Analyst Frenzy Surrounds Circle (CRCL) as Valuation Debate Heats Up

Circle (CRCL), the stablecoin issuer behind USDC and one of the most hyped IPOs of 2025, became the center of analyst attention Monday as multiple Wall Street firms initiated coverage. The stock, which debuted at $31 on June 5, has soared to nearly $300 following favorable legislative developments and speculative fervor. Now, the analyst community is weighing in — and not everyone agrees on whether the gains are justified.

WATCH: You’re Being Played — This Market Rally Is a Setup

Bernstein was among the most bullish voices, initiating CRCL with an Outperform rating and a $230 price target. The firm sees Circle as a foundational piece of the next-generation financial system, describing it as a “must-hold” for investors. Bernstein highlighted Circle’s regulatory edge, liquidity position, and marquee distribution partners as nearly impossible to replicate. Their long-term thesis envisions the stablecoin market ballooning from roughly $225 billion today to $4 trillion over the next decade, with USDC evolving from a crypto-native tool to the money-rail of the broader internet.

Barclays echoed a similarly optimistic tone, initiating with an Overweight rating and a $215 target. Analyst Ramsey El-Assal argued Circle represents one of the only pure-play public vehicles for exposure to blockchain’s intersection with traditional finance. While stablecoin usage today remains mostly siloed within crypto, Barclays believes we are approaching an inflection point — driven by regulatory clarity, dollar demand abroad, and blockchain integration in payments and remittances.

Needham followed suit, assigning a Buy rating and a $250 target. Their note framed Circle as a company with paradigm-shifting potential, akin to Tesla or leading AI names. They expect Circle to dominate as a “reserve asset” in decentralized finance (DeFi), particularly as the GENIUS Act kicks in, incentivizing onshore and compliant stablecoin usage. Needham also pointed to Circle’s fixed-cost model and embedded operating leverage as reasons to support a high-growth multiple.

Not everyone, however, is eager to chase the stock near $300.

JPMorgan offered a notably more cautious view, initiating Underweight with an $80 price target — a figure implying over 70% downside from recent highs. While acknowledging Circle’s early-mover advantage and management quality, JPM cited its current market cap as stretched. The firm expressed concern about competition, particularly as tokenized deposit accounts and new entrants crowd the digital dollar space. They warned that Circle's moat, while impressive, may not hold as regulatory and commercial frameworks evolve.

Similarly, Goldman Sachs weighed in with a Neutral rating and an $83 target. The firm praised Circle’s unique positioning in bridging crypto and fiat systems without the volatility of traditional cryptocurrencies, but flagged valuation as a key overhang. Goldman’s view was that the growth outlook remains healthy, but much of it is already priced in.

Oppenheimer, for its part, took a middle ground. It launched coverage with a Perform rating and no price target, expressing enthusiasm about the company’s fundamentals and USDC’s role in transforming capital markets and payments. However, the firm signaled hesitation due to valuation, noting the meteoric rise from $31 to $180 within four weeks made them cautious on near-term upside.

Amid the flurry of analyst commentary, one of the more closely watched signals came not from a brokerage but from ARK Invest. According to Lookonchain, Cathie Wood’s flagship innovation fund continued to unload shares of Circle into strength, selling another $51.8 million in recent days. In total, ARK offloaded over 342,000 shares since the IPO while redeploying capital into Coinbase (COIN) and Robinhood (HOOD). The selling pressure, while not necessarily a condemnation, has raised eyebrows given ARK’s history of supporting high-growth disruptors — and cutting positions when upside becomes too speculative.

Valuation is the crux of the analyst debate. The stock has pulled back from $298 and is testing support at the $175 area in pre-market trade. Even those with long-term enthusiasm for stablecoin adoption — such as Bernstein and Needham — acknowledge that near-term price action may be running ahead of fundamentals. USDC has a market share of 24% among stablecoins and a market cap of ~$62 billion, but its fee-based revenue model, regulatory exposure, and capital efficiency still raise questions about scalability and profitability.

For investors watching from the sidelines, key areas to monitor include: adoption trends in cross-border payments and remittances, regulatory developments like the GENIUS Act and global stablecoin frameworks, competitive encroachment from banks or decentralized protocols, and ARK’s ongoing trading behavior. Circle’s potential as a keystone of the digital dollar economy is significant — but so are the expectations already priced into the stock.

As Wall Street sorts itself into bulls and bears, one thing is clear: CRCL is now a battleground name.