Should You Cancel an Unused Credit Card? A 2025 Analysis of Risks and Rewards

In an era of streamlined financial management, the question of whether to cancel an unused credit card has never been more consequential—or more nuanced. With evolving credit scoring models, shifting fee structures, and regulatory overhauls, the decision hinges on a delicate balance of factors. Let’s dissect the calculus.

Ask Aime: Should I cancel my unused credit card?

The Credit Score Quagmire: Why Closing Isn’t Always Neutral

Closing an unused credit card can trigger a cascading effect on your credit score, primarily through three mechanisms: credit utilization, average account age, and credit mix.

1. Credit Utilization: The 30% Threshold
   Your credit utilization—the ratio of your balances to your total credit limits—is the single most influential factor in FICO scoring, accounting for 30% of your score. Closing a card with a high credit limit (even if it’s unused) reduces your available credit, thereby increasing your utilization rate. For instance, if you close a card with a $12,000 limit while carrying $7,000 in balances across other cards, your utilization jumps from 28% to 54%—a level likely to drop your score by 10–45 points.
   

2. Average Account Age: The Ghost of Credit Past
   Closing your oldest card immediately shortens the average age of your accounts, a metric that contributes 15% to your FICO score. For example, closing a decade-old card while keeping newer ones reduces the "length of credit history" metric, potentially costing you 5–15 points.

3. Credit Mix: Diversification Matters (But Not Enough)
   Credit mix (the variety of accounts, such as installment loans versus credit cards) is a minor factor (10% of FICO). Closing your sole credit card could reduce your score by 1–5 points if it was your only revolving account.

The Annual Fee Equation: When to Cut Ties

High annual fees—common on premium rewards cards—often outweigh the benefits. Cards charging over $500 annually are prime candidates for closure unless their perks (e.g., travel credits, lounge access) justify the cost. However, alternatives exist:
- Negotiate a Waiver: Call issuers to request a fee exemption or downgrade to a no-annual-fee version.
- Strategic Use: Make small recurring purchases (e.g., streaming subscriptions) to earn rewards or avoid inactivity fees.

Regulatory Shifts: A Silver Lining for Credit Scores

The 2025 Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) rule to remove medical debt from credit reports could partially offset score declines from closing cards. Medical debt, often inaccurately reported or tied to billing errors, previously dragged down scores for millions. The CFPB estimates this rule could boost scores by an average of 20 points for affected individuals. State-level laws, such as California’s S.B. 1061, reinforce this shift, ensuring medical debt exclusion becomes nationwide.

When Closing Is the Prudent Move

Despite the risks, certain scenarios warrant cancellation:
- Debt Consolidation: Transferring balances to a new card with a lower rate, then closing the old one.
- Joint Accounts in Divorce: Removing yourself from a joint account to avoid liability for an ex-spouse’s charges.
- Store Cards with Low Limits: Retail cards often have small limits, making their closure less impactful on utilization but risky to keep if unused.

Mitigating the Fallout: A Step-by-Step Plan

1. Prioritize Closures: Close newer or low-limit cards first to preserve average account age.
2. Lower Utilization: Pay down existing balances before closing to keep utilization under 10%.
3. Redirect Recurring Payments: Avoid missed payments by shifting automatic charges to other cards.
4. Monitor Reports: Ensure the closed account is listed as “closed at customer request” to prevent errors.

Conclusion: A Calculated Risk

Canceling an unused credit card is a decision best made with data in hand. For those with high utilization rates or exorbitant fees, the benefits may outweigh the score dip—especially with regulatory changes softening the blow. However, closing your oldest card or one with a high limit could cost you dearly.

The CFPB’s medical debt exclusion alone could add 20 points to scores for millions, while fee trends show no-annual-fee options are increasingly viable. For 2025, the key takeaway is this: Cancel strategically, not reflexively. Preserve older cards with high limits, negotiate fees, and prioritize accounts that serve your financial goals. In the end, your credit score—and financial future—depend on it.