ETF Education: How ETF Liquidity Really Works

Meta Description

ETF liquidity is different from stock liquidity. Learn the difference between primary and secondary markets, why authorized participants matter, and how investors should evaluate liquidity.

Why ETF Liquidity Is Different From Stocks

When we think about stocks, liquidity usually means trading volume and consistency — the more active, the better. It’s tempting to assume the same rule applies to ETFs: if an ETF only trades 20,000–30,000 shares a day, it must be illiquid. But that’s a misconception.

ETFs have a two-layer liquidity system:

Secondary market liquidity – what you see on your brokerage screen (volume, spreads, etc.)

Primary market liquidity – the ability to create or redeem ETF shares behind the scenes

Understanding both is key to seeing the full liquidity picture.

Secondary Market: The Trading You See

Most investors interact in the secondary market, where ETF shares that already exist are exchanged. Here, liquidity depends on:

- Average trading volume of the ETF

- Bid-ask spreads

- Premiums or discounts relative to net asset value (NAV)

This is the “on-screen” activity that matters for small trades — say, a few hundred to a few thousand shares. For most retail investors, secondary liquidity is the main factor to watch.

Primary Market: The Creation and Redemption Engine

ETFs are unique because their share supply is flexible. When demand rises or falls significantly, authorized participants (APs) step in to create or redeem shares directly with the ETF issuer.

- Creation: An AP delivers a “basket” of the ETF’s underlying securities to the issuer in exchange for new ETF shares.

- Redemption: An AP returns ETF shares to the issuer and receives the underlying securities.

This process links ETF liquidity to the underlying securities market. If the ETF holds very liquid stocks (e.g., S&P 500 companies), the AP can easily assemble or unwind the basket, ensuring strong primary liquidity even if the ETF itself doesn’t trade much day-to-day.

Large Trades: When the Primary Market Matters

If an investor wants to trade tens of thousands of ETF shares (roughly 50,000 or more), the secondary market may not be sufficient. In these cases, the AP mechanism allows big trades to “reach through” to the primary market.

At this scale:

- Secondary market stats like spreads and volume become less relevant

- Underlying asset liquidity becomes the key factor, since the AP must trade in the underlying market to create or redeem shares

Institutional traders often work directly with the ETF issuer’s capital markets desk to assess market impact and connect with liquidity providers.

What Retail Investors Should Focus On

For everyday investors making smaller trades, assessing ETF liquidity comes down to three main metrics:

Average trading volume (is there regular activity?)

Bid-ask spreads (are transactions cost-effective?)

NAV premiums/discounts (is the ETF price close to fair value?)

As long as you’re not moving tens of thousands of shares at once, these secondary market measures are the most relevant.

Key Takeaways

- ETF liquidity operates on two levels: primary and secondary markets.

- Secondary liquidity reflects visible trading activity, spreads, and premiums/discounts.

- Primary liquidity is tied to the ease of creating/redeeming shares, which depends on the underlying securities.

- For large trades, underlying asset liquidity matters most. For smaller trades, spreads and daily volume are what count.

Disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Please consult a licensed financial professional before making investment decisions.