Carronade Capital's Push for Viasat's Spin-Off: A Strategic Catalyst for Value Unlocking

In the high-stakes arena of corporate restructuring, few moves are as transformative as a spin-off. For Viasat Inc. (NASDAQ: VSAT), the debate over separating its defense and broadband segments has intensified, driven by activist investor Carronade Capital Management's aggressive campaign. This push is not just about corporate realignment—it's about unlocking latent value in a company that has long straddled two distinct markets with divergent growth trajectories.

The Financial Rationale: Why Separating Makes Sense

Viasat's recent restructuring into Communication Services and Defense and Advanced Technologies (DAT) segments, effective Q1 FY2025, is a critical first step. The DAT segment, in particular, has shown robust performance: 17% year-over-year revenue growth, 28% EBITDA margins, and a 50% increase in backlog. By contrast, the Communication Services segment has struggled with a -3.8% revenue decline, pressured by terrestrial 5G competition and regulatory headwinds.

Carronade's $50/share standalone valuation for DAT—more than three times Viasat's current price—rests on a compelling argument: the defense segment is a high-margin, government-driven growth engine, while the broadband business operates in a commoditized, capital-intensive space. Separating them would allow each unit to optimize capital allocation, pursue tailored strategies, and trade on their own metrics.

Consider the math:
- DAT's Potential: With a 50% backlog growth and contracts like the $568 million Ligado Networks settlement, the segment is well-positioned to capitalize on the $849.8 billion U.S. DoD FY2025 budget and global defense modernization trends.
- Broadband's Challenges: The segment's 0.41 price-to-sales ratio suggests undervaluation, but its growth is constrained by 5G expansion and thin margins.

A spin-off would eliminate cross-subsidization, where broadband's struggles might drag down DAT's momentum. For investors, this separation could translate to alpha generation as each business is revalued independently.

Market Implications: Unlocking Value Through Strategic Clarity

Spin-offs often create shareholder value by addressing mispricings in conglomerate structures. Viasat's case is no different. Carronade estimates a separation could unlock $11 billion in combined value, with the DAT segment potentially trading at a 20–30% premium to its current implied valuation.

The defense segment's exposure to next-gen technologies—encrypted communications, hybrid space architectures, and direct-to-device systems—positions it to outperform in a sector where margins and growth are decoupled from consumer market volatility. Meanwhile, the broadband unit could reinvest in rural connectivity and enterprise mobility, areas where satellite's strengths in coverage and latency resilience remain unmatched.

Risks and Realities: Not All Spin-Offs Succeed

While the upside is compelling, the path isn't without risks. Viasat's debt-to-equity ratio of 1.65 and a negative Altman Z-Score (0.44) highlight financial fragility. A spin-off would require significant restructuring costs and could exacerbate liquidity pressures, especially with near-term debt maturities.

Moreover, management resistance remains a hurdle. Viasat's board has not yet committed to Carronade's proposal, and insider selling of $381 million over the past year suggests skepticism among executives. If the spin-off fails to materialize, the stock could stagnate or underperform as investor patience wanes.

Investment Advice: Positioning for the “What If” Scenario

For investors, the key question is whether to bet on the potential of a spin-off or remain cautious. Here's a framework for decision-making:
1. Short-Term: Monitor Viasat's Q1 FY2025 earnings (first reported under the new segment structure) for clues about management's willingness to embrace Carronade's vision.
2. Long-Term: Consider a small, opportunistic position if the stock trades below $20, factoring in the $50–$100 price target Carronade outlined.
3. Hedging: Given the company's leverage, pairing Viasat with defensive plays in the satellite or defense sectors could mitigate risk.

Conclusion: A High-Risk, High-Reward Proposition

Carronade's campaign for Viasat's spin-off is a classic case of activist-driven value unlocking. The DAT segment's growth potential and the broadband business's undervaluation create a compelling case for separation. However, investors must weigh the strategic promise against Viasat's financial vulnerabilities and management's reluctance.

If executed successfully, the spin-off could redefine Viasat's trajectory, transforming two underperforming units into two high-performing entities. For now, the ball is in the board's court—but the market is watching closely.

"""