e.l.f. Beauty’s Controversial Campaign Backfires Stock Dives 3.16% as $210M Volume Ranks 455th

On August 19, 2025, e.l.f. Beauty (ELF) closed with a 3.16% decline, its shares trading at $0.21 billion in volume, ranking 455th in market activity. The drop followed intense backlash against the company’s latest advertising campaign featuring comedian Matt Rife, which sparked significant social media criticism. The campaign, co-starring drag queen Heidi N Closet in a satirical legal-themed ad, faced widespread condemnation for Rife’s past remarks about domestic abuse during a 2023 stand-up special. Influencers and users criticized the brand for overlooking Rife’s controversial history, with some calling out the decision as tone-deaf. The company issued an apology, acknowledging the campaign “missed the mark” for its audience. Chief Marketing Officer Kory Marchisotto cited demographic alignment with Rife’s TikTok following—75% under 34 and 80% female—as a rationale for the partnership, though the campaign’s negative reception highlighted risks in real-time cultural marketing strategies.

The incident underscores the volatility of brand reputation in social media-driven markets. Despite e.l.f.’s emphasis on real-time engagement, the campaign’s fallout revealed gaps between perceived audience reception and actual public sentiment. The company’s admission of error and withdrawal of the ad reflect broader challenges in balancing humor with sensitivity in influencer-driven campaigns. While e.l.f. has not disclosed financial impacts from the controversy, the stock’s sharp decline indicates investor concerns over brand equity and customer trust. The episode also raises questions about due diligence in selecting brand ambassadors, particularly for companies targeting socially conscious demographics.

The strategy of buying the top 500 stocks by daily trading volume and holding them for one day from 2022 to now delivered moderate returns. The 1-day return was 0.98%, with a total return of 31.52% over 365 days. This indicates the strategy captured some short-term momentum but also reflected market volatility and potential timing risks.