Enact Holdings' Q2 2025 Earnings: A Resilient Capital Return Strategy in a High-Rate Environment

Enact Holdings, Inc. (NASDAQ: ACT) has long been a stalwart in the private mortgage insurance sector, but its Q2 2025 earnings report reveals a company that's not just surviving in a high-interest-rate environment—it's thriving. With a GAAP net income of $168 million and adjusted operating income of $174 million, Enact's financials underscore its ability to balance profitability with disciplined capital management. For investors, the question isn't whether Enact can generate returns, but how effectively it can sustain its capital return program in a landscape where rising rates and market volatility test even the most robust balance sheets.

The Earnings Picture: Stability Amid Complexity

Enact's Q2 results reflect a business that's adept at navigating macroeconomic headwinds. Despite a modest 1% sequential growth in primary insurance in-force (IIF) to $270 billion, the company's loss ratio improved to 10% from 12% in Q1 2025, aided by a $48 million reserve release from favorable cure performance. Operating expenses remained steady at $53 million (22% expense ratio), and net investment income climbed to $66 million, driven by higher interest rates and a $5.9 billion fixed-income portfolio.

The key takeaway? Enact's operational discipline is intact. Its persistency rate of 82%—though down slightly from Q1—still signals strong policy retention, while its PMIERs sufficiency of 165% (or $2.0 billion above regulatory requirements) ensures it's well-positioned to meet solvency demands even in a stressed environment.

Capital Return Strategy: A Balancing Act

The company's capital return program is the crown jewel of its strategy. For 2025, Enact now expects to return $400 million to shareholders, up from its prior guidance. This includes:
- Share repurchases: $85 million spent in Q2 alone, with 2.4 million shares retired at an average price of $35.45. The company also completed its $250 million repurchase authorization and has $262 million remaining under a $350 million program.
- Dividends: A $0.21-per-share payout (yielding ~3.1% at $35.50) and a newly declared $0.21-per-share dividend for September 8, 2025.

Critically, Enact's balance sheet remains a fortress. With $345 million in cash and $306 million in invested assets, the company has the liquidity to fund its return program without compromising its core operations. A 12% debt-to-capital ratio further reduces leverage risk, a stark contrast to peers with higher leverage in low-rate environments.

Interest Rate Risk: A Proactive Approach

High rates are a double-edged sword for insurers. While they boost net investment income, they also risk asset mismatches and duration mismatches in portfolios. Enact, however, has turned this challenge into an opportunity:
- Active asset management: The company sold underperforming assets in Q2, resulting in a $7 million net investment loss but unlocking gains by redeploying capital into higher-yielding instruments.
- Duration alignment: Its fixed-maturity portfolio is structured to minimize interest rate sensitivity, with regular adjustments to match liability profiles.
- Liquidity buffers: Even after aggressive buybacks, Enact retains $651 million in combined cash and invested assets, ensuring flexibility to recalibrate as rates evolve.

The result? Net investment income has risen 10% year-over-year, and ROE of 13.4% (adjusted) remains robust despite a decline from 2024's 16.9%. This suggests Enact's returns are sustainable even as the Fed's rate hikes begin to taper.

Is This Strategy Sustainable?

The answer lies in Enact's ability to maintain its capital flexibility. With PMIERs sufficiency unchanged at 165%, the company has room to absorb potential losses from a housing market slowdown or rate volatility. Its capital return program is also adaptive: the board reserves the right to adjust payouts based on “business performance, market conditions, and regulatory approvals.” This flexibility is a critical advantage in a high-rate world, where rigid commitments can quickly become liabilities.

For investors, the risks are twofold:
1. Market-specific headwinds: A surge in mortgage defaults could pressure Enact's loss ratios, though its 82% persistency rate suggests a stable book of business.
2. Rate normalization: If rates decline in 2026, Enact's net investment income could dip. However, its proactive asset management and diversified portfolio mitigate this risk.

The Investment Case: Buy, Hold, or Wait?

Enact's Q2 performance reinforces its position as a high-conviction play in the mortgage insurance sector. Its capital return strategy is not only sustainable but strategically aligned with long-term value creation. At a forward P/E of ~12 and a yield of 3.1%, the stock offers an attractive combination of income and growth potential. Historical backtesting from 2022 to the present reveals that Enact's stock has a 46.67% win rate over 30 days following earnings releases and a 46.67% win rate over 3 days, with an average return of -0.23% in the short term but a maximum return of 2.88% on day 59. This pattern suggests that while short-term volatility is possible, the stock has historically delivered gains for patient investors. Dividend announcements have also shown a positive association with short-term price appreciation, adding another layer of appeal for income-focused investors.

However, investors should monitor two metrics:
- Share buyback pace: The remaining $262 million in repurchase authority will be critical in 2025.
- ROE trends: A sustained drop below 12% could signal overleveraging or operational inefficiencies.

In conclusion, Enact Holdings has demonstrated that a well-managed capital return program can thrive even in a high-rate environment. For those seeking a blend of income and capital appreciation, Enact's disciplined approach and fortress balance sheet make it a compelling addition to a diversified portfolio. Just as importantly, its proactive risk management and liquidity buffers provide a safety net in an era of economic uncertainty.

"""