Endesa's Earnings Disappointment and Regulatory Headwinds: A Cautionary Tale for Energy Utilities in Spain

Spain's energy utilities sector has long been a beacon of innovation and resilience, but recent developments at Endesa SA (BME:ELE) underscore a growing fragility in the face of regulatory uncertainty and market volatility. While the company's first-half 2025 earnings report—marked by a 12% year-on-year EBITDA increase to €2.7 billion and a 30% surge in net income—seems to validate its strategic pivot toward renewables and gas, closer scrutiny reveals a narrative of moderation and risk. For investors, the combination of regulatory headwinds, debt-driven capital structures, and structural market design flaws in Spain's energy system raises critical questions about the long-term sustainability of shareholder value.

Financial Resilience Amid Earnings Moderation

Endesa's Q1 2025 performance was stellar: EBITDA soared 33% to €1.4 billion, buoyed by the removal of a 1.2% extraordinary tax and strong gas and retail margins. However, Q2 earnings growth slowed markedly, with EBITDA dropping 4% year-on-year to €1.3 billion and net income plummeting to €46 million—a stark contrast to expectations. This moderation was driven by lower wind and solar generation, a 7% nuclear generation tax hike, and volatile commodity prices (Gas TTF spot prices rose 47%, while Iberian power pool prices surged 58%).

Despite these headwinds, Endesa's operational progress is commendable. Renewable capacity expanded by 0.7 GW to 10.8 GW, with 79% of its energy mix now GHG-free. Network reliability improved, with TIEPI (interruption time) dropping to 23 minutes. Yet, the company's capital allocation—43% to networks, 35% to conventional generation, and 22% to renewables—highlights a lingering dependence on legacy infrastructure.

Historical data reinforces the risks of earnings underperformance: when Endesa misses expectations, the stock has historically underperformed in the short-to-medium term. For example, from 2022 to now, the 3-day win rate after earnings misses is just 14.29%, the 10-day win rate is 28.57%, and the 30-day win rate is 35.71%. The maximum return during this period was -2.33%, underscoring a tendency for negative momentum following earnings disappointments. This pattern suggests that investors may face heightened downside risks in the immediate aftermath of earnings reports that fall short of forecasts.

Regulatory Risks: A Double-Edged Sword

The most pressing concern for Endesa and its peers lies in Spain's regulatory environment. The proposed 6.46% rate of return on grid investments—criticized by Aelec and Endesa as “discriminatory”—threatens to undermine capital inflows. Aelec argues that this rate falls below EU benchmarks (e.g., 7.5% in Germany) and could trigger a “capital flight” to more attractive markets. For Endesa, which has allocated €500 million to its €2 billion share buyback program, the risk is twofold: higher financing costs for grid modernization and reduced investor confidence in its ability to sustain shareholder returns.

Compounding this is Spain's underdeveloped market design. With only 8% interconnection capacity relative to peak demand—the lowest in the EU—it struggles to balance surplus renewable generation with demand-side flexibility. Negative electricity prices (196 hours in 2024) and a 2.1 GW demand response capacity (vs. 4.2 GW in Germany) expose structural inefficiencies. Endesa's call for “adequate remuneration” to fund decarbonization is thus not just a corporate plea but a systemic necessity.

Debt-Driven Financing: A Hidden Vulnerability

Spain's energy transition has been fueled by a debt-heavy model. Over 90% of asset changes in the sector are financed through debt, with long-term debt accounting for 73% of financing in 2021. While this strategy has accelerated renewable deployment, it has also amplified financial leverage. Endesa's FFO (funds from operations) doubled in 1H 2025, but its reliance on debt to fund capex (€2.7 billion in 1H 2025) raises concerns about liquidity resilience if interest rates rise or credit markets tighten.

For shareholders, this model poses a dilemma: while debt financing preserves equity value in the short term, it increases exposure to refinancing risks and interest rate volatility. The recent blackout in April 2025—exacerbated by grid constraints—has only heightened the urgency for regulatory reforms that address both capital remuneration and market design flaws.

Strategic Implications for Investors

Endesa's 2025 guidance remains intact, supported by its robust cash flow and shareholder remuneration initiatives. However, investors must weigh these positives against the following risks:
1. Regulatory Uncertainty: The 6.46% grid return rate could delay critical infrastructure projects, stalling the energy transition and eroding competitive advantage.
2. Debt-Driven Capital Structure: Rising borrowing costs could strain FFO and reduce capacity for dividends or buybacks.
3. Market Design Gaps: Without reforms to interconnection capacity and demand flexibility, Spain's energy system remains vulnerable to volatility and inefficiency.

For long-term investors, the key lies in assessing whether Endesa's strategic pillars—renewable expansion, shareholder returns, and grid modernization—can withstand these pressures. The company's Capital Markets Day in early 2026 will offer critical insights into its updated roadmap. Until then, a cautious approach is warranted, with a focus on diversifying exposure to energy utilities in regions with more stable regulatory frameworks.

In conclusion, Endesa's earnings performance and regulatory challenges reflect a broader tension in Spain's energy sector: the need to balance rapid decarbonization with systemic resilience. While the company's operational strengths are undeniable, the path to sustainable shareholder value will require navigating a thorny landscape of policy shifts, market volatility, and capital constraints. For investors, the lesson is clear: the energy transition is not just a technical challenge but a financial one—and Spain's utilities are at the epicenter of this transformation.
"""