The Allure of Defensive Investing in Gold: Evaluating U.S. Global Investors' Dividend Resilience

In an era of macroeconomic uncertainty, defensive investing has regained prominence. For income-focused investors, the gold sector—long a haven during market stress—offers a unique proposition. U.S. Global Investors (NASDAQ: GROW), a manager of gold and precious metals ETFs, has carved out a niche with its consistent monthly dividend policy. As of September 2025, GROW's annualized dividend of $0.09 per share yields 3.49%, outpacing the Financial Services sector average of 2.75%GROW - U S Global Investors stock dividend history, payout ratio^[4]. This article examines whether GROW's dividend resilience, despite structural challenges, makes it a compelling case for defensive investing in the gold sector.

Gold Sector Dynamics: Volatility and Structural Tailwinds

The gold market in Q3 2025 has been a study in contrasts. A 25-basis-point Federal Reserve rate cut in September initially drove gold to an intraday high of $3,707 per ounce, only for prices to retreat to $3,668.27 within hoursGold outlook Q3 2025^[2]. This volatility underscores the sector's sensitivity to monetary policy. Yet, structural demand from central banks—particularly in emerging markets—has provided a floor. Q1 2025 saw net purchases of 244 tonnes, the second-highest first-quarter total on recordGold outlook Q3 2025^[2]. Analysts argue that gold's role as a diversification tool against dollar weakness and geopolitical risks ensures its relevance, even amid short-term swingsExamining the gold price rally | Outlook and forecast | Lombard Odier^[5].

For GROW, which manages the U.S. Global GO GOLD and Precious Metal Miners ETF (GOAU), these dynamics are a double-edged sword. While gold's price swings create near-term uncertainty, the ETF's exposure to mining companies—many of which operate with all-in sustaining costs around $1,500 per ounce—has generated robust profit margins as spot prices exceed $3,000U.S. Global Investors (GROW) Dividend History, Dates & Yield^[1]. This margin expansion has been critical to sustaining GROW's dividend, even as the company reported a net loss of $382,000 in Q3 2025U.S. Global Investors Reports Results for the Third Quarter^[3].

Dividend Resilience: A Mixed Picture

GROW's dividend policy is its most compelling feature. Since 2007, the company has maintained monthly payouts, with the September 2025 ex-dividend date marking another $0.008 per share distributionU.S. Global Investors (GROW) Stock Dividend History & Growth^[6]. Annualized, this yields 3.49%, a figure that has remained stable despite the company's negative payout ratio of -692.31%GROW - U S Global Investors stock dividend history, payout ratio^[4]. Such a ratio—where dividends far exceed earnings—raises sustainability concerns. Yet, GROW's liquidity position softens this risk. As of March 2025, the firm held $26.3 million in cash and cash equivalents, alongside a conservative debt-to-equity ratio of 0.06Gold outlook Q3 2025^[2]. This liquidity buffer, combined with a current ratio of 21.7:1, suggests the company can weather short-term earnings shortfallsU.S. Global Investors (GROW) Stock Dividend History & Growth^[6].

A backtest of GROW's ex-dividend dates from 2022 to 2025 reveals that while the stock's dividend resilience is notable, its price performance around these events has been mixed. Over the first 10 trading days post-ex-dividend, the average return was -0.3%, slightly outperforming the benchmark's -0.6% but without statistical significance. However, from day +20 onward, the stock showed outsized positive returns (e.g., +5.6% at +20 days), though the small sample size (three events in 2025) limits the reliability of these findingsBacktest of GROW’s ex-dividend dates (2022–2025)^[7]. This suggests that while the dividend provides a steady income, investors should be cautious about relying on short-term price performance around ex-dividend dates.

The dividend's appeal is further amplified by its consistency. While GROW's Dividend Growth Potential Score (DGPS) remains stagnant, its track record of uninterrupted payments since 2007 is rare in the volatile ETF management spaceExamining the gold price rally | Outlook and forecast | Lombard Odier^[5]. For income investors, this predictability is invaluable, especially in a market where traditional yield sources like bonds have been compressed by accommodative monetary policy.

Strategic Moves and Long-Term Viability

GROW's management has not been idle in addressing its financial challenges. The company has repurchased 801,043 shares at a net cost of $2 million over the past yearU.S. Global Investors Reports Results for the Third Quarter^[3], signaling confidence in its intrinsic value. Simultaneously, it has expanded its exposure to Bitcoin and HIVE Digital Technologies, betting on the growing intersection of digital assets and traditional commoditiesU.S. Global Investors Reports Results for the Third Quarter^[3]. While these moves introduce new risks, they also diversify GROW's revenue streams beyond gold, potentially insulating it from sector-specific downturns.

The launch of the WAR ETF, focused on technology and aerospace & defense, further illustrates this strategyGROW - U S Global Investors stock dividend history, payout ratio^[4]. With global defense spending rising, this ETF taps into a trend that could provide stable inflows. However, the success of these initiatives will depend on execution and market appetite—a wildcard for long-term dividend sustainability.

Conclusion: A Defensive Play with Caveats

U.S. Global Investors presents a paradox: a high-yield dividend supported by weak earnings but bolstered by strong liquidity and sector tailwinds. For defensive investors, the key question is whether the company's cash reserves and strategic pivots can offset its negative payout ratio. While the risk of a dividend cut remains, the gold sector's structural demand—driven by central bank purchases and inflationary pressures—provides a floor. Investors willing to accept the volatility inherent in the sector may find GROW's 3.49% yield, combined with its defensive positioning, a compelling trade-off.

As the Fed's policy trajectory remains uncertain and geopolitical tensions persist, gold's role as a safe-haven asset is unlikely to wane. For GROW, the challenge will be to balance its dividend commitments with the need for reinvestment and growth. In this context, the company's ability to maintain its payout while navigating a complex macroeconomic landscape will be the ultimate test of its defensive credentials.