Is Card Factory plc (LON:CARD) a Bargain at Current Prices?

Card Factory plc (LON:CARD), a UK-based greeting card and stationery retailer, has seen its stock price drift sideways in recent months, trading near 91 pence as of April 2025. But with a P/E ratio of 6.72—far below its historical average—and analysts estimating its intrinsic value at £1.34 per share, investors are left wondering: Is this a buying opportunity, or a trap?

Valuation: Undervalued or Just Stagnant?

Card Factory’s stock currently trades at a 36% discount to its estimated fair value, according to recent analyses. . This gap is partly explained by short-term pressures, including a 9.8% rise in the National Living Wage and unseasonably poor weather, which crimped margins. Yet the company’s revenue grew 5.9% year-on-year in the first half of 2025, and it’s projected to see a 38% profit increase over the next two years, driven by cash flow improvements and operational efficiencies.

.

Financial Health: Growth Amid Margin Strains

While revenue trends are positive, profitability has suffered. Earnings per share (EPS) fell to £0.03 in 1H 2025 from £0.056 in the prior year, as wage costs surged. However, the company’s dividend yield of 4.96%—bolstered by consistent payouts—offers income appeal. The most recent dividend (4.50p final) reflects a 4.8% yield, with a dividend cover of 3.00, suggesting earnings comfortably support payouts.

Strategic Moves and Risks

Card Factory’s expansion into the U.S. market via the Garven acquisition—a move to tap into a £70 billion greeting card industry—is a bold bet. Yet execution risks remain, as the company navigates unfamiliar supply chains and competition. Domestically, it faces headwinds from rising inflation and weak consumer spending.

The company’s high beta (implying heightened volatility relative to the market) adds another layer of risk. . Investors must weigh this against its 3-year stock price surge of 91%, which outpaced broader retail sector peers.

Management Confidence and Insider Activity

Notably, CEO Darcy Willson-Rymer and CFO Matthias Seeger have recently bought shares, signaling optimism about the company’s prospects. Seeger’s June 2024 purchase at 95.60p suggests confidence in long-term value. However, the stock’s 52-week low of 73p underscores how quickly sentiment can shift.

The Verdict: Buy, Hold, or Sell?

Card Factory presents a compelling value case for patient investors. Its low P/E ratio and undiscounted intrinsic value suggest the market is underestimating its growth potential in the U.S. and its ability to stabilize margins. The dividend also provides a safety net.

However, near-term risks—margin pressure, macroeconomic uncertainty, and execution in new markets—cannot be ignored. The one unspecified "warning sign" highlighted by analysts adds prudence to the equation.

Final Analysis

At 91p, Card Factory offers a 27% upside to its £1.34 intrinsic value estimate. For investors willing to tolerate volatility, the stock could be a multi-year growth story. Those focused on stability may prefer to wait for clearer profit recovery signals.

.

Conclusion: Card Factory plc is a buy for investors seeking exposure to a potentially undervalued retailer with strategic growth avenues, provided they can stomach short-term turbulence. The strong revenue growth, insider confidence, and dividend yield align with a value-oriented strategy. However, the path to realizing the upside hinges on margin recovery and successful U.S. expansion—outcomes that remain uncertain.

As of April 2025, the stock’s 4.96% yield and 38% projected profit growth make it a compelling candidate for a dividend-focused, growth-oriented portfolio, but with a hold rating for risk-averse investors until profitability stabilizes.

Data as of April 2025. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Always conduct independent research or consult a financial advisor before making investment decisions.