Constellation Brands' Q3 Earnings Report: Resilient Demand in Beer Segment Offsets Wine and Spirits Challenges

Constellation Brands (STZ), a leading beer, wine, and spirits producer, reported its Q3 (November) earnings for fiscal 2023, beating estimates on earnings per share (EPS) while missing on revenue expectations. The company posted EPS of $3.19, excluding non-recurring items, surpassing estimates of $3.01 by $0.18. However, revenues increased by only 1.4% year-over-year (YoY) to $2.47 billion, falling short of the $2.54 billion estimate. 

The company reaffirmed its guidance for fiscal 2024 (February), projecting EPS of $12.00-12.20, excluding non-recurring items, compared to the $11.93 estimate. The guidance assumes a 8-9% net sales growth for the Beer segment, and a 7-9% organic net sales decline for the Wine and Spirits segment, excluding $38.5 million of net sales and $19.5 million of gross profit less marketing that are no longer part of results. 

Despite missing revenue estimates and reducing its FY24 Wine and Spirits organic sales outlook, Constellation Brands shares have remained relatively afloat due to the resilient demand in its Beer segment. The segment, which accounts for 80% of total revenue, posted a 4.0% improvement in net sales in the quarter, driven by a 3.4% increase in shipments and a 8.2% increase in depletions. 

The Beer segments strong performance offset the weak Wine and Spirits segment, which experienced a 7.0% organic net sales decline, due to the ongoing transition of STZs portfolio towards higher-end offerings. The company had previously let go of its lower-priced wines, aiming to boost margins and reenergize sales. 

While the Wine and Spirits segment continues to face challenges, there were some positive signs. The Prisoner, STZs largest fine wine brand, registered a 6.0% depletion growth, outpacing the broader wine category. In craft spirits, Mi CAMPO tequila, STZs second-largest brand, achieved over 80% depletion growth. 

Although the Beer segment has been a bright spot for the company, it cannot fully compensate for the underperformance in the Wine and Spirits segment. The swift turnaround in Wine and Spirits is unlikely, as STZ significantly reduced its FY24 Wine and Spirits organic net sales forecast to a 7-9% decline YoY, compared to its previous estimate of a 0.5% decline to 0.5% growth. 

Despite the challenges faced by the Wine and Spirits segment, STZ reiterated its FY24 adjusted earnings guidance of $12.00-12.20 due to the strong performance in the Beer segment. However, until STZ can successfully revive the Wine and Spirits segment, the potential for greater stock growth may be limited. 

In conclusion, Constellation Brands Q3 earnings report highlights the resilient demand in its Beer segment, which has been crucial in offsetting the challenges faced by the Wine and Spirits segment. While the Beer segment continues to perform well, the underperformance in the Wine and Spirits segment has weighed on the overall portfolio and limited the companys stock growth potential. STZ must focus on revitalizing the Wine and Spirits segment to achieve more meaningful growth in the future.

$STZ(STZ)