Colombia’s Strategic Debt Repurchase and Its Implications for Emerging Market Sovereign Bonds

In 2025, Colombia embarked on an ambitious fiscal restructuring strategy to alleviate its sovereign debt burden, leveraging Swiss franc loans to repurchase high-cost liabilities denominated in Colombian pesos and U.S. dollars. This move, described as “unprecedented” by Public Credit Director Javier Cuellar, aims to reduce interest debt payments from 4.7% to 4.5% of GDP, a modest but symbolically significant step in a landscape where emerging markets grapple with escalating debt levels and constrained fiscal space [1]. The strategy reflects a broader trend of innovative debt management in the Global South, where nations are increasingly experimenting with non-traditional tools to balance fiscal sustainability with economic growth.

The Mechanics of the Repurchase

Colombia’s approach hinges on exploiting favorable borrowing conditions in Swiss franc markets to finance the repurchase of higher-yielding domestic and dollar-denominated bonds. By August 2025, the government had already repurchased $2.9 billion in bonds for $1.9 billion, achieving a $1 billion nominal discount [2]. This tender, part of a larger $10 billion Swiss franc borrowing plan, seeks to lower the debt-to-GDP ratio while diversifying away from U.S. dollar exposure—a critical move given the volatility of global interest rates and the fragility of emerging market currencies. The strategy mirrors debt-for-climate swaps seen in Ecuador and Gabon, where debt relief is exchanged for environmental commitments, though Colombia’s focus remains purely fiscal [3].

However, the risks are stark. Short-term rollover risks and exposure to exchange rate fluctuations—particularly between Swiss francs and Colombian pesos—could amplify losses if market conditions deteriorate. As noted by the Institute of International Finance (IIF), such strategies require robust institutional frameworks to mitigate “bluewashing” and ensure transparency, challenges Colombia has sidestepped by avoiding conditional swaps [4].

Lessons from Emerging Market Precedents

Colombia’s strategy aligns with a growing but contentious trend in emerging markets: using debt restructuring to unlock fiscal space. Debt-for-nature and debt-for-climate swaps, such as Ecuador’s 2023 $1.6 billion deal to expand marine protected areas, demonstrate that restructuring can achieve dual objectives of fiscal relief and environmental stewardship [5]. Yet these mechanisms often face hurdles, including high transaction costs and protracted negotiations. For instance, Suriname and Zambia’s restructurings under the G20 Common Framework took years to finalize, underscoring the complexity of coordinating diverse creditor interests [6].

The impact on borrowing costs and credit ratings is equally mixed. Countries that restructure often face prolonged speculative-grade ratings, with borrowing costs up to nine times higher than investment-grade peers [7]. Colombia’s own credit rating, currently at BB+ with a negative outlook from S&P, reflects lingering concerns about structural fiscal challenges, including a 2026 primary deficit increase to 2% of GDP [8]. While the recent bond repurchases have temporarily boosted investor confidence—evidenced by mild gains in bond prices—the long-term trajectory depends on sustained fiscal discipline and structural reforms.

The Path Forward: Unlocking Value or Creating New Vulnerabilities?

The success of Colombia’s strategy hinges on two factors: the durability of its fiscal reforms and the resilience of its external financing. By reducing debt servicing costs, the government aims to free up resources for infrastructure and social programs, a critical need in a country where public investment has lagged for years. However, reliance on Swiss franc borrowing introduces new risks. If the Swiss National Bank tightens monetary policy or the peso depreciates sharply, Colombia could face a debt spiral akin to Argentina’s recent crisis [9].

Comparative evidence from IMF programs offers a glimmer of hope. On average, IMF-backed restructurings reduce borrowing costs by 72 basis points, with larger programs yielding greater relief [10]. Colombia, however, has opted for a unilateral approach, bypassing multilateral support. This choice may limit the credibility of its restructuring in the eyes of global investors, particularly if fiscal reforms falter.

Implications for Emerging Markets

Colombia’s experiment highlights a broader dilemma for emerging markets: how to restructure debt without sacrificing access to international capital. The use of Swiss francs as a non-traditional currency for sovereign borrowing is a novel but precarious tactic. If successful, it could inspire similar strategies in countries like Brazil or South Africa, which also face high debt servicing costs. Conversely, a failure could reinforce perceptions of emerging markets as high-risk, further entrenching the “original sin” of dollar-denominated debt [11].

Conclusion

Colombia’s strategic debt repurchase represents a bold but calculated gamble. By leveraging Swiss franc liquidity to reduce near-term liabilities, the government has demonstrated a willingness to innovate in the face of fiscal constraints. Yet the long-term success of this strategy will depend on its ability to implement structural reforms, maintain fiscal credibility, and navigate the inherent risks of currency mismatches. For emerging markets, the lesson is clear: creative debt management can unlock value, but it must be paired with institutional strength and a clear vision for sustainable growth.

Source:
[1] Colombia turns to Swiss francs to restructure crippling debt, [https://www.swissinfo.ch/eng/various/colombia-turns-to-swiss-francs-to-restructure-crippling-debt/89629918]
[2] Colombia Buys Back $2.9 B in Bonds in Plan to Ease Debt, [https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2025-08-11/colombia-repurchases-2-9b-in-bonds-in-effort-to-ease-debt-load]
[3] Debt-for-nature swaps: A case study of Gabon, [https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1566014124001390]
[4] Publications Filter, [https://www.iif.com/publications/publications-filter/c/Research/t/Debt]
[5] Debt for climate swaps: a primer for FiCS members - CPI, [https://www.climatepolicyinitiative.org/publication/debt-for-climate-swaps-a-primer-for-fics-members/]
[6] Emerging Markets Debt Restructurings: A Year of..., [https://investments.metlife.com/insights/fixed-income/emerging-market-debt-restructurings-a-year-of-resilience-and-innovation/]
[7] Sovereign debt Defaults, restructurings and resolution, [https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1042443125000873]
[8] Strategic Bond Buybacks and the Impact on Sovereign Credit Profiles: Colombia Case Study, [https://www.ainvest.com/news/strategic-bond-buybacks-impact-sovereign-credit-profiles-colombia-case-study-2509/]
[9] OECD Economic Outlook, Volume 2025 Issue 1, [https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-economic-outlook-volume-2025-issue-1_83363382-en/full-report/general-assessment-of-the-macroeconomic-situation_3e68d1e3.html]
[10] IMF programs and borrowing costs does size matter?, [https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0014292125001205]
[11] Developing countries face record-high public debt burdens, [https://unctad.org/news/developing-countries-face-record-high-public-debt-burdens-now-time-reform]