49-Year-Old Ex-CEO of Camp for Sick Kids Charged with Embezzling Over $50 Million from Paul Newman-Founded Nonprofit

Christopher L. Butler, a 49-year-old former CEO of The Painted Turtle, a camp for children with chronic or life-threatening illnesses, has been charged with embezzling over $5.2 million from the nonprofit over a seven-year period. The charges were announced by Los Angeles County prosecutors, who emphasized the severity of stealing from an organization that serves vulnerable children. Butler is expected to be arraigned in Los Angeles on Thursday.

The Painted Turtle, co-founded by the late actor Paul Newman, provides free programs to children with serious medical conditions. The camp relies entirely on donations to fund its operations. Prosecutors allege that Butler, who served as both CEO and controller for part of his tenure, used his position to misappropriate funds and alter or delete financial records to conceal the theft.

Los Angeles County District Attorney Nathan J. Hochman stated that stealing from organizations that serve vulnerable members of the community is a grave offense. Hochman emphasized the district attorney's office will hold such actions fully accountable under the law.

Why the Move Happened

The embezzlement came to light in August 2025 when a new controller at The Painted Turtle discovered financial irregularities. Prosecutors said Butler allegedly stole hundreds of thousands of dollars each year, with the total amount reaching about $5.2 million over the period from 2018 to 2025.

Butler worked for The Painted Turtle from 2018 until the summer of 2025. During that time, he held multiple roles, including controller, allowing him to manipulate financial records to hide the theft.

What Analysts Are Watching

The charges could have lasting implications for The Painted Turtle and similar nonprofit organizations. The case highlights the importance of internal audits and oversight in preventing financial misconduct.

Nonprofits like The Painted Turtle typically rely on donor trust and transparency. If a nonprofit is found to have been mismanaged or misused funds, it could impact future donations and public perception.

Analysts are also watching the broader implications for leadership roles in nonprofit organizations. A lack of oversight or internal checks can lead to significant financial losses, especially when the organization serves a vulnerable population.

What Comes Next for the Organization

The Painted Turtle has not yet responded to requests for comment on the charges. A public defender who previously represented Butler declined to speak on the matter, stating she no longer handles his case.

Butler faces 15 felony charges, with a potential prison sentence of more than 18 years if convicted. The case will proceed through the judicial process, and the outcome could determine the extent of restitution and the long-term impact on the nonprofit's operations.

The Painted Turtle's role in providing free programs to children with chronic illnesses is vital to its mission. The nonprofit must now address the breach of trust and ensure that such incidents do not recur.