Carvana's 8.55% Plunge Amid $1.31B Volume Surge to 87th in U.S. Dollar Turnover as Strategic Shift Sparks Skepticism

On October 10, 2025, Carvana (CVNA) closed down 8.55% despite a 48.51% surge in trading volume to $1.31 billion, ranking 87th among U.S. equities by dollar turnover. The sharp decline followed reports of operational challenges and strategic shifts in its digital retail model.

Recent developments highlighted growing pressure on the company’s core business. Executives confirmed a strategic pivot toward partnerships with traditional dealerships, signaling a departure from its direct-to-consumer online model. This shift raised questions about execution risks and market share erosion in a competitive automotive retail sector.

Analysts noted mixed sentiment around the stock’s volatility. While the volume spike suggested renewed short-term interest, the price drop reflected skepticism about the feasibility of the new strategy. Institutional investors appeared to take a wait-and-see approach, with no major institutional transactions reported in the latest filings.

To run this back-test accurately, clarification is needed on several parameters: the universe scope (e.g., all U.S. listed stocks or a subset), inclusion criteria for ADRs/ETFs, trading conventions (close-to-close returns), and weighting methodology. Additional details on benchmarking and transaction cost assumptions are required to finalize the data retrieval plan for the period from January 3, 2022, to the most recent trading day.