BMO's Outlook on Canadian GDP and Its Implications for Bank Earnings

The interplay between Canada's Q3 2023 GDP growth, inflation resilience, and the fourth-quarter performance of Canadian banks has become a focal point for investors navigating a complex macroeconomic landscape. According to a report by BMO Economics, the Canadian economy posted a robust 2.6% annualized GDP growth in Q3 2023, driven by a sharp decline in imports (-8.6%) and a surge in government spending on defense and infrastructure. While this growth exceeded expectations and averted a technical recession, it also highlighted structural imbalances, such as weak domestic demand and stagnant business investment according to RBC analysis. For Canadian banks, the implications of this GDP rebound-and its alignment with inflation trends-are critical to understanding their Q4 2023 earnings outlook.

Q3 GDP Growth: A Mixed Bag for Banks

The Q3 GDP report revealed a paradox: headline growth was buoyed by net trade and government spending, but domestic demand remained fragile. Consumer spending edged down 0.4%, while business investment contracted by 4.5%. This divergence creates a challenging environment for banks, which rely on both credit growth and stable economic conditions. BMO's analysis underscores that while the Bank of Canada's rate cuts in September 2023 (reducing the benchmark rate to 2.5%) aim to stimulate activity, the uneven recovery in domestic sectors could weigh on credit quality. For instance, the decline in car purchases and elevated household debt servicing costs suggest that consumer lending may remain under pressure.

However, the surge in crude oil exports (+6.7%) and government investment in non-residential structures provided a tailwind for banks' corporate and institutional clients according to Statistics Canada. BMO notes that energy sector income rebounded by 2.5% in Q3, driven by higher production, which could bolster loan demand and fee income for banks with strong energy sector exposure

.

Inflation Resilience and Central Bank Policy

Inflation in Q3 2023 rose to 2.4%, exceeding expectations and complicating the Bank of Canada's policy calculus. While core inflation measures like CPI Median and CPI Trim remain above the 2% target, the central bank has opted for a cautious approach, prioritizing cost pressures over demand-side factors. This hesitancy to aggressively cut rates could limit banks' ability to pass on lower borrowing costs to customers, potentially squeezing net interest margins.

BMO's projections, however, suggest that inflation will trend closer to target by 2025, supported by declining energy prices and global economic stabilization. The bank forecasts a 100-basis-point rate cut by the end of 2024, which would bring the policy rate to 4%. Such easing could stimulate loan growth and reduce credit losses, particularly in sectors like housing and small business lending.

BMO's Q4 Earnings Outlook: Optimism Amid Risks

BMO's Q4 2023 earnings analysis for Canadian banks highlights a nuanced outlook. While the Big Six banks faced headwinds in Q3-such as higher provisions for credit losses (PCLs) and elevated expenses-the bank expects a rebound in Q4 driven by investment banking and wealth management segments according to Reuters. For example, BMO Financial Group reported Q3 net income of $1,454 million, with adjusted earnings of $2,037 million, reflecting resilience in its Canadian Personal and Commercial Banking division. The integration of Bank of the West and AIR MILES has also diversified revenue streams, mitigating some of the risks from domestic economic volatility.

However, BMO cautions that valuations remain stretched, and any earnings shortfall could trigger a sharp correction in bank stocks. Risks include the potential non-renewal of the USMCA trade agreement, which could disrupt key export sectors like softwood lumber and pharmaceuticals. Additionally, a housing market correction in Ontario and high household debt levels could exacerbate credit risks in Q4.

Conclusion: A Cautious Path Forward

The link between Q3 GDP growth, inflation resilience, and Q4 bank earnings hinges on the Bank of Canada's ability to balance rate cuts with inflation control. While BMO's projections suggest a modest rebound in bank earnings, the path is fraught with uncertainties. Investors should monitor the central bank's December policy decision and the November federal budget for clues on fiscal stimulus that could bolster economic recovery. For now, the interplay of net export-driven growth, inflation persistence, and strategic diversification will define the earnings trajectory of Canadian banks in the final quarter of 2023.