Bullish Potential Amid Declining Short Interest and Mixed Analyst Ratings for Shell PLC (SHEL)

The energy sector remains a focal point for investors navigating a post-pandemic economic landscape, and Shell PLC (SHEL) has emerged as a compelling case study in market sentiment dynamics. Recent data reveals a notable decline in short interest for the energy giant, coupled with mixed but generally positive analyst ratings. This combination suggests a potential inflection point for SHEL, where bearish bets are waning and institutional optimism is gaining traction.

Short Interest Trends: A Signal of Waning Bearishness

As of July 31, 2025, Shell's short interest stood at 10,780,000 shares, representing 0.37% of its floating shares-a slight decline from the previous period's 10,820,000 shares according to MarketBeat. This reduction, though modest, indicates a softening of bearish sentiment among investors. The short interest ratio (SIR), which measures the number of shares sold short relative to the average daily trading volume, is currently at 2.0 according to MarketBeat. While this figure suggests moderate pessimism, it is far below the thresholds typically associated with widespread negative sentiment (e.g., SIRs above 5.0).

Moreover, Shell's short interest is relatively low compared to its peers in the petroleum and natural gas industry, where short interest percentages range from 0.07% to 1.35% according to MarketBeat. This positions SHEL as a stock with limited downside risk from short sellers, a factor that could support its price in the near term.

Analyst Ratings: A Mixed but Generally Positive Outlook

For Q4 2025, Shell has received a "Moderate Buy" consensus from 22 analysts, with 11 hold ratings, 9 buy ratings, and 2 strong buy ratings according to MarketBeat. The average 12-month price target from 34 ratings is $41.48 according to Barron's, while another source suggests a higher average of $74.48 from 11 analysts, with a high of $91.00 and a low of $42.79 according to TipRanks. This divergence reflects differing views on the energy sector's trajectory, particularly amid geopolitical tensions and the transition to renewable energy.

Notably, recent upgrades from firms like Piper Sandler (raising its price target to $90 with an "overweight" rating) and BNP Paribas (upgrading to "strong-buy") underscore growing confidence in Shell's strategic positioning according to MarketBeat. These moves align with the company's progress in balancing traditional energy production with investments in renewables and carbon-neutral initiatives.

Connecting the Dots: Bullish Potential Amid Uncertainty

The interplay between declining short interest and mixed analyst ratings paints a nuanced picture for SHEL. On one hand, the low short interest suggests that bearish investors are scaling back their bets, reducing the risk of a short squeeze and limiting downward pressure on the stock. On the other, the analyst ratings highlight a spectrum of expectations, with the higher price targets ($74.48–$91.00) indicating optimism about Shell's long-term value creation.

Currently trading at approximately $72.30, SHEL is already above the lower end of analyst price targets but below the upper estimates according to MarketBeat. This positioning, combined with a forward price-to-earnings ratio of 14.8 and a quarterly dividend of $0.716 according to MarketBeat, suggests that the stock offers both income and growth potential. The recent upgrades from major institutions further validate its appeal in a market where energy stocks are increasingly viewed as defensive plays.

Conclusion: A Strategic Buy for Patient Investors

While the mixed analyst ratings reflect ongoing debates about the energy transition's impact on legacy oil and gas firms, the declining short interest and institutional upgrades signal a shift toward optimism. For investors with a medium-term horizon, Shell's combination of stable dividends, strategic diversification, and improving sentiment metrics makes it a compelling candidate. However, as with any energy stock, macroeconomic factors such as oil prices and regulatory changes will remain critical to its performance.