a high-risk, high-reward proposition.

---