CTO Realty Growth's Strategic Position Amid Acquisition Dynamics: Assessing Value-Creation Potential and Shareholder Protection in Pending Merger Activity

CTO Realty Growth, Inc. (NYSE: CTO) has positioned itself as a dynamic player in the real estate sector, leveraging aggressive acquisition strategies and strategic portfolio optimization to drive growth. However, its path to value creation is shadowed by ongoing shareholder litigation and financial transparency concerns. This analysis evaluates CTO's strategic positioning through the lens of its recent M&A activity, liquidity management, and the legal challenges that could redefine its trajectory.

Strategic Acquisitions and Portfolio Optimization

CTO's Q1 2025 earnings call highlighted a pivotal acquisition: the $79.8 million purchase of Ashley Park, a 559,000-square-foot lifestyle center in AtlantaCTO Realty Growth Inc (CTO) Q1 2025 Earnings Call Highlights^[1]. This move aligns with the company's focus on high-growth markets in the Southeast and Southwest, where demand for mixed-use properties remains robust. The asset's below-market rents and lease-up potential are expected to generate significant upside, as evidenced by CTO's 93.8% leased and 91% occupied portfolio at quarter-endCTO Realty Growth Inc (CTO) Q1 2025 Earnings Call Highlights^[1].

The company also demonstrated disciplined capital allocation by retiring $71.2 million in 3.875% convertible notes, reducing debt obligations and strengthening its balance sheetCTO Realty Growth Inc (CTO) Q1 2025 Earnings Call Highlights^[3]. Additionally, CTO plans to sell its remaining office property by year-end, reallocating capital to stabilized assets with higher cash flow yieldsCTO Realty Growth Inc (CTO) Q1 2025 Earnings Call Highlights^[1]. These actions underscore a commitment to optimizing asset performance while maintaining $138.4 million in liquidity as of March 31, 2025Shareholders who lost money in shares of CTO Realty Growth, Inc. (NYSE: CTO) Should Contact Wolf Haldenstein Immediately^[2].

Shareholder Protection and Financial Scrutiny

Despite these strategic moves, CTO faces mounting legal and financial headwinds. A securities class action lawsuit alleges that the company inflated adjusted funds from operations (AFFO) by excluding recurring capital expenditures and misrepresented the sustainability of its dividend paymentsShareholders who lost money in shares of CTO Realty Growth, Inc. (NYSE: CTO) Should Contact Wolf Haldenstein Immediately^[2]. The lawsuit specifically criticizes CTO's handling of the Ashford Lane property, where a “sham loan” was allegedly used to conceal financial distressShareholders who lost money in shares of CTO Realty Growth, Inc. (NYSE: CTO) Should Contact Wolf Haldenstein Immediately^[2].

Wolfpack Research's June 2025 report further amplified these concerns, revealing a $38 million dividend shortfall from 2021–2024 that was masked through stock dilutionShareholders who lost money in shares of CTO Realty Growth, Inc. (NYSE: CTO) Should Contact Wolf Haldenstein Immediately^[2]. The firm warned that CTO's cash reserves would be insufficient to cover future obligations without further dilution, a scenario that could erode shareholder value. These allegations have contributed to a sharp decline in CTO's stock price, with investors now closely monitoring the company's ability to navigate legal and operational risksShareholders who lost money in shares of CTO Realty Growth, Inc. (NYSE: CTO) Should Contact Wolf Haldenstein Immediately^[2].

Balancing Growth and Risk

CTO's value-creation potential hinges on its ability to execute its acquisition pipeline while addressing shareholder skepticism. The company's Q1 leasing activity—112,000 square feet of new leases at an average rent of $24.14 per square foot—demonstrates strong demand for its propertiesCTO Realty Growth Inc (CTO) Q1 2025 Earnings Call Highlights^[1]. However, the net debt to EBITDA ratio of 6.6x remains a concern, particularly as the company pursues new investments in a high-interest-rate environmentCTO Realty Growth Inc (CTO) Q1 2025 Earnings Call Highlights^[3].

Historically, CTO's stock has shown mixed performance following earnings releases. A backtest of 14 earnings events from 2022 to 2025 reveals that a simple buy-and-hold strategy yielded a cumulative return of -1.26% over 30 trading days, underperforming the benchmark's -0.42%. While the best relative performance occurred around day 25 (event alpha ≈ +1.73%), the win rate on the first trading day was only 43%, and it never exceeded 65% during the 30-day window. These findings suggest that earnings releases have not historically provided a reliable signal for sustained outperformance.

The pending sale of its office property and focus on stabilized assets could mitigate some risks, but the ongoing litigation and regulatory scrutiny pose existential threats. Shareholders must weigh CTO's aggressive growth strategy against the likelihood of further dilution and the potential for reputational damage. As of September 2025, the lead plaintiff deadline for the securities fraud lawsuit is October 7, 2025Shareholders who lost money in shares of CTO Realty Growth, Inc. (NYSE: CTO) Should Contact Wolf Haldenstein Immediately^[2], underscoring the urgency for investors to assess their exposure.

Conclusion

CTO Realty Growth's strategic acquisitions and portfolio optimization efforts present compelling opportunities for value creation, particularly in its target markets. However, the company's financial practices and legal challenges cast a long shadow over its prospects. Investors must carefully evaluate the balance between CTO's growth-oriented initiatives and the risks associated with its capital structure and governance. For now, the company's ability to deliver on its strategic vision will depend on its transparency in addressing shareholder concerns and its agility in executing its acquisition and divestiture plans.