Backblaze Under the Microscope: Navigating Fraud Allegations and Investor Risks

In the ever-volatile world of tech stocks, few stories capture attention like a high-profile securities fraud investigation. backblaze, Inc. (NASDAQ: BLZE), a cloud storage provider, has found itself at the center of such a controversy after the Pomerantz Law Firm launched an inquiry into potential financial misconduct. Let’s dissect the claims, the company’s rebuttals, and what this means for investors.

The Allegations: A Short Seller’s Play or Legitimate Fraud?

On April 24, 2025, Morpheus Research published a scathing report accusing Backblaze of “sham accounting,” improper capitalization of expenses, and misleading disclosures to inflate its stock price. The report highlighted:
- Aggressive insider stock sales: Executives allegedly sold shares post-IPO, coinciding with a 76% drop in BLZE’s price by late 2022.
- Inflated cash flow forecasts: Former finance executives claim they were pressured to certify inaccurate financial statements.
- Growing losses: Backblaze reported a $48.5 million net loss in Q4 2024, following a $59.7 million loss in 2023, with shares rising 80% since its 2021 IPO—a red flag for valuation sustainability.

The result? BLZE’s stock plummeted during intraday trading on April 24, prompting Pomerantz to investigate whether executives misled investors.

Backblaze’s Defense: “Baseless” Claims or a Valid Pushback?

The company hit back swiftly. In multiple statements, Vice President of Marketing Patrick Thomas called the report “baseless, inaccurate, and misleading” and attributed it to short sellers seeking to manipulate the stock. Key points from their rebuttal:
1. Third-party validation: Backblaze claims independent reviews confirm its financial disclosures are accurate.
2. Operational stability: Thomas emphasized that its cloud storage services remain reliable, countering fears from outlets like How-To Geek that financial woes could jeopardize customer data.
3. Legal stance: The company denies ties between its financial disclosures and lawsuits filed by former employees, including ex-finance head Huey Hall and ex-Vice President James Kisner.

However, Backblaze sidestepped addressing the core financial metrics: its $108.2 million cumulative losses over two years and a stock price down 71% since its IPO.

The Legal Landscape: Class Action Risks and Investor Fallout

Pomerantz’s investigation is not flying solo. The Rosen Law Firm and The Schall Law Firm have also launched probes, urging investors who sold BLZE at a loss to come forward. This raises two critical questions:
- Will class actions succeed? Pomerantz’s track record includes multimillion-dollar recoveries, but Backblaze’s denial and lack of admitted wrongdoing complicate claims.
- How will the stock react? BLZE’s volatility is extreme—investors must weigh the risk of further declines against the possibility of a legal win boosting confidence.

Data-Driven Analysis: The Numbers Tell a Story

Let’s break down the metrics:
- Revenue Growth: BLZE’s revenue grew from $246 million in 2021 to $298 million in 2024—a 21% increase over three years. However, net losses have outpaced revenue growth, raising sustainability concerns.
- Valuation: With a market cap of ~$300 million (as of April 2025) and heavy losses, Backblaze’s valuation appears stretched unless it turns profitable.
- Share Dilution: The 80% increase in shares outstanding since 2021 suggests repeated fundraising efforts to cover losses—a red flag for dilution risks.

The Bottom Line: Proceed with Extreme Caution

Investors face a binary outcome:
1. Fraud allegations are upheld: BLZE could face fines, investor lawsuits, and further stock declines.
2. Backblaze is exonerated: The stock might rebound, but its losses and valuation cloud long-term appeal.

Key takeaways:
- Risk/Reward: BLZE’s current price reflects significant downside risk. Only speculative investors with high risk tolerance should consider it.
- Watch Q1 2025 Results: Due May 7, 2025, these results could validate or refute Morpheus’ claims about cash flow and expenses.
- Legal Outcomes: If lawsuits are dismissed, the stock might stabilize. If not, prepare for more volatility.

In conclusion, Backblaze’s journey is a cautionary tale of tech startups balancing growth and profitability. While the company insists its books are clean, the data paints a picture of a struggling business under legal siege. For now, BLZE remains a high-risk play—investors should proceed with eyes wide open and portfolios diversified.

JR Research disclaims any liability for the content above. Always consult a financial advisor before making investment decisions.

Ask Aime: "Could Backblaze's SEC investigation affect tech stock valuations?"