Aon's 235th-Ranked $430M Volume Stock Faces Lawsuit Over Collateral Protection Insurance Scheme

Aon (AON) rose 0.18% on August 15, 2025, with a trading volume of $430 million, ranking 235th in the market. The stock’s performance coincided with a high-profile lawsuit filed by the Vesttoo Creditors Liquidating Trust, which alleges misconduct in Aon’s collateral protection insurance (CPI) program tied to fraudulent intellectual property (IP) lending. The complaint claims Aon’s CPI structure, designed to enable IP-rich companies to borrow against their assets, relied on unreliable valuations and forged letters of credit (LOCs) that contributed to Vesttoo’s collapse in 2023.

The lawsuit accuses Aon of pushing risky CPI deals to Vesttoo while internal communications reportedly expressed concerns about valuing pre-revenue IP and lending practices. Aon has denied the allegations, calling the case a “perverse attempt” to shift blame for Vesttoo’s fraud. The broker emphasized that Vesttoo’s own investigation implicated its executives and “co-conspirators,” vowing to defend against “meritless claims.” The dispute highlights growing scrutiny over collateral verification and valuation governance in insurtech and capital markets, with potential ripple effects on industry standards for IP-backed financing.

Industry observers note that court rulings in Delaware’s bankruptcy proceedings could reshape collateralized reinsurance and ILS-adjacent markets. Enhanced due diligence on LOCs, tighter borrower criteria, and clearer valuation protocols may emerge as key themes. Aon’s role in the CPI model, which initially aimed to open new asset classes for lenders, now faces reputational and operational risks. The case also underscores the fragility of innovation in risk transfer models, where unverified collateral and opaque governance can lead to systemic losses for insurers and reinsurers.

The strategy of buying the top 500 stocks by daily trading volume and holding them for one day from 2022 to now delivered moderate returns. The total profit grew steadily over the period, with a few fluctuations due to market dynamics. As of the latest data, the strategy's total profit stands at $10,720.