Blue Ridge Bankshares: Early-Stage Growth Signals in an Under-Followed Regional Bank

In the shadow of Wall Street's relentless focus on megabanks and fintech disruptors, regional banks like Blue Ridge Bankshares (BRBS) often fly under the radar. Yet, these institutions can harbor compelling value propositions for investors who know where to look. For BRBS, the second quarter of 2025 marked a pivotal moment: a return to profitability after a year of turbulence, strategic realignment, and early-stage signals of a sustainable turnaround. This article unpacks BRBS's performance and positioning to identify whether it fits the profile of an under-followed regional bank poised for growth.

A Turnaround in the Books: Q2 2025 Earnings as a Baseline

Blue Ridge Bankshares reported a net income of $1.3 million in Q2 2025, or $0.01 per diluted share, reversing a $0.4 million loss in Q1 2025 and a $11.4 million loss in Q2 2024. This swing from red to black was driven by a combination of operational discipline and strategic cost-cutting.

Key metrics highlighted the company's progress:
- Net interest income rose to $19.8 million, with a 3.15% net interest margin (NIM), up from 2.90% in Q1. This improvement stemmed from a decline in deposit costs, a critical win in an environment where funding costs often erode margins.
- Noninterest expenses fell by $1.0 million year-over-year, reflecting a 14% reduction in headcount and a 3% drop in consulting costs. Total expenses now stand at $22.0 million, down from $23.0 million in Q1.
- Capital ratios exceeded regulatory requirements, with a 12.89% tier 1 leverage ratio and 18.91% total risk-based capital ratio, signaling a stronger balance sheet.

The company's efficiency ratio—a key barometer of operational health—remains elevated at 116.9% (Q4 2024), but management has signaled a clear path to improvement. With a target of reducing noninterest expenses to below 3% of assets by year-end 2025, BRBS is aligning itself with the cost-conscious playbook of high-performing regional banks.

Historically, BRBS's earnings releases since 2022 have shown mixed outcomes for investors. While the stock has achieved a 50.00% win rate over 10 days post-earnings, the average return across all periods remains negative: -4.39% (3-day), -1.02% (10-day), and -1.73% (30-day). This suggests that while there are occasional opportunities—such as the 0.61% maximum return observed on day 16—investors should approach post-earnings moves with caution, as volatility and short-term underperformance have been common.

Strategic Shift: From “Fixers” to “Growers”

BRBS's transformation is not just numbers—it's a recalibration of identity. CEO G. William “Billy” Beale has openly framed the company's evolution as moving from a “team of fixers” to a “team of growers.” This shift is evident in three areas:

1. Exit from Non-Core Assets:
   The sale of its mortgage division in March 2025, though resulting in a $0.2 million loss, cleared a regulatory and operational burden. Similarly, the exit from fintech BaaS partnerships eliminated $445 million in volatile deposits, reducing reliance on unstable funding sources.

2. Capital Optimization:
   BRBS redeemed $15.0 million in subordinated debt in June 2025 and initiated a $10.0 million partial redemption of 2029-maturing notes. These moves are expected to save $2 million annually in interest costs and improve capital flexibility.

3. Deposit and Loan Refocus:
   The company is pivoting to in-market deposit growth, with a 10% annual increase in 2024. By shifting away from fintech deposits (cost of funds: 3.09% in Q4 2024), BRBS reduced its cost of funds to 2.63% in Q2 2025. This stability in funding is critical for margin resilience.

Early-Stage Growth Signals: Why BRBS Deserves Attention

Under-followed regional banks often exhibit telltale signs of a turnaround before broader market recognition. BRBS checks several boxes:
- Regulatory Compliance: The company has met—and exceeded—OCC-mandated capital ratios, reducing the risk of further penalties.
- Operational Discipline: A 170-person reduction in headcount since Q2 2024 has streamlined operations, while a $0.3 million release of reserves from prior-year activities boosted Q2 earnings.
- Asset Quality: Nonperforming loans remain low at 0.94% of total assets, and a 1.11% allowance for credit losses suggests prudent risk management.

However, BRBS is not without challenges. Its 116.9% efficiency ratio lags behind peers like Valley National Bancorp and Orrstown Financial Services, and loan growth remains constrained by a runoff of non-core assets. Yet, these are early-stage hurdles. The company's focus on community banking—a sector with durable demand in a low-interest-rate environment—positions it to capture market share as it rebuilds its loan and deposit pipelines.

Investment Implications

For investors seeking undervalued regional banks, BRBS offers a mix of risk and reward. The stock trades at a discount to tangible book value and has a 12.5% tangible common equity-to-tangible assets ratio, which is robust for its peer group. While the path to profitability is still in its early stages, the company's capital position, operational improvements, and strategic clarity suggest a compelling setup.

A key watchpoint is loan growth. BRBS must demonstrate that it can generate organic loan growth within its core markets to offset the runoff of non-core assets. If the company can achieve a 10% annualized loan growth rate by 2026, it could unlock significant upside.

Final Take

Blue Ridge Bankshares is emblematic of the under-followed regional bank narrative: a company emerging from a period of turmoil, with a clear strategic vision and early-stage momentum. While it's not a “buy and hold” story yet, its progress in reducing costs, optimizing capital, and refocusing on community banking makes it a candidate for cautious optimism. For investors with a medium-term horizon and a tolerance for volatility, BRBS could represent a high-conviction, early-stage play in a sector ripe for rediscovery.

In the end, the question isn't whether BRBS is perfect—it isn't. But in the world of under-followed regional banks, perfection isn't the goal. Sustainability, discipline, and adaptability are. And on those counts, BRBS is showing promise.
"""