Bitcoin News Today: Crypto Treasury Premiums Teeter Between Collapse and Stability Amid Fading Bitcoin Volatility

The modified net asset value (mNAV) premiums of crypto treasury firms are facing heightened scrutiny amid shifting market dynamics, with investors and analysts closely monitoring whether the trend will collapse or stabilize. While no widespread collapse has been confirmed, the premiums-measured as the ratio of a company's enterprise value to the value of its cryptocurrency holdings-remain fragile, dependent on capital engineering, market trust, and Bitcoin's volatility.

Digital asset treasuries (DATs) have seen mNAV compression since June 2025, driven by market saturation, investor caution, and unsustainable business models, according to Standard Chartered. The bank noted that mNAV suppression is particularly acute for smaller firms, with larger players like Strategy (MSTR) and Bitmine (BMNR) better positioned due to lower-cost funding and staking yields. Meanwhile, NYDIG's Greg Cipolaro highlighted that investor anxiety over supply unlocks, profit-taking, and lack of differentiation are further eroding premiums.

Bitcoin's volatility, which has declined to multi-year lows, is another critical factor. The flattening volatility curve has reduced opportunities for treasury companies to generate returns above their underlying holdings, pushing mNAV toward 1.25, a level that suggests investors are questioning the value proposition of these firms. This trend is compounded by a 97% drop in monthly BTC purchases by treasury firms since November 2024, signaling a cautious market approach.

MetaPlanet, often dubbed "Japan's MicroStrategy," exemplifies the tension between premium sustainability and operational risks. Despite a -73% drawdown in its stock price and an mNAV near 1, analysts argue its aggressive Bitcoin accumulation and unique Japanese funding mechanisms justify its premium. The company's BTC holdings have grown at a steeper rate than most peers, with 6,796 BTC in its treasury. However, critics like Charles Edwards warn of "convergence risk," where mNAV trends toward 1 over time, aligning stock prices with the intrinsic value of Bitcoin holdings.

Strategy, the largest corporate Bitcoin holder with 607,770 BTC, maintains a premium due to its early accumulation, institutional access, and regulatory clarity. Its mNAV has fluctuated between 1.91x and 3.89x in 2025, reflecting investor reassessment of its capital structure and role as a Bitcoin exposure vehicle. The firm's ability to raise capital through preferred shares and convertible notes-while diluting existing shareholders-has allowed it to maintain a Bitcoin-per-share ratio that outpaces many rivals.

Regulatory clarity remains a double-edged sword. While the GENIUS Act's passage in July 2025 provided some legislative certainty, the absence of a finalized Anti-CBDC Act leaves ambiguity about the future of digital assets. Additionally, the proliferation of spot Bitcoin ETFs, including BlackRock's IBIT and Fidelity's FBTC, has introduced cheaper alternatives for Bitcoin exposure, potentially pressuring mNAV premiums.

Forbes' Korok Ray proposed a new valuation metric-Market-to-Fair Book Value (MFBV)-to account for debt and provide a clearer picture of downside risk. Under this framework, Metaplanet's MFBV is negative, indicating that its debt exceeds the value of its Bitcoin holdings, a red flag for equity holders in bankruptcy scenarios.

The future of mNAV premiums hinges on Bitcoin's volatility and macroeconomic factors. A rebound in volatility could reignite investor enthusiasm, allowing treasury companies to capitalize on price swings and justify higher multiples. Conversely, prolonged low volatility may push investors toward direct Bitcoin exposure, bypassing corporate structures.

Regulatory developments will also play a pivotal role. As the Federal Reserve's dovish pivot and potential rate cuts loom, the "Fed put"-where central banks cushion asset markets during downturns-may further bolster Bitcoin's appeal as a store of value. However, this dynamic could also exacerbate moral hazard, encouraging risk-taking without accountability.

For now, the crypto treasury sector remains a test of resilience. Firms with robust capital engineering, diversified strategies, and regulatory agility are best positioned to weather the storm. Yet, as Standard Chartered noted, consolidation is inevitable, with larger players likely to acquire weaker rivals in a bid to maintain market dominance.

---

Source: [1] This is the Full Title of the First News Article (https://coinlineup.com/modified-nav-premiums-crypto-scrutiny/)

[2] Understanding Premiums to NAV as Crypto Treasury Companies Proliferate (https://www.nydig.com/research/understanding-premiums-to-nav-as-crypto-treasury-companies-proliferate)

[3] Digital Asset Treasuries Face mNAV Collapse, Standard Chartered ... (https://cointelegraph.com/news/digital-asset-treasuries-mnav-collapse-standard-chartered)

[4] Bitcoin Treasury Premium Value Sinks: Eroding mNAV After 97 (https://www.coin-views.com/2025/09/bitcoin-treasury-premium-value-sinks.html)

[5] Why MetaPlanet Is Still Undervalued-Despite the Hype (https://insights.mnav.com/why-metaplanet-is-still-undervalued-despite-the-hype/)

[6] Metaplanet -73% Drawdown and mNAV Near 1: Charles Edwards ... (https://blockchain.news/flashnews/metaplanet-73-drawdown-and-mnav-near-1-charles-edwards-highlights-infrequent-btc-buys-and-convergence-risk)

[7] Why mNAV Matters: Understanding Bitcoin Treasury Premiums (https://www.blockspaceforce.com/research/bitcoin-treasury-stocks-mnav-premium-explained)

[8] Is the mNAV Worth It? Introducing "Days to Cover mNAV" (https://insights.mnav.com/is-the-mnav-worth-it-introducing-days-to-cover-mnav/)

[9] Why MSTR Trades at a Premium: Inside Strategy's ... (https://www.ccn.com/education/crypto/strategy-stock-mnav-premium-explained/)

[10] A New Way To Value Bitcoin Treasury Companies (https://www.forbes.com/sites/digital-assets/2025/07/11/a-new-way-to-value-bitcoin-treasury-companies/)