Avis Budget Group's Valuation and Earnings Discrepancy: A Goldman Sachs Downgrade as Opportunity or Warning?

The recent downgrade of Avis Budget Group (NASDAQ: CAR) by Goldman Sachs from “Neutral” to “Sell” has sent ripples through the investment community. The move, coupled with a revised price target of $105—implying a 38% decline from the current stock price of $164.07—raises critical questions for long-term investors. Is this a warning sign of deeper structural issues, or does it signal a mispriced opportunity in a company poised to reshape the future of mobility?

The Valuation Puzzle: Cheap or Broken?

Avis's valuation metrics tell a story of extremes. Its price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio is effectively zero, a result of its recent earnings shortfall. The company reported Q2 2025 earnings of $0.10 per share—far below the expected $2.02—and posted a negative net margin of 19.06%. Meanwhile, its price-to-book (P/B) ratio is incoherent, as the company's book value per share is negative ($-78). Even the price-to-sales (P/S) ratio of 0.5 appears absurdly low compared to peers like DHL (14.29 P/E) and Kuehne & Nagel (18.12 P/E).

These metrics suggest Avis is either undervalued or fundamentally broken. The former is plausible if the company's strategic initiatives—such as its partnership with Waymo—can unlock new revenue streams. The latter is a risk if the earnings slump persists.

Earnings Slump: A Symptom or a Disease?

The Q2 2025 earnings report was a wake-up call. Revenue fell 0.3% year-over-year to $3.0 billion, and adjusted EBITDA, while up 29% to $277 million, couldn't offset a 71% drop in net income. Operating expenses ballooned to $1.526 billion, driven by restructuring charges, interest costs, and legal fees. The Americas segment, which accounts for the bulk of Avis's business, saw a 2% decline in revenue per rental day to $70.03, despite stable rental volumes.

The International segment, however, showed promise: Revenue per day rose 7% to $60.74, and Adjusted EBITDA surged 71% to $82 million. This divergence highlights the complexity of Avis's global operations. While the Americas struggle with pricing pressure and competition, the International segment demonstrates the potential for growth in markets with less saturation.

Historical data reveals a nuanced pattern when CAR misses earnings expectations. From 2022 to the present, the stock has shown a 66.67% win rate in the 3 days following an earnings miss, rising to 100% over 10 days and stabilizing at 66.67% over 30 days. Notably, the stock has delivered a maximum return of 12.81% on August 8, 2025, after an earnings miss. While short-term volatility persists, these results suggest that the market has historically priced in recovery potential after earnings underperformance.

Strategic Moves: Innovation or Overreach?

Goldman Sachs's downgrade may overlook the long-term value of Avis's strategic bets. The partnership with Waymo to launch autonomous ride-hailing in Dallas by 2026 is a bold pivot from traditional rentals to fleet management for self-driving networks. Avis's role as a “fence operator”—managing infrastructure, maintenance, and depots—leverages its 75-year expertise in fleet logistics without requiring it to develop autonomous technology itself. This low-risk, high-growth play positions Avis to monetize the autonomous mobility boom, a market projected to reach $2 trillion by 2030.

Additionally, Avis's launch of “Avis First,” a premium rental service with curbside convenience and luxury vehicles, targets a more lucrative customer segment. While these initiatives are nascent, they align with broader trends toward premiumization and tech-driven convenience in the mobility sector.

Market Dynamics: A Battle for Survival

The rental car industry is in flux. Post-pandemic, demand has been volatile, with economic uncertainty and inflation dampening travel. Avis faces competition from legacy rivals like Hertz and Enterprise, as well as disruptors like Tesla's FSD (Full Self-Driving) and Uber's electric vehicle partnerships. Meanwhile, the rise of car-sharing platforms and electric vehicle (EV) adoption is reshaping customer expectations.

Avis's response has been pragmatic: Refinancing debt, extending loan maturities, and maintaining $950 million in liquidity. These moves strengthen its balance sheet, but they don't address the root issue—profitability. The company's return on equity of -14.74% is a red flag, suggesting it's destroying value for shareholders.

The Goldman Sachs Dilemma: Bearish or Myopic?

Goldman Sachs's downgrade is rooted in short-term concerns: declining earnings, weak margins, and a challenging operating environment. However, the firm's $105 price target assumes Avis's current trajectory continues, ignoring the potential upside from its Waymo partnership and Avis First. Deutsche Bank's $196 target, by contrast, reflects optimism about these strategic plays.

The broader analyst consensus—a “Hold” rating with an average target of $131.20—suggests a middle ground. Investors must decide whether to bet on Avis's ability to execute its long-term vision or on the likelihood that its near-term struggles will dominate.

Investment Implications: Risk vs. Reward

For long-term investors, Avis presents a classic value trap scenario. The stock's low valuation could be a discount if the company turns its earnings around, but it could also be a warning of deeper issues. Key risks include:
- Execution risk: Can Avis scale its Waymo partnership profitably?
- Market risk: Will autonomous mobility adoption accelerate faster than expected?
- Financial risk: Can Avis sustain its debt refinancing strategy amid rising interest rates?

Conversely, the rewards are significant. If Avis successfully transitions to a fleet management and mobility solutions provider, its valuation could re-rate from a P/S of 0.5 to a more industry-appropriate 1.5 or higher, implying a $176.70 stock price.

Conclusion: A Calculated Gamble

Goldman Sachs's downgrade is a cautionary signal, but not a death knell. Avis's valuation is undeniably low, but its strategic moves into autonomous mobility and premium services offer a path to long-term growth. For investors with a five- to ten-year horizon, the stock could be a compelling opportunity—if they're willing to stomach the volatility.

However, the risks are non-trivial. Investors should consider hedging their positions with short-term puts or allocating only a small portion of their portfolio to Avis. The key is to monitor the company's execution of its strategic initiatives and its ability to stabilize earnings.

In the end, Avis Budget Group is a case study in the tension between traditional business models and the future of mobility. For those who believe in its vision, the current discount may be a rare chance to buy in at the ground floor. For others, the Goldman Sachs downgrade is a timely reminder that not all cheap stocks are good investments.
"""